Final report for GW25-008
Project Information
Fusarium wilt of lettuce, caused by the soilborne fungus Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae (Fol), poses a significant threat to United States’ over $4 billion lettuce industry. This serious disease disrupts water and nutrient transport, causing wilting, stunting, and often plant death. Fol survives in soil for extended periods as chlamydospores, making eradication nearly impossible once fields are infested. Traditional management strategies, such as crop rotation, soil fumigation, and use of resistant cultivars, have had limited success due to the pathogen’s persistence and adaptability. Recent detection of highly virulent Fol variants capable of overcoming resistant cultivars demonstrates the urgent need for innovative sustainable management solutions.
This project evaluates the efficacy of organic and low-risk soil-applied treatments for managing Fusarium wilt of lettuce (Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae) through greenhouse, small-plot field, and commercial-scale trials. Greenhouse experiments, replicated field trials, and commercial-scale evaluations have been completed, and data analysis is finalized. The study focused primarily on commercially available microbial biological products due to their widespread use and relevance to grower decision-making. In addition, a preliminary greenhouse experiment evaluated the potential interaction between a high-sulfur organic fertilizer and biological treatments. While initial results suggested potential effects, this component was not advanced to field-scale validation due to logistical constraints and prioritization of treatments with higher immediate applicability.
Across experimental systems, treatments including biological control agents, biostimulants, and low-risk fungicides were assessed for their ability to reduce disease severity and improve plant physiological performance. Results to date indicate that none of the evaluated treatments provided consistent or reliable suppression of Fusarium wilt or improvement in plant health under the conditions tested.
Educational and outreach efforts have been initiated, including a field day attended by approximately 150 stakeholders and presentations at industry and academic events. Additional outreach materials, peer-reviewed publications, and a video-based educational series are currently in development.
Research Objectives
- Evaluate the Efficacy of Organic Treatments for Fusarium Wilt Management
Greenhouse trials were conducted to screen a range of organic treatments, including biological-based and fertilizer-based solutions, for their effects on disease severity and plant health. Replicated small-plot field trials and commercial-scale evaluations were completed to assess the performance of selected treatments under production-relevant conditions. Due to grower interest and practical relevance, later field evaluations focused primarily on commercially available microbial biological products. - Quantify Disease Suppression and Pathogen Reduction
Disease severity was assessed using standardized rating scales and correlated with physiological plant health metrics, including stomatal conductance, transpiration rate, and photosystem II efficiency. UAV-based multispectral imaging was also used to assess canopy-level responses and spatial variability in disease development under field conditions. Quantification of Fusarium pathogen populations in soil was explored using selective plating and molecular approaches, but these methods were not pursued further due to limitations in reliability, efficiency, and practical relevance for evaluating grower-facing treatment outcomes. - Identify Potential Synergies Between High-Sulfur Fertilizers and Biofungicides
A preliminary greenhouse trial was conducted to investigate the effects of a high-sulfur organic fertilizer alone and in combination with a Trichoderma-based biofungicide. Preliminary results suggested disease suppression associated with the fertilizer treatment regardless of Trichoderma inclusion. Due to logistical constraints and prioritization of microbial biological products with stronger immediate grower relevance, this component was not advanced to field-scale validation and remains an area for future study. - Provide Growers with Field-Validated Data for Decision-Making
Independent field and commercial-scale trials were completed to generate practical efficacy data on organic treatments for Fusarium wilt management. Results to date provide third-party information on the performance and limitations of widely used microbial biological products under realistic production conditions and will support practical recommendations for sustainable pest management.
