Progress report for LNC19-419
Project Information
The protection and preservation of rangelands is integral to key ecosystem services within the North Central Region such as biodiversity, recreation, and food and fiber production. Educating youth through a sustainable agriculture curriculum can serve as the direct link to the future sustainability of rangelands in the Great Plains and South Dakota. This project, entitled “Investigating Rangeland Systems and Practices: Enhancing Sustainable Agriculture Curriculum in South Dakota,” is focused on educating youth in grades 6, 7, and 8 about sustainable agriculture through a lens of rangeland systems and practices. Our overall objectives are to promote sustainable agriculture curriculum through educational events for teachers and 4-H Youth Program Advisors, and have educators and youth learn about sustainable agriculture through a rangeland lens. To maximize reach, we conducted workshops for teachers and 4-H Youth Program Advisors, providing educators with lesson and laboratory/field exercises that align with the Next Generation Science Standards. All lessons and laboratory/field exercises involve active learning strategies, such as think-pair-shares and small group discussions, as well as experiential and hands-on learning. We are working with ranchers to provide vlogs (video blogging) for the curriculum. Students and educators will learn about the local, national, and worldwide impacts sustainable agriculture has on people, the economy, and the protection of natural resources. This project will result in increased awareness of sustainable agriculture among youth, including challenges faced, impacts of management strategies, and career opportunities. Ultimately, this project will provide youth and, consequently, their families an objective understanding of what farmers and ranchers are doing, making them informed citizens and cognizant neighbors and future voters.
Learning outcomes: 1) teachers and 4-H Youth Program Advisors will learn about sustainable agriculture and how to teach the curriculum, 2) students will learn about sustainable agriculture, 3) students will gain awareness of careers and higher education paths in agricultural fields. Action outcomes: 1) students will share sustainable agriculture information with their families, 2) students will seek careers or higher education paths in agricultural fields, 3) the curriculum will be adopted by states within the North Central Region. Condition outcomes: 1) increased concern for the protection and conservation of natural resources, 2) increased labor force in agricultural fields.
This progress report includes activities to date from November 1, 2019 to December 31, 2023. Below we provide an overview of activities that occurred during Year 3 of our grant (1/1/2022 to 12/31/2022). We finished a final curriculum module by summer 2022 - Module 5: Foraging. This completes the number of modules we suggested in the original grant proposal. In addition, we completed a budget reallocation and no-cost extension (NCE) request in July 2022. The main reason for the budget request is that instead of doing stand alone workshops with teachers, we are actively incorporating the modules into Extension and outreach activities that already exist. The rationale for the NCE is to continue producing outputs for the grant. The request was approved by SARE, and included the following:
I have had success with this project and have completed the following to date: (includes activities from 11/1/2019 through 7/1/2022). Completed products and associated notes are bolded italic. Suggested changes are noted. Products that are additional to the original scope of the proposal are noted as **bolded italic.
- 5 Core Curriculum Modules with Lessons: Module 1: Overview of Rangelands, Module 2: Rangeland Plants, Module 3: Rangeland Animals, Module 4: Soil Health, and Module 5: Foraging.
- All modules are complete.
- 4 Workshops for Teachers and 4-H YPAs, Total expected participants = 80.
- 1 workshop held 10/27/2021, 19 adult participants, SDSU Extension Fall Conference; Brookings, SD
- **1 pilot of the curriculum conducted with Mobridge Middle School; Mobridge, SD during 2021-2022 school year
- 2 adults, approximately 40 youth
- 1 workshop held 5/12/2022, 24 adult participants, SD 4-H Professionals’ Spring Training; Yankton, SD
- Upcoming workshop, 7/26/2022, TBD adult participants, SD Career and Technical Education (CTE) Conference; Sioux Falls, SD
- Upcoming workshop, 11/2022, TBD adult participants, North Dakota State University Extension Fall Conference; Fargo, ND
- I anticipate doing 2-3 additional workshops and presentations from 11/1/2022 to 10/31/2023.
- 2 Reflection Roundtables, Total expected participants = 40 (We expect ~ 50% of educators will be available).
- Suggested change: Instead of reflection roundtables, we would like to complete surveys with teachers and 4-H advisors who attend workshops, parents who assist at Rangeland and Soils Days (see note below under Field Trips), and students who experience some SARE lessons through other outreach events.
- 6 Sets of Field Trips (Fall, Spring) for Educators and Students, Total expected participants = 360. There will also be 6 participating ranchers, (3 ranchers Year 1, 3 ranchers Year 2). Each ranch will conduct two field trips per year – one in fall and one in spring, for one class/school.
