Progress report for FNE24-100
Project Information
The primary objective of this proposal is for a network of small farmers in the Hudson Valley of New York to continue to work together to evaluate annual white-grain sorghum for crop yield and soil health. We are selecting five farms for this study with conditions, priorities, and needs distinctive from each other, allowing us to document a range of approaches for growing sorghum and serve as case studies in a final report. From this experience, we will be able to outline priorities for future research and investments. Sharing our process, from planting to market along with successes and failures, will support other small farmers to grow sorghum and help expand the New York Grainshed. We will continue to collect data at regular intervals
with our suite of off-the-shelf tools for soil health assessment, and simultaneously sample soil and plants for analysis at two professional labs. This aids us in our secondary objective: to verify the accuracy of the Carbon Sponge Kit and make data collection recommendations for farmers wanting to balance crop yield and soil health. We will draft preliminary best practices for regenerative sorghum production in our region that is backed by farmer experience and data.
The Carbon Sponge Hub at White Feather Farm in Saugerties, NY, is supporting small farms in the Hudson Valley of New York trial climate-smart crops within a regenerative framework and employ off-the-shelf tools for self-monitoring soil. This is a farm-led initiative and a peer-to-peer farmer network for learning, sharing, and evaluating agroecological practices. With climate emergency a reality and not some far-off scenario, we are moving to adopt crops that can thrive despite extreme weather fluctuations, serve as a staple food for local populations, and last in storage for several years or more. Farmers need to balance managing crops through unpredictable weather while also cultivating soil for the future. Since 2021, we have grown white-grain annual sorghum across ten small farms and are excited by its potential to support food and soil security in our region. The focus of this grant is to continue to trial and evaluate sorghum while also validating our suite of soil-monitoring tools.
Sorghum, an ancient grain from East Africa where it remains a staple food, is heat-loving, drought-tolerant, and grows in many soil types. It has deep roots and produces a large amount of above-ground biomass, factors that increase potential for soil carbon storage. It is also a C4 plant, meaning it uses light, water, and nutrients more efficiently than most crops to fix carbon dioxide. For all these reasons, it is considered an important climate-smart crop. Sorghum can be harvested for its grain as well as its stalk juice (which can be evaporated into syrup), making it a valuable dual-purpose crop. Sorghum is not common in the Northeast, and when it is grown, farmers often use it for silage or select sorghum sudangrass for summer cover crop. The U.S. is the top sorghum producer and exporter in the world, but production mostly occurs in Kansas and Texas, and a large portion of the grain is exported to China for animal feed (Sawe; “Foreign Demand”).
There is significant opportunity to grow sorghum in new regions of the U.S., like the Hudson Valley, to take advantage of the plant’s ability to adapt to a wide range of conditions, provide ecosystem services on farms, including increasing soil organic carbon, while generating revenue. Rather than focusing on industrial scale or global revenue streams, a farmer in the Hudson Valley can integrate sorghum into a market garden and sell directly to consumers through existing farmer’s markets and CSAs. Small farmers can pool their harvests to sell in larger quantities to local bakers, restaurants, and breweries. In Heather Coiner’s “Growing Grain Handbook,” she describes the industrial consolidation of grain farming in the U.S. and challenges for smaller scale operations, but also points to opportunities for small farmers who clean, bag, and market their grain directly to a baker-miller. They can charge 6-10 times the price than if sold straight from the field and double that if sold at a farmer’s market. Entering the grain market is possible for small farmers who leverage higher prices and partners with neighboring farmers (2-4).
With the support of a Farmer Grant, we will document a year of sorghum production at five Hub farms from field preparation and planting through harvest to market. We will trial the same varieties, enabling us to consolidate harvest, and share specialized equipment, yet each farm has different physical conditions, cultivation preferences and individual needs making their story unique. We are focused on white-seeded grain sorghum because it is more palatable and nutritious than colored grains with higher tannins. We will produce a final report with five case studies to share with other small farmers interested in growing cover crops as a cash crop and entering grain production. We will outline where we think future research and investments are needed to grow and sell sorghum successfully in our region.
