Giant Miscanthus Production on Maryland Eastern Shore’s Marginal Land: Grassroots Efforts to Restore Profitable Agriculture

Progress report for ONE21-392

Project Type: Partnership
Funds awarded in 2021: $25,801.00
Projected End Date: 11/30/2024
Grant Recipient: University of Maryland
Region: Northeast
State: Maryland
Project Leader:
Dr. Sarah Hirsh
University of Maryland
Expand All

Project Information

Project Objectives:

This project seeks to:

1)     Perform research about giant miscanthus growth on marginal land

The field will serve as an important next step to make observations about potential issues and the outlook of this crop on marginal land. Correlations between soil moisture and soil salt content with miscanthus yield will be important for researchers to understand how this crop performs in coastal marginal land. The field will also allow researchers to study miscanthus tolerance to deer. The field-scale (10 acre) planting of miscanthus by our collaborating farmer will allow researchers to study a range of soil conditions and to study deer behavior in a realistic environment.

2)     Foster regionally relevant education about giant miscanthus

The planting will provide a field-scale demonstration of miscanthus for regional farmers to observe. Through field-day and workshop education events the project will educate regional farmers about this crop and facilitate a grassroots effort among farmers to discuss the viability of this crop as an option for marginal land.

Introduction:

In low lying areas on the Eastern Shore of Maryland cropland has been subject to sea-level rise and saltwater intrusion, causing farmers to abandon growing conventional crops (corn, soybean, wheat) on some fields. Affected land will continue to expand over the next century (Boesch et al., 2018). In addition, farmers are abandoning land due to extreme deer pressure from both white-tailed and sika deer. Farmers express interest in growing crops and crop varieties that are deer resistant or not affected by deer herbivory. 

The proposed project investigates growing giant miscanthus (Miscanthus x giganteus) on marginal land on the Eastern Shore of Maryland. There is a need to find crops that grow on marginal land and have a regional market. A needs assessment of farmers on the Eastern Shore of Maryland found that “marketing opportunities for local products” ranked as the highest need in the area of farm management (Behnke et al., 2019). Giant miscanthus is a promising crop for Maryland with a burgeoning market. Furthermore, miscanthus can provide an array of environmental benefits.

Our collaborating farmer has approximately 500 acres of marginal land in Dorchester County, Maryland, which no longer supports rowcrop production due to prolonged periods of flooding, saltwater intrusion and heavy deer pressure. In recent years the field was planted into soybean, but yielded no harvestable crop. As a result, the farmer is interested in the prospects of growing giant miscanthus on this land. However, miscanthus requires a large initial investment of approximately $1200/acre simply to acquire rhizomes and rent specialized planting equipment. Because of the high upfront costs and the lack of field-scale trials of miscanthus on marginal land, farmers are not able to risk planting miscanthus on marginal land. While miscanthus is one of the most promising perennial herbaceous industrial crops worldwide, cultivation is lacking due to high initial costs and low biomass potential during the crop establishment period (von Cossel et al., 2019).  A 10 acre field that will serve as both a demonstration and research plot will be planted by our collaborating farmer to investigate the viability of giant miscanthus on marginal land. Giant miscanthus is a perennial crop (maintaining maximum biomass for up to 15 years) and requires minimal inputs after establishment (Kalmbach et al., 2020).

Studies gathering data on the tolerance of alternative crops to environmental stressors are often performed in small plots or pots. This project is unique as we propose miscanthus be planted on a 10 acre field that is representative of the typical marginal land in this region, posing multiple environmental stressors (salt, flooding, and deer pressure) and being managed with commercial scale equipment by an experienced farmer. In addition, this field-scale trial will serve as a demonstration site for educational events. We propose holding educational workshops to discuss the agronomy and economics of miscanthus as well as a facilitated roundtable meeting of local farmers to discuss the efficacy of giant miscanthus as a viable crop for marginal land in the region.