- 1 field trip conducted 10/15/2021 with Mobridge Middle School for the pilot
- 4 adults, approximately 40 youth
- **1 event, 6/14-6/15/2022, Rangeland and Soils Days; Murdo, SD
- Suggested change: Instead of doing additional field trips, we would like to incorporate some of the SARE curriculum modules into an already existing event for youth – Rangeland and Soils Days, held annually in June in South Dakota. I (K Ehlert) lead Rangeland and Soils Days and at the event we just held in June 2022, I incorporated some of the SARE lessons into my work with the “New Rangers” group of 8-10 year old kids. I would like to use some of the participant support costs to fund travel and supplies for the New Rangers group to Rangeland and Soils Days, including reimbursing for this year and next year, where it will be held in Watertown, SD.
- Suggested change: Since Rangeland and Soils Days will be hosted in Watertown, SD (“East River”) in 2023, I would also like to work with partners such as The Nature Conservancy (TNC) and NRCS, the SD Grassland Coalition, and the SD Soil Health Coalition, to host another youth event “West River” sometime in 2023.
- 1 field trip conducted 10/15/2021 with Mobridge Middle School for the pilot
- 7 Video Blogs (Vlogs) Per Participating Rancher.
- Suggested change: Due to COVID, and a lack of newer cell phone technology that some producers don’t have, it has been difficult to get video blogs completed that are of high quality.
- Suggested change: Thus, we propose doing 3 vlogs per participating rancher, 6 ranchers, for a total of 18 vlogs.
- Suggested change: The budget reallocation request includes money for a contractor to go and meet with producers and film the vlogs, across North and South Dakota.
- 1 Journal Article. Will be submitted to a journal such as the Journal of Agricultural Education.
- This will be completed at the end of the project.
- 3 Extension Articles. Will be published on the South Dakota State University Extension website (extension.sdstate.edu) to highlight the project and provide a final summary to the general public.
- These are in progress and will be completed by the end of the NCE.
- 2 Conference Talks. Papers will be presented at conferences such as the National Association of County Agricultural Agents (NACAA) and the Society for Range Management.
- 1 presentation was given 2/2021 at the Society for Range Management Annual Meeting.
- An additional conference talk/presentation will be given in 2023.
Cooperators
Research
Education
Our overall objectives are to promote sustainable agriculture curriculum through educational events for teachers and 4-H Youth Program Advisors (YPAs), and have educators and youth learn about sustainable agriculture through a rangeland lens. We have focused on workshops for teachers and 4-H YPAs. Experiential and hands-on learning are at the core of this project and will directly expose students to the economic, environmental, and social aspects of sustainable agriculture systems and practices.
We presented the curriculum and held workshops for teachers and 4-H YPAs will be held for science and ag teachers and 4-H Youth YPAs. Workshop attendees were given materials including modular lesson plans and when available, any materials needed to complete each activity. Lesson plans and laboratory/field exercises provide a summary of the activity and learning outcomes, and alignment with the Next Generation Science Standards and South Dakota Standards of Learning. Further information such as appropriate classroom assessment techniques (CATs) and references are outlined for each lesson. When possible, we have provided participant support costs to teachers and 4-H YPAs to offset the cost of mileage and lodging.
In our original grant proposal, we suggested an approach we called “Adopt-a-Rancher” where ranchers would develop video blogs (“vlogs”) to amplify a rancher’s viewpoint, thought processes, and daily decisions, as well as the seasonal foresight and adaptability needed to achieve sustainable and regenerative ranching practices. Vlogs were intended to “attach a face” to a person (i.e. a rancher) perhaps previously unknown to students and their families. Finally, we had proposed field trips to ranches to expose students to practical skills such as plant identification and rangeland health assessment, as well as provide the opportunity to interact directly with someone who is invested in the future of sustainable agriculture.
As a result of COVID-19, we quickly adapted to the fact that it was difficult to get students and teachers on field trips to ranches due to COVID restrictions. Further, it was also very difficult to have the ranchers themselves provide vlogs - they often had older cell phone models, so we did purchase some GoPros and associated video equipment to help with this. However, the ranchers we initially were collaborating with on the project seemed unsure of where to start with the videos. Thus, we removed the "Adopt-a-Rancher" component of the project, and instead are relying on a contractor to conduct short vlogs with producers in the North Central region. This avenue allows us to have more control over the consistency of the video footage - the quality, sound, etc. Moreover, vlogs serve as a “day in the life” for students to see and hear what a rancher does and allows students to be exposed to different ways of knowing, ultimately challenging their way of thinking and demonstrating multi-faceted problem solving. We have a goal that the vlogs will be captured spring/early summer 2023, and be ready as the final component of the curriculum by October 2023 (the end of the no-cost extension).
