Final report for ONC23-120
Project Information
Weeds can severely reduce crop yield and farm profitability. Choosing weeding tools can be confusing, and it’s not uncommon for vegetable growers to buy expensive tools that don’t work for them. Farmers learn more and learn better when they can experiment with weeding tools in the field, learning from experts and farmers in the process, but such opportunities are rare. Historically underserved farmers have additional barriers to accessing weed management resources. For example, immigrant growers often lack access to trainings delivered in their primary languages or presented in culturally relevant ways. This project will educate vegetable farmers in Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois and Iowa about weeding tools through four on-farm workshops, hosted at farms operated by HMoob, Latinx, and women farmers, making these events more welcoming to HMoob and Spanish-speaking growers. Host farmers will receive expert training in the use of new weeding tools on their farms during the season so they can share their experiences in their native languages at the workshops. The workshops will demonstrate three scales of weeding tools for farmers to try and will include HMoob and Spanish interpretation. Post-project, the tools will be stored at Fondy Farm and available to farmers and ag professionals for training.
- Improve weed management knowledge and skills on vegetable farms by hosting culturally-appropriate, farmer-led, hands-on workshops accessible to farmers in WI, MN, IL, IA (with targeted outreach to HMoob and Latinx growers)
- Provide farmers with strategic understanding to guide their investments in weeding tools
- Strengthen farmer networks to promote continued farmer-to-farmer learning
- Promote and model the development of inclusive, culturally and linguistically accessible field days for other ag professionals and Extension colleagues
- Build relationships and trust between Extension and underserved growers (with a focus on HMoob and Latinx farmers)
Cooperators
- - Technical Advisor (Educator)
- - Technical Advisor (Educator)
Research
NA
NA
Educational & Outreach Activities
Participation summary:
UW-Madison Extension staff worked with organizational partners and farmers at Fondy Farm to coach growers in the use of mechanized cultivation tools. SARE funds were used to purchase a tool library that was made available to Fondy farmers throughout the 2023 growing season with several opportunities for small group demonstration and workshops allowing growers to utilize the tools and learn the benefits that each tool might offer to increase efficiency of farm operations. A small group of 4-6 farmers worked with the tools through the summer. A late summer 2023 field day trained 18 additional farmers and service providers in mechanized tillage approaches.
Two mechanical weed control field days were held during the fall of 2024. Topics covered during the field days included the theory behind weed management including the weed seed bank, timing, depth, and type of tillage/cultivation. There were also hands-on demonstrations on how the tools operate, what they can be used for, and how to modify them based on field conditions and task. The first field day took place at Rodrigo Cala's farm in Western WI and included 11 farmer attendees. Material was presented in both Spanish and English with simultaneous interpretation. As part of the event, Rodrigo shared the framework of mechanical weed control tools as an investment in the longevity of a farm and how he determines the return on investment for a piece of equipment. The next event occurred in Waukesha County at Gwenyn Hill Farm as part of an apprentice field day serving beginning growers from both the FairShare Apprenticeship program and other growers from around the greater Milwaukee area. This event had 20 farmer or farm worker attendees.
In the spring of 2025, tools were transferred to Fondy Farm and became part of a tool rental library available for both farmers and technical assistance (TA) providers. UW Madison Extension and Fondy Farm hosted a tool library launch field day on May 1st 2025. The first half of the day covered the scenarios in which each tool should be utilized, the safe use of each tool, and the modifications that can be made to each tool based on field conditions and field layout. In the afternoon attendees had the chance to complete their equipment best practice and safety training that is required to be able to rent a piece of equipment. Growers who expressed interest in purchasing some of their own tools also received support in searching for used tools as well as key factors to consider when buying used.
Both TA providers and farmers will be able to rent equipment. Rentals will be free for farmers while TA providers will be charged a small fee for rentals. Rental fees will support ongoing tool maintenance. In order to rent equipment from the library, users must successfully pass a skills test (Fondy Tool Library Skills Test). To support safe usage, the project also developed a User Checklist for Rental of Power Ox.
To support on-going tool use and management, the project has drafted a user agreement based on examples of tool agreement forms and waivers being used for tool libraries related to maker spaces and public libraries around the country (Draft Tool Library Agreement Form). During the 2025 season, Fondy farm was undergoing a lot of changes including modifications to field access and acreage as well as a staffing shortage. As a result, a formal rental agreement protocol and agreement form remain in draft form and have not been finalized.
