Implementing precision irrigation management tools to improve the sustainability of Christmas tree production in a changing climate

Final report for ONC24-145

Project Type: Partnership
Funds awarded in 2024: $49,995.00
Projected End Date: 03/30/2026
Grant Recipient: Michigan State University
Region: North Central
State: Michigan
Project Coordinator:
Younsuk Dong
Michigan State University
Expand All

Project Information

Summary:

Michigan experienced significant drought conditions and erratic precipitation. Growers reported high rates of tree mortality on recently planted trees, especially under non-irrigated conditions. Young trees often have small, poorly developed root systems and are the most vulnerable to drought stress, resulting in tree mortality and poor growth. Irrigation has been shown to improve survivability and increase growth of young trees. However, excess irrigation wastes water resources, increases nutrient leaching and soil erosion, and promotes suitable environments for Phytophthora root rot, a significant pathogen leading to tree mortality. Proper irrigation management is critical to improve the sustainability of the Christmas tree industry amongst a changing climate. Often, growers use personal observations to schedule irrigation events. A commonly accepted viewpoint is irrigation events of 1 inch per week are sufficient in the absence of rainfall. However, there is limited evidence to support this value and determining the actual amounts of irrigation applied can be difficult. The goal of this project is to partner with Christmas tree growers to demonstrate and evaluate the effects of irrigation management tools, including weather-based irrigation scheduling, soil moisture monitoring equipment, and automated irrigation control systems for use in Christmas tree production.  Results from 2024–2025 showed that ET-based irrigation increased cumulative leader growth by approximately 30% compared to both the growers’ standard practice (e.g.; rule of thumb, 1” per week) and non-irrigated treatments. These findings suggest that ET-based scheduling maintains optimal soil moisture, enhances growth, and improves water-use efficiency. The MSU Irrigation Lab developed the “MSU Irrigation Scheduling” mobile app, an ET-based irrigation scheduling tool. Since the team shared the results with stakeholders, an additional 14 Christmas tree growers have begun using the app, demonstrating adoption of this practice.

Project Objectives:

Objective 1: Train and familiarize Christmas tree growers with various irrigation tools such as weather-based irrigation scheduling, soil moisture sensor monitoring units, and automated irrigation systems.

Objective 2: Evaluate the effects of irrigation management tools in newly planted Christmas trees on survivability, irrigation water use efficiency, and Phytophthora root rot presence.

Objective 3: Share the results and grower’s experience of irrigation tools and technology with other Christmas tree growers through meetings (panel discussion) and publications.

Cooperators

Click linked name(s) to expand/collapse or show everyone's info

Research

Materials and methods:

Objective 1 – Train and familiarize Christmas tree and nursery growers with various irrigation tools such as weather-based irrigation scheduling and soil moisture sensor monitoring units.

Four tree farms were selected for demonstration of weather-based irrigation scheduling and soil moisture monitoring equipment in 2024, with the support of the NCR-SARE program. Two farms use drip irrigation, and the other farms use a center pivot irrigation system. The demonstration farms are Badger Evergreen (Allegan, MI), Dutchman Tree Farm (Manson, MI), Korson Tree Farm (Sidney, MI), and Top Hill Farm (Goodrich, MI). In the 2024 growing season, Badger installed AgSense center pivot irrigation controlling system, and Korson installed a 9V solenoid valve controlling system to turn the irrigation on and off remotely. At Dutchman Tree Farm, the center pivot was already equipped with AgSense system. At Top Hill farm, the team decided to control irrigation using a manual valve because the farm uses a diesel water pump which requires manual operation. The project team installed LOCOMOS (Low-Cost Sensor Monitoring System) sensors on each demonstration farm. LOCOMOS sensors record in-field soil measurements (soil moisture level at 6, 12, and 24-inch depths, soil temperature) and environmental conditions (air temperature, relative humidity, and precipitation) and send the data to an IoT cloud webserver using an embedded cellular modem. Figure 1 shows photos of installed sensor monitoring systems.

Fied demonstration sties 

Figure 1. Christmas tree irrigation demonstration farms. IoT-based soil and weather monitoring equipment were installed to monitor soil moisture levels, temperature, relative humidity, leaf wetness duration, and precipitation.

 

Objective 2 – Evaluate the effects of irrigation management tools on newly planted trees on survivability, irrigation water use efficiency, and Phytophthora root rot presence.

Each demonstration farm was divided into three sections to evaluate irrigation strategies (Figure 2). The strategies were grower’s existing irrigation strategy (applying 1 inch/week as a supplement), weather-based irrigation scheduling (rPET-based), and non-irrigation. Reference potential evapotranspiration (rPET) is the primary parameter in weather-based irrigation scheduling. Tree growth and survivability were monitored also monitored.

Plot design

Figure 2. Irrigation demonstration plots: (1) Badger Evergreen, (2) Dutchman Tree Farm, (3) Korson Tree Farm, and (4) Top Hill Farm.