Educational Objectives
- Disseminate Findings to Growers and Stakeholders
Outreach activities were initiated through a field day at Cal Poly and presentations at industry and academic events. These activities shared research progress and practical observations with growers, pest control advisors, students, and other stakeholders. - Engage Broader Audiences Through Publications
A grower-focused article was published, and additional publication efforts are in progress. Manuscript development and other written outreach materials are underway as part of the project’s continuing dissemination efforts. - Enhance Knowledge of Fusarium Wilt and Soil Health Interactions
The project generated data-driven insights into the relationship between disease development, plant physiological stress, and canopy-level responses measured through UAV-based imaging. These results are contributing to broader understanding of how plant health measurements can complement disease evaluations in sustainable agriculture research. - Develop Educational Media for Sustainable Practices
A video series summarizing research findings and practical applications of organic treatments is currently in progress. Video development has been delayed relative to the original timeline, but this objective remains active and will be completed before the final report deadline
The project has largely followed the proposed timeline, with greenhouse experiments, replicated field trials, and commercial-scale evaluations completed during the 2025 growing season. Data collection across all experimental components has been completed, and data analysis is finalized.
Outreach activities, including a field day and presentations to growers, researchers, and industry stakeholders, were conducted and provided early dissemination of project findings.
Development of educational video content and preparation of publications are currently in progress and will be completed as part of the remaining project activities.
Cooperators
- - Producer
- (Educator and Researcher)
Research
Greenhouse Trials
Greenhouse experiments were conducted to evaluate organic treatments under controlled conditions using a susceptible iceberg lettuce cultivar. Pasteurized potting mix was used and inoculated with a spore suspension of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lactucae (FOL) to establish uniform disease pressure. The inoculum was prepared from cultured isolates and adjusted to a target concentration representative of field conditions.
Two primary greenhouse experiments were conducted.
Experiment 1: Screening Organic Fungicides and Biostimulants
A completely randomized design with four replications was used to evaluate a range of commercially available biological and low-risk treatments, including bacterial- and fungal-based products, botanical oils, and a synthetic standard. Treatments were applied as soil drenches at transplanting and/or post-inoculation depending on product type. Disease severity was assessed weekly using a standardized ordinal scale, and area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) was calculated. At harvest, root discoloration severity and plant biomass were recorded.
Experiment 2: High-Sulfur Fertilizer Evaluation
A separate greenhouse experiment was conducted to evaluate a high-sulfur organic fertilizer alone and in combination with a Trichoderma-based biological treatment. Plants were grown in naturally infested soil to better reflect field conditions. Treatments were applied prior to planting. Disease severity and plant growth responses were monitored to assess potential treatment effects.
Physiological Measurements
A greenhouse physiology experiment was conducted to evaluate potential biostimulant effects under heat stress conditions. Stomatal conductance, transpiration rate, and photosystem II efficiency were measured using a LI-COR porometer/fluorometer at multiple time points. Biomass measurements were collected at harvest. Data were analyzed using linear and mixed-effects models to assess treatment and time effects.
Field Trials
Replicated small-plot field trials were conducted to evaluate treatment performance under production-relevant conditions. Trials were established using a randomized complete block design with artificially introduced FOL inoculum applied at transplanting to ensure uniform disease pressure.
Treatments included microbial biological products and a conventional fungicide standard. Applications were made via soil drench or chemigation at labeled rates. Disease incidence and mortality were assessed weekly, and AUDPC values were calculated to quantify disease progression.
Due to confounding factors such as vertebrate damage in some trials, mortality-based metrics were emphasized over visual severity ratings where appropriate.
Commercial-Scale Field Evaluation
Commercial field trials were conducted in collaboration with a grower in Santa Maria, California. Large-scale treatment plots were established under standard commercial practices. Treatments were applied through drip chemigation at multiple timings.
Disease severity was assessed using a disease severity index (DSI) in the most affected field. Spatial variability in disease development was captured using a grid-based sampling approach across treatment plots.
UAV-Based Canopy Assessment
Unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) multispectral imaging was conducted across field trials to assess canopy-level responses. Vegetation indices including NDVI, NDRE, leaf area index (LAI), and apparent leaf nitrogen (ALN) were calculated from multispectral imagery.
Area under the curve (AUC) was calculated for each index across the growing season. These metrics were used to evaluate treatment effects on canopy development and to assess relationships between canopy condition and disease severity.
Pathogen Quantification
Quantification of pathogen populations in soil was explored using both selective plating on Komada’s medium and molecular methods. However, these approaches were not pursued further due to limitations in reliability, high variability, and limited efficiency under field conditions. As a result, disease severity, plant physiological responses, and canopy metrics were prioritized as primary indicators of treatment performance.