There were several takeaways from the first season of the tool library at Fondy Farm. First, even with several field days on weed control and tool demonstrations, farmers still required significant one-to-one support to operate the tools and learn how they could be effectively incorporated into their farming systems. The most effective approach was to set up the equipment and use it in a farmers’ field alongside them. Once they saw it worked well in their fields and how much time it saved, then they were willing to try it themselves and in different situations. Farm staff also parked and displayed the tools in the middle of the farm where farmers would drive by and gather for breaks. This led to more growers asking to try the tools compared to when they were out of sight in the storage shed. Despite the many benefits these tools can provide, change can be a big barrier and an idea really needs to be championed to stick. The 2025 season was largely focused on getting Fondy growers to use the equipment. The 2026 season will be a focus on expanding tool use to the greater Milwaukee area farming community in part through social media posts and taking the tools to other farm clusters. It is anticipated that word-of mouth recommendations from early adopters will gradually lead to increased adoption of these tools within the grower community.
To further support this community of growers in increasing their knowledge of sustainable management practices, strengthening their farmer networks, and building stronger connections with Extension, remaining grant funds were used to support continued learning about weed control approaches through grower attendance to two field days in the fall of 2025 as well as the Emerging Farmers Conference in November 2025. Support included interpretation, mileage reimbursement, and conference registration. Fall field days featured farm tours of two farms in northeastern Wisconsin and one farm in central WI to show how these farms are successfully implementing sustainable weed management practices. Tours allowed attendees to see how other farms are implementing different tools and practices and helped these growers build relationships with experienced farmers with whom they might not have otherwise connected. Two UW Madison Extension staff attended the events alongside the growers to strengthen awareness of technical assistance resources as well as continue to build trust between Extension and underserved growers.
Evaluations from the 2024 field days indicated that all participants increased their knowledge around mechanical weed control either somewhat (33%) or a great deal (67%). Participants indicated that they will change aspects of their farming practices somewhat (63%) and a great deal (37%) of the time based on information they learned during these field days. After the tool library launch, two farmers at Fondy farm indicated that they plan to buy their own equipment with one grower especially interested in purchasing a used walk behind tractor. Some common themes around changes to practices included thinking of weed control as part of a larger cultural system of production and managing the germination zone as a way to draw down the weed seedbank without bringing up deeper weed seeds.
Learning Outcomes
Timing of weeding- weeding earlier when weeds are not visible or can barely be seen (white thread stage) is the most effective time to weed
Managing the germination zone and cultivating more shallowly to prevent bringing up more weed seeds
Weed control as part of a larger cultural system- field/bed design, planting including spacing and straight rows all impact the ability to use certain equipment efficiently later in the season for weeding. It is important to think about how all planning and management stages interact and affect one another
Changing weeding strategies based on age of crop.
Modifying weed management to the type of weeds that are most present on their farm and learning the top three weeds on their farm to make the biggest impact on reducing weed pressure
Project Outcomes
Weed management can be a large portion of labor needs on a farm and can increase labor costs significantly if not managed in an efficient manner. Weeds also have the potential to negatively impact crop yields due to competition between weeds and cash crops. To address these impacts, this project combined the theory of weed management including the weed seedbank and germination zone, the tools to identify the top three weed problems on a farm and how their lifecycles impact management, and hands-on tool demonstrations. This comprehensive framework guided farmers to think of weed management as part of their larger farm system. Providing farmers with not only the physical weeding tools but also the context of how these tools can work on their particular farm will result in the biggest positive impacts on successful weed management and the variety of benefits that come with it. The first area of impact is economics. Implementing both mechanical weeding tools and a comprehensive understanding of weed control will reduce the amount of time farmers need to spend weeding and thus the cost of labor associated with weeding. There will also be a positive impact on crop yield when competition between crops and weeds is reduced or eliminated. Greater yields will equal greater profits and a greater return on the time and money that they invested in the seeds and growing of the crops. They will also benefit economically from not investing in equipment that doesn’t work in their system. In addition to economic benefits for the farmers, improved weed management through mechanical cultivation is also more environmentally sustainable as farmers will reduce their reliance on herbicides. Finally, the farmers that have participated in project field days increase their network of support by connecting with farmers and technical assistance providers. Now that the project is done, the tool library will provide them with continued connection to resources and support. The tool library will also facilitate continued networking building through the availability of tools to technical assistance providers to host more field days and further the opportunities for more farmers to benefit from these tools.
A small-scale vegetable farmer in SE WI was very skeptical of using the power ox and discs for weeding in her garlic patch. However, Stephen set it up for her and was adamant they try as soil conditions were ideal. He started by using the tool and demonstrating how it could bury weeds. Once she saw how well it worked, she asked to drive. The time and ease of use led her to borrow the tool the next day to plant her potatoes. She gained some confidence using the power ox and attachments in her fields and plans to use them in the upcoming season.