Research results and discussion:

The project team has continued focusing on collaborating with growers to install and train them on the operation of automatic irrigation systems. In addition, IoT-based soil moisture sensor data website was shared with growers. Figure 3 shows an IoT (Internet of Things) website of the one of on-farm demonstration sites. We discussed how to access and interpret the collected data.

iot website

Figure 3. An IoT website that display real-time soil moisture sensor data at 6, 12, and 24 inch depth and precipitation.

We also installed and demonstrated the Sentek drill and drop probes in demonstration Christmas tree farms, to show how it is installed and monitor water dynamics in soil (Figure 4). Each probe contains sensors at 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, and 60 cm. The recorded soil moisture data provided further understanding of root zone dynamics and irrigation efficiency across treatments. 

sentek

Figure 4. Installed a Sentek Soil probe in a Christmas tree farm.

We have evaluated the effects of three irrigation treatments, non-irrigated control, ET-based irrigation, and grower-standard irrigation, on soil moisture dynamics and tree growth. Soil moisture data collected using Sentek sensors revealed that ET-based irrigation maintained more consistent volumetric water content within the effective root zone (0–50 cm) compared to the other treatments (Figure 5). Control plots experienced notable water deficits during mid-summer dry periods. Moisture fluctuations were more pronounced in the upper soil layers (0–20 cm), closely following rainfall and irrigation events, whereas deeper layers (40–60 cm) responded more gradually, indicating that only substantial rainfall or irrigation events penetrated to those depths.

 

sensor data

Figure 5. Soil moisture monitoring for each treatement.

Results from 2024–2025 showed that ET-based irrigation increased cumulative leader growth by 10-30% compared to both the growers’ standard practice (e.g.; rule of thumb, 1” per week) and non-irrigated treatments (Figure 6).  These results indicate that ET-based irrigation more effectively maintained optimal soil moisture throughout the growing season.

Tree leader growth

Figure 6. Cumulative two-year (2024 +2025) leader growth for each irrigation treatment at two demonstration Christmas tree farms. 

 

Participation summary
4 Farmers/Ranchers participating in research

Educational & Outreach Activities

3 Consultations
1 Curricula, factsheets or educational tools
4 On-farm demonstrations
1 Online trainings
1 Published press articles, newsletters
3 Webinars / talks / presentations
1 Workshop field days

Participation summary:

1,100 Farmers/Ranchers
80 Agricultural service providers
Education/outreach description:

The team gave a talk regarding sensor technology for irrigation management at Michigan Seedling Grower Association summer meeting, which was held in Allegan, MI on 8/29/24. PI Dong also recorded a presentation on irrigation management for Christmas Tree production, which was shared with nursery and Christmas tree growers in 2025. In addition, the PI Dong gave a presentation at MSU Christmas Tree Webinar Series in February 2025, attracted more than 200 growers and ag professionals from across U.S. In 2025, the project team presented findings at the National Christmas Tree Summer Meeting, held at Dutchman Tree Farms (Manson, MI) from July 24–26, 2025. The presentation highlighted the importance of efficient irrigation management in Christmas tree production and introduced strategies to enhance water use efficiency, including irrigation system uniformity checks, smartphone-based irrigation scheduling applications, and soil moisture sensor deployment. There were over 900 participants. Additionally, PI Dong shared the results of this study with over 90 Christmas tree growers at the 2026 Michigan Christmas Tree Winter Meeting in Frankenmuth, Michigan.

National Christmas Tree Meeting

National Christmas Tree Summer Meeting (Manson, MI).

Learning Outcomes

240 Farmers/Ranchers gained knowledge, skills and/or awareness
Key changes:
  • Using soil moisture sensors for irrigation management

  • Evapotranspiration-based Irrigation Management for Christmas Tree Production

  • Irrigation Scheduling Smartphone App

Project Outcomes

3 Grants received that built upon this project
Project outcomes:

This project improved the sustainability of Christmas tree production by demonstrating data-driven irrigation management practices that enhance water use efficiency, tree growth, and grower decision-making. Weather-based (ET-based) irrigation increased cumulative leader growth by 10–30% compared with grower-standard irrigation and non-irrigated treatments, improving tree uniformity and market potential while reducing reliance on fixed irrigation rates. These practices can lower pumping, fuel, and labor costs by targeting irrigation only when soil and crop conditions require it. Environmentally, the use of IoT-based soil moisture sensors and ET scheduling reduced over-irrigation and maintained more consistent soil moisture within the effective root zone. Improved moisture management supports groundwater conservation and reduces nutrient leaching. Socially, the project increased grower knowledge and confidence through hands-on training with automated irrigation systems, soil moisture sensors, and cloud-based data platforms. On-farm demonstrations across diverse irrigation systems supported peer learning and adoption of precision agriculture tools, strengthening grower capacity to adapt to climate variability and long-term water resource challenges.

2 New working collaborations
Recommendations:

Future research should evaluate the long-term economic benefits of ET-based irrigation, including water use savings, energy costs, and impacts on production timelines across multiple years and weather conditions. Additional study is recommended to quantify irrigation-related disease impacts, particularly Phytophthora root rot, under different soil moisture thresholds identified through sensor data.

Information Products

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.