Instead of having ranchers directly involved in the curriculum, from a time constraint process, the grant Co-PIs led the curriculum effort. As a result, we conducted a pilot of the curriculum with Mobridge Middle School (Mobridge, SD). This allowed us to change the curriculum based on feedback from a middle school teacher and students. For example, some time estimates we had on activities were much too short, and actually took twice as long due to needing to conduct the activity with 20-25 students! We also learned from the Pilot that we needed to provide educators with more background information so that s/he felt confident presenting the material to students.
We developed five core curriculum modules: Module 1: Overview of Rangelands, Module 2: Rangeland Plants, Module 3: Rangeland Animals, Module 4: Soil Health, and Module 5: Foraging. Hands-on experiential learning is woven throughout all curriculum modules. All of the components of the curriculum modules translate well to Bloom’s taxonomy, which is a framework for categorizing educational goals, and is familiar to teachers and 4-H YPAs. To illustrate how one of our curriculum modules connects to specific Next Generation Science Standards we will focus on an example of Module 2: Rangeland Plants. Students will first learn how to differentiate between types of plants such as grasses, forbs, and shrubs. This aligns with MS-LS1: From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and Processes and challenges students to think about how plants reproduce, what impact environmental conditions have on growth, and the effects that characteristics such as flower color can have on pollinator attraction and therefore reproduction (Performance Standards MS-LS1-4 and MS-LS1-5). Further, there will be a focus on grasses so that students learn about different photosynthetic pathways and the cycling of matter and energy flow into and out of organisms (Performance Standards MS-LS1-6).
One of the last steps of this project is to conduct evaluations with students and educators who have been exposed to the curriculum. As of 12/2023 we have evaluation data from most of the presentations and workshops we've conducted. This will give us further information on areas that need improvement, ideas for future curriculum modules, and any concepts that students had difficulty with.
Project Activities
Educational & Outreach Activities
Participation Summary:
-Consultations:
- Ehlert K and J Bachler. Mobridge Pilot Meeting. 2021 August 30. Mobridge Middle School. Mobridge, SD.
-Curricula, Fact Sheets, or Educational Tools:
- Ehlert K, J Bachler and C Wood. 2020. Module 1: Overview of Rangelands.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2020. Module 2: Rangeland Plants.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2021. Module 3: Rangeland Animals.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2021. Module 4: Soil.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2022. Module 5: Foraging.
-Webinars, talks, and presentations:
- Bachler J. 2021 October 20. Mobridge Pilot - in-classroom assistance. Mobridge Middle School. Mobridge, SD.
- Direct contacts: 2 adults, approximately 25 youth.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2021 October 27. Sustainable agriculture for middle school students. South Dakota State University (SDSU) Extension Conference. Brookings, SD.
- Direct contacts: 25 adults.
- Ehlert K and C Wood. 2021 February. Investigating rangeland systems and practices: Enhancing sustainable agriculture curriculum in South Dakota. Society for Range Management 2021 Annual Meeting. Virtual. SRM 2021 Poster.
- Ehlert K, C Wood, and J Bachler (presenter). 2022 February 4. Sustainable agriculture curriculum for middle school students. South Dakota STEM Conference. Huron, SD.
- Direct contacts: 4 adults.
-Workshops and field days:
- Ehlert K and J Bachler. 2021 October 15. Mobridge Pilot field day. Mobridge, SD.
- Direct contacts: 3 adults, approximately 25 youth.
- Synopsis: Students were exposed to plant identification through hands-on learning in the field (Module 2: Plants), we discussed why rangelands are important for both livestock and wildlife (Module 1: Overview of Rangelands; Module 3: Animals), and how ranchers are good stewards of the land. We also had a demonstration of a cattle dog herding cattle, and further discussed nutrient cycling in relation to "where the dung piles are" on the landscape (Module 4: Soil).
- No formal evaluation conducted.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2022 May 15. Sustainable agriculture curriculum for middle school students. South Dakota 4-H Professionals Spring Conference. Yankton, SD.
- Direct contacts: 26 adults.