Greenhouse Trials
Across multiple replicated greenhouse experiments, treatment effects on disease severity were statistically significant; however, no biological or organic treatment consistently reduced disease severity relative to the inoculated control. In some cases, treatments exhibited similar or greater disease severity compared to untreated controls. A conventional fungicide standard showed limited and inconsistent suppression depending on the experiment. Biomass measurements generally reflected disease severity, with no treatment improving plant growth relative to the inoculated control.
A separate greenhouse physiology experiment found no significant effects of biological treatments on stomatal conductance, transpiration rate, or photosystem II efficiency across sampling dates. Biomass was also not significantly affected, indicating no measurable biostimulant effect under the conditions tested.
A preliminary greenhouse experiment evaluating a high-sulfur organic fertilizer indicated a trend toward reduced disease severity relative to untreated controls. This effect appeared independent of Trichoderma inclusion, though results were not further validated under field conditions.
Small-Plot Field Trials
Three replicated field trials were conducted with artificially introduced inoculum. Disease developed successfully in all trials, with mortality in inoculated controls reaching high levels (up to approximately 96% in one trial). Treatment effects on disease progression, quantified by area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC), were not statistically significant in any trial. No biological or chemical treatment consistently reduced disease incidence or mortality.
Commercial-Scale Field Trials
Commercial field evaluations conducted in Santa Maria, California confirmed these findings under production conditions. Disease severity index (DSI) exceeded approximately 67% across treatments under high disease pressure, with no treatment demonstrating suppression relative to the untreated control. Disease progression occurred rapidly and uniformly across treatment plots.
UAV-Based Canopy Assessment
Multispectral UAV imaging detected no significant treatment effects on canopy development across vegetation indices including NDVI, NDRE, LAI, and apparent leaf nitrogen. However, strong negative correlations were observed between canopy indices and disease severity, with correlation coefficients approaching −0.8 in some analyses. These results indicate that UAV-based imaging effectively captured spatial variability in disease expression but did not detect treatment-level differences.
Cost Analysis of Treatments
A cost-efficiency comparison of selected biological products demonstrated substantial variation in cost relative to microbial propagule concentration. Bacterial-based product programs were generally in the range of approximately $50–100 per acre, making them substantially less expensive than many fungal-based alternatives. Some Trichoderma-based products provided greater colony-forming units (CFU) per dollar, but at higher overall program costs. Despite these differences in cost-efficiency, no treatment demonstrated consistent disease suppression under greenhouse, field, or commercial conditions.
Summary of Findings
Across all experimental systems, none of the evaluated soil-applied biological or low-risk treatments provided consistent or reliable suppression of Fusarium wilt or improvement in plant health. Results highlight the limitations of currently available products under both controlled and production conditions and emphasize the need for integrated disease management approaches
Research outcomes
This project demonstrates that currently available soil-applied biological and low-risk products did not provide consistent or reliable suppression of Fusarium wilt of lettuce under greenhouse, field, or commercial production conditions. Based on these findings, growers should exercise caution when adopting biological products for management of soilborne diseases and should not rely on these products as stand-alone solutions. Instead, Fusarium wilt management should continue to prioritize integrated approaches, including the use of resistant or tolerant cultivars, field selection, planting timing, and crop rotation strategies that address long-term inoculum buildup. The persistence of the pathogen in soil, combined with the emergence of new pathogenic variants capable of overcoming resistance, further emphasizes the need for diversified management strategies rather than reliance on single inputs.
Economic considerations are critical for adoption decisions. Cost analysis conducted in this project showed substantial variation in product cost relative to microbial propagule concentration, including differences in colony-forming units per dollar among products. Lower-cost bacterial programs were generally in the range of approximately $50–100 per acre, while some higher-cost fungal-based programs provided greater propagule density per unit cost but did not translate into improved disease control. These findings highlight the importance of evaluating both efficacy and cost when considering input adoption, as well as establishing realistic experimental budgets for on-farm trials.
