Establishing a Silvopasture Site for Long-term Research, Education, and Livelihood

Progress report for FW24-010

Project Type: Farmer/Rancher
Funds awarded in 2024: $25,000.00
Projected End Date: 03/01/2027
Host Institution Award ID: G243-24-WA507
Grant Recipient: Sol Cycle Farm
Region: Western
State: Oregon
Principal Investigator:
Jason Bradford
Sol Cycle Farm
Expand All

Project Information

Summary:

As the climate becomes hotter,
dryer, and more variable, we face increasing heat stress on
livestock, less reliable growth of forage resources, and
ecosystem perturbations affecting a multitude of species. Animal
health and farm income are at risk with no quick solutions as
most ranches, following a history of tree and hedgerow removal to
enlarge fields, lack the vegetative structural diversity needed
for weather resilience. 

 

We propose silvopasture
development, i.e., the deliberate integration of trees into a
grazing system, using native plants to build vegetative
structure, improve livestock health, and support area
biodiversity. Our project will document installation techniques,
initial environmental, and biodiversity responses on a 10 acre
field in the Willamette Valley of Oregon. While the specific
plant species may be most relevant for inland valleys west of the
Cascades, many lessons should be broadly applicable. 

 

A silvopasture develops over
decades, yet many research questions can be asked at this phase
of the project. We are interested in the practice and cost of
establishment for native trees and shrubs, whether from cuttings
taken from nearby forests or purchased from nurseries. Our
experimental design allows for comparison of growth rates between
tree species. We expect early insight into crucial environmental
parameters, such as temperature differences between treatment and
control areas during heat waves, and changes in biodiversity
indicators in the soil, avifauna, and arthropod communities.
While trees take many years to reach full stature, by the end of
the study we may have at least one test of animal health impacts
by comparing groups of livestock kept in treatment vs control
environments (pending additional funding). 

 

We will conduct field days,
present at regional stakeholder meetings, publish in standard
outlets (e.g., Extension, NRCS), and use popular YouTube channels
and podcasts, to explain our project rationale and disseminate
our results.

Project Objectives:
  1. Secure the establishment of the silvopasture using native
    trees and shrubs on a seasonally wet field. 
  2. Install and learn to utilize fencing systems to protect new
    plantings. 
  3. Collect baseline data on plant growth rates, soils, climate,
    and biodiversity.
  4. Solidify collaboration with researchers and pursue additional
    funding.
  5. Potentially get early trials on animal health in control vs
    treatment areas during a heatwave.
  6. Take lessons learned and translate into updated guidelines
    through area stakeholders. 
  7. Have well attended field days of interest to both livestock
    managers, farmland managers, and environmental professionals.
  8. Produce outreach materials for talks and poster sessions at
    regional events.
  9. Gain wider audience from outlets such as YouTube and podcast
    channels. 
Timeline:

 

Date

Activities

Team Members

Mar-Sept, 2023

Bee traps deployed

PI-Jason, Andony Melathopoulos

May-July, 2023

Complete mulching

PI-Jason, Intern

May, 2024

Install weather station

PI-Jason

May-July, 2024

Breeding season bird survey

PI-Jason, William Kirsch

June-Aug, 2024

Graze and mow

PI-Jeremy, PI-Jason

July-Aug, 2024

Irrigate

PI-Jason, PI-Jeremy

Aug, 2024

Assess mortality

PI-Jason, Intern

Aug-Sept, 2024

Till and plant pasture

PI-Jason, Contractor

Nov, 2024

Replant as needed

PI-Jason, Intern

Dec, 2024-Feb, 2025

Winter season bird survey

PI-Jason, William Kirsch

Mar-Sept, 2025

Bee traps deployed

PI-Jason, Andony Melathopoulos

May-July, 2025

Breeding season bird survey

PI-Jason, William Kirsch

June, 2025

Soil sampling

TA-Jennifer Moore, PI-Jason, Intern

June-Oct, 2025

Graze

PI-Jeremy, PI-Jason

July-Sept, 2025

Irrigate

PI-Jason, PI-Jeremy

Dec, 2025-Feb, 2026

Winter season bird survey

PI-Jason, William Kirsch

Mar-Sept, 2026

Bee traps deployed

PI-Jason, Andony Melathopoulos

Mar-Oct, 2026

Video and drone footage documentation over season

PI-Jason, Andrew Millison

May-July, 2026

Breeding season bird survey

PI-Jason, William Kirsch

June-Oct, 2026

Graze

PI-Jeremy, PI-Jason

June-Oct, 2026

Grazing trials (pending additional funding)