Cooperators

Click linked name(s) to expand/collapse or show everyone's info
  • Dr. Sarah Hirsh (Educator and Researcher)
  • Dr. Haley Sater - Technical Advisor (Educator and Researcher)
  • Dr. Jon Moyle (Educator and Researcher)
  • Ben Flahart - Producer
  • Bud Malone

Research

Materials and methods:

1)     Perform research about giant miscanthus growth on marginal land

The collaborating farmer contacted the giant miscanthus rhizome supplier company (AgroTech) as well as a neighboring farmer who grows giant miscanthus on prime land at a commercial scale. The collaborating farmer coordinated with AgroTech and the local neighboring farmer to plant and establish the miscanthus on two small fields (total of approximately 10 acres). Giant miscanthus is recommended to be planted in either early spring or fall according to rhizome availability and field-conditions, which varies by weather and other factors both on the Eastern Shore and in North Carolina where the rhizomes are grown. In our study, the giant miscanthus was planted on 7 Jun 2022, approximately 2 months later than anticipated, due to weather and equipment availability.

We divided the field using GPS technology into a grid with 20 x 0.5 acre subdivisions (Figure 1). In order to characterize field conditions we took soil samples on 6/24/22 in each 0.5 acre subdivision (sample of 20 composite cores per subdivision). Those 20 cores were taken along a straight transect diagonally across each plot. Complete soil analyses were completed by AgroLab (Harrington, DE), which included all of the basic measurements (pH, nutrients, CEC, etc.) as well as total salts, salinity, and nitrogen.

Detailed observations and measurements were made in 20 x 1 m2 quadrats (Figure 1). These 20 quadrats were located within each of the 20 0.5 acre subdivisions. The following observations and measurements were taken in the quadrats:

  • Soil samples (sample of 10 composite cores per quadrat) were taken on 3/10/23. Complete soil analyses were completed by AgroLab (Harrington, DE), which included all of the basic measurements (pH, nutrients, CEC, etc.) as well as total salts, salinity, and nitrogen.
  • Sprouted rhizome count to determine emergence and stand establishment was completed on 8/15/22.
  • Heights of miscanthus was measured on 8/15/22.
  • Total biomass of miscanthus post dry down and leaf drop was measured on 3/10/23.

We monitored soil moisture continuously from planting through the first year of growth using Watermark soil moisture sensors and datalogging equipment. We measured soil moisture at 2”, 6”, 12”, and 18” soil depths within six of the 1 m2 quadrats (Figure 1). Quadrats were chosen that spanned the obvious drainage variability in the field--two in flooded areas, two in dry areas, and two in what appeared to be intermediate areas.  

In order to assess deer pressure on giant miscanthus, we walked down four miscanthus rows on 9/1/22 and 10/26/22 and recorded the number of leaves that were grazed by deer. We also set-up two wildlife cameras and counted the number of deer sightings during the first year of growth. 

We will perform a regression analysis to correlate miscanthus yield versus salt content, total salts, nutrient content, and other factors. We will perform a multivariate analysis to determine which soil factors most influence miscanthus yield.

In addition, the collaborating farmer will provide miscanthus yield data from the whole field at the end of the season. Through interviews with the collaborating farmer, we will document experiences and challenges involved with planting miscanthus on marginal land.

Figure 1. Map of 0.5 acre field subdivisions, 1 m2 quadrats, and soil moisture monitoring equipment locations.

 

2)     Foster regionally relevant education about giant miscanthus

We will hold a series of five educational programs introducing giant miscanthus and facilitating farmer discussion. Topics will include:

1)     Introduction to giant miscanthus and basics of production; Discussion of AgroTech partnership and potential markets (Virtual webinar)

2)     Experience growing giant miscanthus on marginal land and results of research study (Virtual webinar)

3)     Crop budget and economic analysis (Virtual webinar)

4)     Tour of miscanthus growing on marginal land (In-person field-day)

5)     Facilitated roundtable farmer discussion of whether miscanthus is a viable crop on marginal land in the region (grassroots efforts to garner grower interest and support and get ideas/engage). Example topics of discussion include, "What support would farmers need to make this crop more viable?", and "How does miscanthus compare with other options such as conservation easements or other crops?" (In-person meeting)

Research results and discussion:

Soil results from the 20 subdivisions are listed below (Table 1). Sodium levels are considered high in all subdivisions.