- Synopsis: Module 5: Foraging was used as a demonstration along with the presentation of the rest of the curriculum.
- Evaluation
- General comments
- "All of the materials are very helpful/useful."
- "I like the variety of hands-on programming options."
- "At this point, I feel there will be a select set of activities I definitely use. Our schools are hard to get into but also want to share with teachers."
- "Love that the modules can be used all together or in parts! Pieces of this will work great in an existing program I have."
- "Thank you! This was so much fun and very informational. I am looking forward to utilizing this curriculum."
- Average score of 4.9 for the evaluation question: How would you rate your attitude toward agriculture and helping youth understand it, specifically from a sustainable lens? Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = I don't think this is important at all; 5 = I think it is very important.
- Average score of 4.2 for the evaluation question: How would you rate your personal understanding of agriculture – from the role that plants and animals have to the importance of soil health? Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = I know very little; 5 = I live it - I farm/ranch with my family.
- Average score of 3.5 for the evaluation question: Do you plan to incorporate one or more of either the modules or an activity from a module into your 4-H programming? Scale of 1 to 4: 1 = Not going to because I'm not interested or don't feel it is important; 4 = I am very interested and feel it is important to incorporate.
- General comments
- Ehlert K. 2022 June 14-15. South Dakota Rangeland and Soils Days. Murdo, SD.
- Direct contacts: 4 adults, 8 youth.
- Synopsis: Students learned plant identification through hands-on learning in the field (Module 2: Plants), we discussed why rangelands are important (Module 1: Overview of Rangelands), and how ranchers are good stewards of the land. We also spent time talking about how rangelands provide multiple uses, including wildlife habitat (Module 3: Animals). Further, students learned a little bit about soil and how soil is living (Module 4: Soil).
- No formal evaluation conducted.
- Ehlert K, J Bachler, and C Wood. 2022 July 26. Sustainable agriculture curriculum for middle school students. South Dakota Career and Technical Education (CTE) Summer Conference. Sioux Falls, SD.
- Direct contacts: 6 adults.
- Synopsis: Module 5: Foraging was used as a demonstration along with the presentation of the rest of the curriculum.
- Evaluation
- General comments
- "I like the foraging concept and would like to add that."
- "The modules will be great to integrate to build literacy and grow interest."
- "I will incorporate much of this into my 7th grade ag class."
- "I like the hands-on activity provided. It would be great to provide more resources to get teachers in the range."
- Average score of 4.8 for the evaluation question: How would you rate your attitude toward agriculture and helping youth understand it, specifically from a sustainable lens? Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = I don't think this is important at all; 5 = I think it is very important.
- Average score of 3.8 for the evaluation question: How would you rate your personal understanding of agriculture – from the role that plants and animals have to the importance of soil health? Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = I know very little; 5 = I live it - I farm/ranch with my family.
- Average score of 4 for the evaluation question: Do you plan to incorporate one or more of either the modules or an activity from a module into your 4-H programming? Scale of 1 to 4: 1 = Not going to because I'm not interested or don't feel it is important; 4 = I am very interested and feel it is important to incorporate.
- General comments
- Ehlert K, G Villmow, and J Bachler. 2022 July 27-28. Rangeland: why is it important? South Dakota State University Dakota Dreams Camp. Brookings, SD.
- Direct contacts: 1 adult, 95 youth (middle school age).
- Synopsis: Students listened to a presentation about rangelands - where we find them, why they are important (Module 1: Overview of Rangelands) for both livestock and wildlife (Module 3: Animals), learned a few different rangeland plants (Module 2: Plants), and had fun learning about rangeland foraging (Module 5: Foraging).
- Evaluation
- General comments
- "You guys did a great job, hope to join your class later in life!"
- "Thank you! I am Native American so it was really fun."
- Average score of 4.1 for the evaluation question: The people teaching us were engaging. Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = Strongly disagree; 5 = Strongly agree.
- Average score of 3.6 for the evaluation question: I liked learning about rangeland and the Native American historic uses of rangeland plants. Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = Strongly disagree; 5 = Strongly agree.
- Average score of 4.2 for the evaluation question: I learned about rangelands in South Dakota and how important they are. Scale of 1 to 5: 1 = Strongly disagree; 5 = Strongly agree.
- General comments
-Upcoming Outreach:
- 2023 June. Rangeland and Soils Days. Watertown, SD.
Learning Outcomes
- Overview of Rangelands - where they are in the world, why they are important
- Rangeland Plants
- Rangeland Animals
- Rangeland Soils
- Rangeland Foraging