TA-Serkan Ates, PI-Jeremy

July-Sept, 2026

Irrigate

PI-Jason, PI-Jeremy

Jun-Sept, 2026

Field Days

PI-Jason, PI-Jeremy, TA-Serkan Ates

Aug, 2026

Assess plant heights

PI-Jason, Intern

Sept, 2026-Apr, 2027

Analyses, Write-ups, Media development

PI-Jason, PI-Jeremy, TA-Serkan Ates, Andrew Millison

Dec, 2026-Feb, 2027

Winter season bird survey

PI-Jason, William Kirsch

Cooperators

Click linked name(s) to expand/collapse or show everyone's info

Research

Materials and methods:

This grant will allow us to maintain and secure establishment of the silvopasture, and obtain baseline and early data on environmental changes. The TAs plan on securing additional resources to conduct experiments, quantify effects on livestock, and track long-term changes to biodiversity, soil health, and carbon stocks. During 2022-2023 the site has been laid out, including the planting of trees and shrubs (See Supplemental Materials maps). Additional planting to compensate for first year mortality will be done in fall/winter 2023-24. 

The Confluence Farms property encompasses 112 acres, including 90 in farm fields and 17 in riparian forest along a mile of the Marys River. The farm has a mile long west to east axis and varies in width north to south from 700 to 1200 ft. It has a perimeter livestock fence and cross fences, and buried, well-fed, livestock water lines. An irrigation pump accesses the Marys River and buried mainline and risers distribute water to fields. Soils and slopes change from west to east, reflecting the geomorphology of historic Marys River overflow channels. Soils are primarily silty-clay loams suitable for high value crops, although seasonal flooding and slow drainage on Conser soil swales are a management challenge. 

We have installed the silvopasture on a 10 acre field with predominantly Conser soil. This field is centrally located and least valuable as cropland, making it ideal for this project. Based on tolerance to hydric soils, three main, canopy tree species have been planted: Black cottonwood (Populus trichocarpa), White alder (Alnus rhombifolia), and Pacific willow (Salix lasiandra). (Note: Oregon ash was not chosen because of the Emerald ash borer risk). In addition, a diversity of small trees and shrubby species are planted as an additional vegetation layer: Blue elderberry, Red elderberry, Pacific ninebark, Red-osier dogwood, Hooker's willow, Oregon crabapple  Lewis’ mockorange, Black hawthorn, Osoberry, Red-flowering currant, Black twinberry, Common snowberry, Douglas spirea, Salmonberry, Thimbleberry

In addition to practical information on ease of establishment and growth rates for each species, our goals are to both understand the characteristics of these single species plantings on some basic environmental and forage parameters, as well as uncover any differences from more diverse plantings in key metrics (e.g., carbon sequestration, biodiversity). Plantings are in a complete block design, with three blocks, meaning there are replicates of each planting combination within each block (3 single species tree X 3 replicates; 3 single species tree + diverse understory X 3 replicates) for 18 treatment rows. Because we have questions about the efficacy of carbon sequestration, animal health, and other environmental parameters there are control areas between blocks lacking tree cover. 

Objective 1: Maintain and secure establishment

The trees and shrubs need time to grow in the absence of browsing and we plan to keep livestock out of tree rows for at least five years. The trees were planted prior to sowing a pasture sward, but we may still need to mow vegetation as we develop grazing systems to allow for irrigation equipment (K-line) to be moved and ensure high survivorship, reduce competition, and promote rapid growth rates. Local arborists are dropping off wood chips, and these are being dumped at the base of trees to retain water and prevent weed growth. 

After a summer of mowing, grazing, and mulching with chips, we will till the area between rows of trees and shrubs and sow a new, permanent pasture. The pasture itself will be biodiverse, including forbes, clovers, and potentially native wetland plants. 

We have a data table that collects survivorship of each individual planted, after a few years we will also be able to infer and compare growth rates among species, and over time follow biomass accumulation.