Preliminary findings from a high-sulfur organic fertilizer trial suggested potential disease suppression independent of microbial biological products, indicating that fertilizer-based approaches may represent an alternative management strategy that warrants further investigation under field conditions. In addition, results from multiple experiments suggest that plant responses to treatments may vary depending on cultivar, as several lettuce cultivars were used across greenhouse and field trials. These observations indicate that potential interactions between host genotype and treatment response should be considered in future research and may influence the consistency of biological product performance.
From a methodological perspective, several important limitations and considerations were identified. The viability and establishment of microbial biologicals in soil remain uncertain under field conditions, and treatment performance may depend heavily on environmental compatibility and timing relative to pathogen activity. Application methods, including chemigation and transplant delivery, require further refinement to ensure uniform distribution and effective placement in the root zone. Variability in application uniformity and field conditions may contribute to inconsistent outcomes and should be addressed in future work. At the same time, UAV-based multispectral imaging and plant physiological measurements proved valuable for quantifying plant health and disease progression, even when treatment effects were not observed, and may support future research and on-farm monitoring efforts.
Future research should focus on integrated disease management strategies, improved understanding of soil microbial ecology and microbial product performance, evaluation of host–treatment interactions across cultivars, and development of more reliable methods for assessing biological products under field conditions. Additional work is needed to determine whether fertilizer-based approaches, including sulfur amendments, can be optimized for practical disease management and how biological products may be effectively integrated into broader management programs.
The project also supported completion of an M.S. thesis evaluating organic and low-risk approaches to managing lettuce Fusarium wilt across greenhouse, small-plot field, and commercial production settings. A manuscript based on this research was submitted for peer-reviewed publication. These scholarly outputs preserve the project’s methods, data, and interpretation for future research and extend the value of the work beyond the grant period.
Education and Outreach
Participation summary:
Educational outreach was conducted through a combination of in-person events, professional presentations, and development of written and digital materials to communicate research findings to growers, pest control advisors, agronomists, and students. A field day was held at the Cal Poly Organic Center, where research plots and demonstration materials were presented to attendees. Demonstrations included symptomatic lettuce plants and Fusarium inoculum to provide visual context for disease identification and management challenges. Project findings were also shared through presentations at professional continuing education events, including a meeting of the Central Coast Pest Control Advisors Association and a webinar for the Western Region Certified Crop Adviser program. These presentations were tailored to agronomists and pest control advisors and incorporated results from greenhouse and field trials. The Certified Crop Adviser webinar focused on putative biostimulant effects of microbial biological products and included relevant field trial data, while the Pest Control Advisors Association presentation focused on Fusarium wilt trial results and disease management implications. A grower-focused article was developed and published in Progressive Crop Consultant to translate research findings into an applied format. Development of a video-based educational series is currently in progress to provide accessible summaries of research findings and practical considerations for growers. Outreach efforts emphasized clear, data-driven communication of results, particularly highlighting observed limitations of soil-applied biological products under field conditions.
Educational outreach activities reached a diverse audience of growers, pest control advisors, agronomists, researchers, and students. The field day event was attended by approximately 150 participants and provided direct engagement with stakeholders through demonstrations and discussion. Professional presentations delivered at a meeting of the Central Coast Pest Control Advisors Association and a webinar for the Western Region Certified Crop Adviser program reached approximately 90 or more participants through continuing education programs, expanding dissemination of project findings to key decision-makers in crop production systems. These presentations increased awareness of the limitations of soil-applied biological treatments and generated discussion around realistic expectations and management strategies. The Progressive Crop Consultant article, which was selected as an Editor’s Choice article, contributed to broader dissemination of results in an applied format accessible to growers, pest control advisors, and agricultural professionals. Feedback from stakeholders indicated strong interest in independent evaluation of commercially available products and the practical implications of these findings for disease management. Discussions of treatment cost and program-level economics, including cost analysis of biological products, also provided context for manufacturers and industry representatives regarding practical budget constraints in lettuce production systems and considerations for product testing and adoption. Development of a video series is ongoing and is expected to further expand accessibility of project findings.
Poster - 2026 Central Coast Organic Agriculture Conference
Organic Field Day 2025 Program