Table 1. Baseline soil characteristics

Field Subdivision pH sodium (ppm) soluble salts (EC mmho/cm) nitrate-N (ppm N) ammonium-N (ppm) phosphorus (ppm) potassium (ppm) CEC (meq/100g) organic matter (%)
1 5.7 280 0.82 13.7 6.8 81 96 7.2 2.4
2 5.8 150 0.74 16.1 5.3 70 123 7.8 2.5
3 5.6 400 1.39 17.2 7.5 169 182 9 2.9
4 5.7 120 0.69 13.8 9 73 170 7 2.1
5 5.8 160 0.87 17.3 8.3 81 129 9.7 2.3
6 5.7 150 0.76 23.2 7.9 95 138 7.4 2.5
7 5.6 160 0.88 14 9 74 125 7.2 2.1
8 5.8 190 0.93 21.5 10.4 58 91 7.4 2.2
9 5.8 550 1.54 8.4 3.5 127 101 10 2.8
10 5.6 420 1.36 6.4 5.7 110 64 8.6 2.7
11 5.7 260 0.75 6.3 1.7 85 50 6.8 2.7
12 5.7 210 0.65 7.4 1.8 84 45 6.6 2.5
13 5.9 280 0.51 7.4 1.4 87 70 7.4 2.7
14 5.7 620 1.67 8.3 3.3 136 110 9.2 2.5
15 5.8 270 0.74 6.6 0.8 79 58 7.1 2.5
16 5.8 400 1.07 7.4 6.9 129 93 7.9 3
17 5.7 520 1.38 6 1.6 148 113 9.4 2.9
18 5.6 460 1.13 7.6 2.5 142 111 9 2.8
19 6.1 300 0.91 8.2 1.8 78 68 8.1 2.6
20 6.2 430 1.13 6.9 5.2 153 98 8.4 2.3

 

Soil results from the 20 quadrats are listed below (Table 2). Sodium levels are considered high in all subdivisions.