Objective 2: Obtain baseline and early data on environmental changes

During the early years we will be collecting data on weather, soil health, and biodiversity. The initial weather station will allow for continual sampling of wind, precipitation, temperature, and humidity. We plan on having two stations eventually, one near a tree row and one in a control area. Additional funding will be sought for more fine-grained deployment of microclimate sensors, and expanded data on irradiance and soil moisture, as tree rows mature. 

Standard surface layer (0-8” depth) soil sampling will be conducted in control and treatment areas, and compare pasture vs tree rows. Soil health metrics include standard chemical analyses, as well as bulk density, aggregate stability, and infiltration. We plan to store soil samples at -80C for eventual environmental DNA tests (eDNA), which will likely pick up many macro-organisms too. We will seek additional funding to repeat these tests after the term of this grant, and also to perform non-standard soil sampling at deeper horizons that will help refine estimates of carbon dynamics.

For biodiversity surveys we are focusing on two taxa with strong area expertise, i.e., birds and bees. Both studies will enable us to understand changes in the silvopasture in the context of broader sampling on the farm and in the region. Monthly bird surveys using standard protocols at 14 sample points on the Confluence Farms property are already being done, including two within the silvopasture. These will allow us to gauge population changes in silvopasture relative to adjacent open farm fields and closed canopy riparian forest. Bee surveys using standard techniques developed by the Oregon Bee Atlas team, will allow for species richness, abundance, and relative population reproduction estimates each summer. 

These metrics have been chosen to understand how silvopasture alters microclimate, builds carbon above and below ground, and how the biological communities respond. We are facing atmospheric overloads of carbon, farmland loss of carbon, as well as regional declines in many bird and insect populations from intensive, industrial agriculture. Silvopastures incorporating native vegetation may help arrest these trends, and by demonstrating changes on the more marginal soils we might ease farmer acceptance and adoption.

Research results and discussion:

Establishment Data 2024

Establishment data are kept on the three main tree species being compared: White Alder, Pacific Willow, and Black Cottonwood. By early spring of 2024 the rows were fully planted out, and by the end of June wood chips were placed in nearly all locations to reduce competition from herbaceous plants and conserve soil moisture (some locations were missed by the work crew and mulched in the fall). Mowing, weed whacking, and irrigation with K-line were used to help trees establish, and in the fall as planting was undertaken to replace dead trees, survivorship was assessed. 

Given row lengths, we expect to have the following number of trees per species: White Alder (116), Pacific Willow (130), and Black Cottonwood (130). Percent survivorship was as follows: White Alder (38%), Pacific Willow (42%), and Black Cottonwood (60%). 

Tentatively, we believe Black Cottonwood is the easiest tree to establish. Pacific Willow and White Alder have similar survival rates, but Pacific Willow is originally taken from cuttings so is cheap and more readily available. For all species, excess cuttings or bare root trees are potted in the fall and planted in early spring. We have not assessed differences in survivorship between fall and early spring plantings.  

Our hope is that management continues to improve and so will survivorship. The mulching may take time to be fully effective, both in terms of killing off competition and breaking down partially to offer soil benefits. We plan to till and smooth the field in 2025, which may help with irrigation efficiency (the effort to move K-line is higher than ideal given field conditions). Though not tested explicitly, one suggestion we would have for others is to place wood chips down ahead of any planting. Local arborists drop off loads of wood chips free of charge for us.

Bird Surveys 2024

We conducted standardized surveys during the breeding season on 14 points spanning the farm. This and Jason’s Yard data provide a solid baseline for tracking potential changes in composition as the silvopasture develops. Our hypothesis is that the silvopasture points will show an increase in frequency and abundance of birds with an affinity towards forests while still retaining elements of grassland avifauna. We are aware of and in conversation with experts in using satellite land cover data and spatial statistics with eBird records to eventually perform these analyses (see: https://ebird.github.io/ebird-best-practices/). 

The farm in 2024 was the second most species-rich Yard in the state of Oregon with 118 species. This species richness is on par with some of the most popular public birding locations in the area that are managed as natural areas, supporting the notion that working farms can be important areas for native biodiversity. 118 species were recorded, with 72 during the summer breeding season. 45 of these were year-round residents and 27 were summer only residents.

Participation Summary

Research Outcomes

No research outcomes

Education and Outreach

2 Tours

Participation Summary:

Education and outreach methods and analyses:

We are eager to tell the story of silvopasture, and given the multiple stakeholders involved will have ample opportunity for outreach and education. 