In addition, the grant will support the continuation and validation of our on-farm testing with the Carbon Sponge Kit. Alongside farmer testing, we will send soil and plant samples to the Cary Institute of Ecosystems Services and Logan Labs, organizations with which we already work. In consultation with Dr. Perl Egendorf, we will analyze results and evaluate the accuracy and usefulness of the Kit. We will make recommendations for specific tests and targets for farmers interested in regenerative sorghum production taking into consideration ease of use, labor, and costs. We aim to better define how sorghum is climate-smart in our region and provide recommendations for incorporating annual sorghum on small farms with equal emphasis on crop yield and soil health.
Cooperators
- (Researcher)
- - Producer
- (Researcher)
- - Technical Advisor
- - Producer
- - Producer
- - Producer
Research
One of this project’s main goals is the evaluation of a suite of a collection of off- the-shelf field monitoring tools (we refer to as the Carbon Sponge Kit) for gauging soil and plant health and potential for soil carbon storage. At the end of the project, we aim to verify the accuracy of the Carbon Sponge Kit and make data collection recommendations for farmers wanting to balance crop yield and soil health. The designated Carbon Sponge area on each of the Hub farms is divided into three equal parts and labeled Site #1-3.
We are testing every three months four times evenly spaced across 12 months. The first testing round was in May 2024, the second was in September 2024, and the third round was completed in January 2025. We are scheduling the fourth and final round in May 2025. The testing is conducted by the Carbon Sponge Team and sometimes with the farmer(s), as scheduling permits.
The Carbon Sponge Kit includes: the Microbiometer, Solvita CO2 Burst, penetrometer, pH and moisture probe, thermometer, and refractometer. The Microbiometer and Solvita tests are competing commercial tests on the market for evaluating soil health. The Microbiometer is a low-cost and quick field test for microbial biomass and fungal-to-bacterial ratio that uses extraction powder to separate microbes from soil particles and detect microbe pigmentation on a membrane. The Solvita CO2 Burst test is a low-cost test that calculates microbial biomass by measuring carbon dioxide respiration. We use a penetrometer to measure compaction. We also use two soil probes, one for temperature and one for pH and moisture. pH is also recorded in the professional lab. We use a refractometer on the sorghum stalk juice to measure for BRIX on the second testing round and at harvest time, measuring for dissolved sugar.
As part of the Kit testing, we record site conditions like weather, irrigation, and percent soil coverage. We document with photographs as well. The Carbon Sponge Field Technician works with each farmer on testing days, providing consistency across the farms and the project, and is responsible for uploading the data to a shared drive. Farmers add observations in a comment section which includes anything from a recent weather event or pest pressure to equipment failure.
Three soil samples are collected on each farm (from Site 1, 2 and 3) on the four designated testing days and delivered to our partner lab, the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, NY. We collect samples at 6” depth using a composite method of 3 samples per site. We also collect a sample for bulk density analysis from the three sites per farm. The tests at the Cary Institute, conducted by Dr. Peter Groffman’s lab, include carbon and nitrogen pools, microbial biomass carbon and nitrogen, potential net mineralization, potential net nitrification, respiration, and bulk density. These lab analyses use professional “gold standards” like the chloroform fumigation and incubation method to measure microbial biomass carbon and will be used to verify and measure the percent accuracy of our Kit results.
On testing day one we sent soil samples from each site on each farm to Logan Labs and will repeat on the fourth testing day in May 2025. These are also collected at 6" depth using the composite method. The soil tests at Logan include exchange capacity, percent soil organic matter, pH, nutrient levels, and soil texture. In mid-summer, we also sampled plant tissue to Logan Labs when the sorghum was beginning to bloom for analysis.
All of this data collected from May 2024 through May 2025 will be used to evaluate soil and sorghum plant health across the five Carbon Sponge Hub farms. Additionally, the comparison of the Kit and lab data will provide the basis for verification of the Kit tools and subsequent recommendations. The analysis and verification will be led by Dr. Perl Egendorf who will utilize a range of exploratory data analyses and statistical significance tests to understand relationships between soil properties, microbial community activities, and sorghum performance.