Table 2. Soil characteristics from quadrats

Quadrat pH soluble salts nitrate-N (ppm N) ammonium-N (ppm) P (ppm) potassium (ppm) calcium (ppm) magnesium (ppm) sulfur (ppm) Boron (ppm) zinc (ppm) manganese (ppm) copper (ppm) sodium (ppm) CEC (meq/100g) H % sat K % sat Ca % sat Mg % sat Na % sat organic matter (%) Al (ppm) Iron (ppm)
1 6.8 0.16 1.3 9.2 43 121 729 187 8 0.69 1.89 150 0.92 70 6.1 5 5 59 25 5 2.3 930 150
2 6.2 0.35 1.2 9 151 117 431 180 27 0.9 2.48 140 1.28 170 5.4 12 6 40 28 14 2.6 1100 290
3 6.4 0.24 0.6 6.2 49 91 675 169 19 0.7 2.06 110 0.98 110 6 9 4 56 23 8 1.7 890 180
4 6.3 0.15 0.4 4.7 58 139 621 99 11 0.66 2.29 120 1.33 70 5.1 10 7 61 16 6 2.2 870 170
5 6.1 0.13 1.2 6 121 159 598 113 13 0.71 3.34 81 1.78 72 5.4 13 8 55 18 6 2.4 1100 220
6 6.2 0.11 1 6.9 95 166 512 77 10 0.68 2.4 120 1.46 57 4.4 12 10 57 15 6 2.3 1000 210
7 6.2 0.16 0.6 6.9 49 105 618 106 17 0.71 1.95 110 0.95 61 5.1 11 5 61 17 5 2.7 820 170
8 6.1 0.27 1 9.2 74 41 759 126 23 0.75 2.3 150 1.06 70 6 13 2 63 17 5 2.5 870 210
9 5.6 0.78 1.4 6.9 92 55 882 209 39 0.74 2.19 130 1.27 260 9.8 24 1 45 18 12 2.4 1400 190
10 5.9 0.21 0.6 3.8 75 28 460 136 24 0.6 1.29 91 1.08 98 4.7 16 2 49 24 9 2.3 1300 170
11 5.8 0.31 1.7 10.1 104 29 768 142 29 0.66 1.77 110 1.19 100 6.9 19 1 56 17 6 3.4 1400 170
12 5.9 0.19 0.1 5.3 94 21 451 85 25 0.6 1.45 130 0.99 82 4 16 1 56 18 9 2.3 1300 170
13 6.1 0.16 0.1 4.9 108 27 610 136 21 0.68 1.65 98 1.32 74 5.3 14 1 58 21 6 2.5 1300 190
14 6 0.95 0.2 4 120 73 482 293 26 0.89 1.84 83 1.05 510 8.6 15 2 28 29 26 2.2 1200 250
15 6.3 0.3 1.2 6.4 71 47 497 173 17 0.8 1.27 87 1 140 5.2 10 2 48 28 12 2.5 1100 250
16 5.9 0.8 0.2 5.2 86 49 496 210 39 0.84 1.53 87 0.93 320 6.9 17 2 36 25 20 2.5 1300 240
17 6.6 0.54 0.4 4.9 93 67 497 192 22 0.76 1.08 150 0.96 310 6 7 3 41 27 22 2.5 1400 190
18 6.2 0.59 0.1 4.2 125 79 450 241 31 0.92 1.34 73 1.06 350 6.8 12 3 33 30 22 2.5 1400 280
19 6.5 0.28 1 4.1 106 34 765 216 20 0.92 1.76 100 1.51 170 7 7 1 55 26 11 2.9 1300 240
20 6.5 0.64 1.1 5.7 240 93 511 250 27 1.2 4.66 130 1.12 390 7.1 8 3 36 29 24 1.7 1100 300

Soil moisture at 3”, 6”, 12”, 18”, and 32” depths is depicted in Figure 2. Especially at deeper depth the field was frequently or constantly saturated (Figure 2).

Figure 2 soil moisture

 

There was no deer grazing of miscanthus evident in the field. Many deer were sighted in the field via wildlife camera footage (Figure 3).

Figure 3 deer sightings

 

On August 15th, 2022 there was an average of 3.8 rhizomes per 1 meter area in the 20 subplots with a minimum of 2 and maximum of 7 rhizomes. 

On August 15th, 2022 plant height in the 20 subplots ranged between 26 and 42 inches. 

Even though the miscanthus was planted fairly late in the spring of 2022, it emerged in most parts of the field. Places with spotty or no miscanthus coverage were waterlogged a significant portion of the growing season. By December of 2022, miscanthus had flowered and reached between 5-9 feet in height. 

Biomass or yield of miscanthus was on average 2.7 tons/acre.

Participation Summary
2 Farmers participating in research

Education & Outreach Activities and Participation Summary

10 Consultations
2 Curricula, factsheets or educational tools
1 Online trainings
2 Published press articles, newsletters
1 Tours
8 Webinars / talks / presentations
1 Workshop field days
1 Other educational activities: Meeting with Maryland Department of Agriculture about potential giant miscanthus markets and cost-share

Participation Summary:

267 Farmers participated
308 Number of agricultural educator or service providers reached through education and outreach activities
Education/outreach description:

We will share the results of the project in our proposed educational programs. One of the virtual programs will be focused on the research results and farmer experiences of growing giant miscanthus on marginal land. In addition, we will hold a field-day tour of the giant miscanthus trial field. The research will also be discussed as part of the roundtable farmer discussion of whether miscanthus is a viable crop on marginal land in the region. In addition to these in-person and virtual educational programs geared towards Eastern Shore farmers, we will publish reports of the research in state-wide Extension newsletters such as University of Maryland Agronomy News. First year project results will also be presented at the 2023 National Association of County Agriculture Agents (NACAA) professional conference. A factsheet and final report of the project will be written that includes:

  • Results of miscanthus establishment, growth and biomass yield on marginal land
  • Correlations between site characteristics (e.g., salt content, soil nutrient content) and miscanthus yield
  • Results of deer presence and herbivory on miscanthus
  • Collaborating farmer experiences and potential ways to improve miscanthus management
  • Take-aways from the farmer roundtable discussion

Project PIs presented on giant miscanthus project at the following events and outreach platforms:

  • University of Maryland Extension Nutrient Management Research Recap. Virtual webinar. Feb 2022. 17 attendees.
  • Lower Eastern Shore Precision Agriculture Day. Princess Anne, MD. March 2022. 120 attendees.
  • Presentation - Giant miscanthus grass as a poultry house buffer. Buffer Demo Day. Lower Eastern Shore Research Center. Salisbury, MD. June 10, 2022. 56 attendees.
  • 2022 NACD Northeast Region & MASCD Annual Meeting. Cambridge, MD. Aug 2022. 30 attendees.
  • Poster - Sater, H., Hirsh, S. Moyle, J. Giant miscanthus production on Maryland Eastern Shore marginal land: Grassroots efforts to research an alternative crop. Maryland Commodity Classic. Queenstown, MD. July 27th, 2023. 100 attendees.
  • Miscanthus: an alternative crop for marginal land? Oral presentation. NACAA AM/PIC. Iowa Event Center, Des Moines, Ia. Aug. 15, 2023. 12 attendees.
  • Sater, H., Hirsh, S. Moyle, J. Giant miscanthus production on Maryland Eastern Shore marginal land: Grassroots efforts to research an alternative crop. Poster presentation. NACAA AM/PIC. Iowa Event Center, Des Moines, IA. Aug. 13-17, 2023. 200 views.
  • Workshop and Virtual tour. Giant miscanthus production on marginal land. Wicomico Extension Office. Aug 24, 2023. 20 attendees.
  • A grassroots effort on the Eastern Shore to produce an alternative crop giant miscanthus on marginal land. University of Maryland College of Agriculture and Natural Resources Cornerstone Event: Advancing agricultural production systems. College park, MD. Oct 24, 2023. 20 attendees.
  • Delmarva Trials Giant Miscanthus for Salt-Intruded and Flooded Land. Lancaster Farming.  https://www.lancasterfarming.com/farming-news/conservation/delmarva-trials-giant-miscanthus-for-salt-intruded-and-flooded-land/article_99447180-472b-11ee-8bd5-4bf6ab0f1e22.html. Digital and Print. August 31, 2023. Sarah Hirsh, Haley Sater, Jon Moyle, Kurt Vollmer were interviewed by the reporter Rebecca Schweitzer for an article about Miscanthus being grown on the Eastern Shore of Maryland. 59,500 paid subscribers.

  • Rising tides, saltier waters are a challenge for farmers along the Chesapeake Bay, by Sheilah Kast and Sam Bermas-Dawes. National Public Radio. On The Record. https://www.wypr.org/show/on-the-record/2023-12-05/rising-tides-saltier-waters-are-a-challenge-for-farmers-along-the-chesapeake-bay. Interviewed in segment. 5 Dec 2023. WYPR with sister stations WYPF WYPO reaches over 150,000 listeners per week in Maryland including Frederick on to the Eastern Shore.

 

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the view of the U.S. Department of Agriculture or SARE.