There are two key outlets for written materials with wide circulation. Ian Silvernail of USDA’s Plant Materials Center will update guides for native tree and shrub selection in part based on this project. A number of us will contribute to an OSU Extension guide to silvopasture establishment that in addition to explaining the use case, explores the choices we made, and various tradeoffs in level of effort, cost, and time. This can be updated periodically as the site evolves and we learn more. 

Regional professional organizations have meetings where talks and/or poster sessions would be open to us. These may include the Oregon Sheep Growers Association, Willamette Valley Grazing and Nutrition Group, Corvallis Sustainability Coalition, Willamette Valley Bird Symposium, and Xerces Society.

Andrew Millison has a very popular YouTube channel (over 300,000 subscribers) and will create at least one video on this project within the first three years. Jason Bradford is a podcast host and has been interviewed many times as a podcast guest on food and agriculture issues. Andony Melothoupulos has a podcast called PolliNation. All of us will have ample opportunities in various contexts over the years to discuss this project. 

The number of partners on the project at OSU makes it likely student groups will be coming out to learn from the site ongoingly. Andrew Millison already brings students out to Confluence Farms multiple times a quarter. Members of the Organic Growers Club are a regular presence. Classes and student clubs from many disciplines, including soils science, entomology, ornithology, animal and range science, horticulture, ecology, environmental science, would find something interesting with the story of silvopasture on a diversified, organic farm, while also conducting related field work. We will have undergrad students doing internships and thesis work at the site year-round, such as collecting data on growth and survivorship of trees, bee and bird surveys, soil collection and lab work, pasture growth and diversity sampling, to livestock behavior and health. 

We also have connections to a myriad of stakeholder groups, from food and farm reform interests, to environmental and watershed non-profits, and agencies who publish newsletters and occasionally organize public tours, such as Benton Soil and Water Conservation District, Benton County Extension, Marys River Watershed Council, and Ten Rivers Food Web. 

Field days are planned for the end of this grant period, once we have plants well established and can thoroughly discuss how to manage livestock grazing in this situation. We will collaborate with stakeholder groups on scheduling and tailoring of field days for their needs. 

In summary, our education objectives are:

  1. Two new or updated guides for silvopasture and native plant establishment with OSU Extension and USDA Plant Materials Center. Publish by the end of 2027. (Jason Bradford, Ian Silvernail, and Serkan Ates)
  2. Create a project poster(s) that is shown at least three times in regional meetings by the end of 2027. (Jason Bradford, Jeremy Morrison, and Serkan Ates)
  3. At least one YouTube video published on Andrew Millison’s channel by the end of 2027. (Andrew Millison and Jason Bradford)
  4. The project will be covered by at least two podcasts by the end of 2027. (Jason Bradford and Andony Melathopoulos)
  5. University classes visiting the site at least six times by the end of the grant term. (Jason Bradford, Andrew Millison, and Serkan Ates)
  6. OSU Bird Nerds ornithology club engaged in biodiversity monitoring ongoingly. (William Kirsch and Jason Bradford)
  7. OSU student groups, such as classes or clubs, participate in native tree and shrub planting, weeding, or chip mulching on at least two occasions during the first year of the grant. (Jason Bradford, Andrew Millison, Serkan Ates)
  8. At least three students spend a quarter as interns during the grant term. (Andrew Millison, Serkan Ates, Jennifer Moore, Jason Bradford)
  9. The project is covered by at least three outlets with newsletters to area stakeholders by the end of 2027. (Jason Bradford)
  10. A minimum of two field days are held during the summer to early fall of 2026. (Jeremy Morrison, Jason Bradford, Serkan Ates)
Education and outreach results:

Andew Millison’s permaculture design course toured and worked for a few hours in the silvopasture. They assisted in late November with assessing mortality, and then planting out potted material that had been carried through the summer.  We explained the experimental design of the site, as well as the reasons for installing a silvopasture in general and in this location on the farm specifically. 

A student of Serkan Ates, Ivan Mametieff, spent the summer as an intern and is back this winter. He has helped with weed abatement, tree establishment, and fencing installation. 

OSU students continue to help with bird monitoring. 

Much of the outreach related to this project occurs later in the timeline.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.