Education & Outreach Activities and Participation Summary
Participation Summary:
On July 27, 2024, Brooke Singer led a Carbon Sponge workshop at White Feather Farm in Saugerties, NY, during their one-day Soil Fest. During this 2.5-hour free, hands-on workshop, participants learned about the Carbon Sponge Hub and how to design a carbon sponge. Singer presented the Carbon Sponge Kit and demonstrated it in the field. There were 12 participants.
On September 14, 2024, also at White Feather Farm in Saugerties, NY, Carbon Sponge hosted a 3-hour workshop with Atina Foods of Catskill, NY. During this workshop, participants learned about our hub of small farmers collectively trialing climate-smart crops, like sorghum, and monitoring soil health. Then Atina Foods shared different ways to prepare sorghum grain to make sorghum dosas, roti, and other flatbreads of Indian origin. There were 25 participants and tickets were sliding scale from $0-20.
On October 5th, 2024, Carbon Sponge participated in Sweet Freedom Farm's sorghum harvest in Millerton, NY. Sweet Freedom Farm is currently one of the 5 Carbon Sponge Hub farms. Brooke Singer set up a table with the Carbon Sponge Kit, Guidebook, and handouts for people to learn about the project and how sorghum is climate-smart. She discussed with attendees what an agroecology framework is that centers sorghum and shared several DIY tools for testing soil and plants for soil and plant health. The audience was a mix of people interested in farming, food, and ecology, as well as experienced farmers. There were approximately 75 people in attendance.
Brooke Singer presented Carbon Sponge at a conference on June 25, 2024, in Windsor, Ontario, called FEMeeting: Women in Art, Science and Technology to an audience of 200. Brooke Singer also presented Carbon Sponge via online video conference to an art, science, and technology faculty research group (15 members) at the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) on August 26, 2024. Brooke Singer joined Northeast SARE's Candice Huber on August 1 for an online webinar titled "Soil Health and SARE Grants" hosted by Sullivan County's Cornell Cooperative Extension (CCE).
Forthcoming, Brooke Singer will present Carbon Sponge at CalTech for a one-day symposium, "Defining a Visual Practice Lab," that explores the essential role of diverse visual practices in driving innovative art-science-society collaborations. This symposium, originally scheduled for January 17th, 2025, has been postponed to April 11, 2025, due to the Los Angeles wildfires. Lastly, Brooke Singer will present Carbon Sponge at the Hudson Valley Grain School in Poughkeepsie, NY, on February 25, 2025, organized by Cornell Cooperative Extension and Glynwood Center for Regional Food and Farming.
There are two more Carbon Sponge Culinary Workshops scheduled for March 2025 with support provided by the Spark of Hudson. One will take place at Knead Love Bakery with Sarah Magid in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, with a focus on gluten-free baking with sorghum. The other will occur at the Brooklyn Granary and Mill in Gowanus, Brooklyn, with baker and grain researcher Katie Phelan. She will lead participants through methods and techniques for working with sorghum grain, syrup, and flour in pastry doughs and layered desserts. Brooke will present about the Carbon Sponge Hub and the climate-smart aspects of sorghum prior to the culinary artists' demonstrations at both events.
Press:
Making the Case for Sorghum, Ambrook Research, June 21, 2024
The Soil-obsessed Artist brings Sorghum to New York Farms, ScienceLine, October 21, 2024
Can an Ancient Grain Support Soil Health in New York, Times Union, April 1, 2024
Sequestering Carbon is not Just a Science but an Art Too, Modern Farmer, April 3, 2024
Learning Outcomes
Changes in knowledge, attitude, skill and/or awareness:
Annual sorghum as a climate-smart plant in New York;
Annual sorghum as a cash crop in New York for both grain and sap for human consumption;
Integration of grain in primarily diversified vegetable small farms;
Grain harvesting and processing techniques on a small scale;
On-farm, rapid field testing that is inexpensive yet informative for gauging soil and plant health;
Analyzing professional laboratory reports with the help of an agronomist;
Coupling soil and plant testing for an integrated, agroecological framework;
Strength of peer-to-peer farmer networks for problem-solving, equipment sharing, and increasing profitability through collective marketing of products.