Developing a method to capture and authenticate single varietal honey on diverse landscapes

2016 Annual Report for FNC15-1019

Project Type: Farmer/Rancher
Funds awarded in 2015: $11,734.00
Projected End Date: 08/15/2017
Grant Recipient: Second Nature Honey
Region: North Central
State: Illinois
Project Coordinator:
Maggie Wachter
Second Nature Honey

Developing a method to capture and authenticate single varietal honey on diverse landscapes

Summary

WORK ACTIVITIES 2015

We began preparing for our SARE project in early March 2015 by moving ten hives of Italian and Russian bees into the apiaries of Curtis Orchard and Pumpkin Patch, a farm that features 20 acres of 30 varieties of apples. During the bloom from April 20 to May 3, the hives were physically transported into the apple orchards to facilitate pollination. 

 

During the apple pollination, we monitored the honey bee pollination of the apples by “bee spotting” i.e. counting bees on the trees within a specified time (one to five minutes).  Bee spotting revealed that our honey bees did not rush towards the apple blossoms.  Rather they appeared to prefer the nearby cherry trees that were blooming at the same time.  We consulted experts to explain this phenomenon:

 

Professional apple pollinator-beekeeper, Michael Palmer, advised that we saturate the apple orchard with twice the hive density, a minimum of one hive per acre.  In a personal communication, Dr. Tom Seeley of Cornell University suggested using stronger hives. Dr. Deborah Delany of the University of Delaware pointed out that honey bees preferred high sugar content in nectar, speculating that the cherry blossoms might be higher in sugar than the apple blossoms.  She also suggested that native bees might be useful pollinators for apple trees. 

 

Later in the summer, we conducted similar attempts to direct bees to wild forest crops, including groves of black locust trees (nearby Mahomet IL).  We decided to include groves of sourwood trees because of the unique location of several hives in the Appalachian Mountains of North Georgia.

 

Our SARE project also included microscopic examination of pollen collected from flowers and honey bee “pollen loads”, samples of pollen that were transported to the hives by honey bees. We taught ourselves the skill of identifying pollen using a microscope.   In the early days of the SARE project, before acquiring a camera to photograph microscopic samples, we sketched microscopic grains of pollen.  Later we used a Cannon Rebel T5 camera to photograph pollen grains through the microscope. 

 

We also conducted some exploratory honey analysis in a University of Illinois laboratory.  This included centrifuging samples of honey and examining them microscopically. 

 

Another aspect of our project was to participate in the University of Maryland Sentinel Honey Bee Project.  We were required to mount two hives on scales and collect and send samples of bees from eight hives to the University of Maryland Bee Lab over a six month period (May to October) for analysis of mite loads and twelve common bee diseases.

 

RESULTS SO FAR

One of the techniques that we used during apple pollination was to move the hives into the midst of the apple trees during the bloom.  We noticed that each time the hives were moved, the hives were weakened because many foragers returned to the empty space where the hive once stood.

 

The results with the black locust blossoms were more successful because we applied the knowledge we gained from the apples: we used strong hives placed directly in front of the grove.  These hives were moved far enough (over two miles) that the bees could not return to the old hive location, so they returned to the new hive location, keeping them strong. The resulting honey had the conventional appearance and taste of black locust.

 

Experimentation with bees in the sourwood trees was less clear.  While the hives were strong and the sourwood grove was thick, the background forage in the Appalachian forest is immensely competitive.  The resulting honey was darker than pure sourwood, but it had a wonderful flavor.  We suspect that the unique flavor of the honey was due to its sourwood-wildflower composition. 

 

We taught ourselves the skill of identifying pollen using a microscope.  The blooms that we sketched or photographed in 2015 include red delicious apple, red haven peach, blueberry, dandelion, tulip poplar, white honeysuckle and sumac.

 

We also began a library of common pollen grains found on the farm.  This year we either sketched or photographed pollen from the plants listed below.  The purpose of the library is to provide a reference for eventually identifying pollen in honey.

 

The monthly health analysis of our bees by the Sentinel Honey Bee Project indicated that our bees were healthy and resilient.  The Project consistently rated our bees on the high end of health compared with others.  We hypothesized that the nutritious and diverse forage that is available on a small family farm contributed to the above average health of our bees.  Research supports this hypothesis (Wheeler & Robinson, 2014).

 

Honey from our project was sold in the Curtis Farm Store and local farmers markets.  Perhaps one of the best outcomes of the first year is that honey from the Curtis Farm received first place in the Central United States in the 2015 International Black Jar Honey Tasting Contest hosted by the Center for Honeybee Research.  This confirms our hypothesis that honey produced on a diverse small farm is exceptional in many ways.

 

WORK PLAN FOR 2016

In 2016 we plan to approach apple pollination differently based on advice we received from experts cited in part one of this report:  we will double the number of hives to saturate the orchard.  This year we plan to preserve the strength of the foraging populations by keeping the hives stationary, leaving them in their home apiary near the orchards but not moving them into the apple trees.  We also plan to encourage a diversified pollinator population by building nests for native bees and placing them near the orchards.  We hope that the stronger and more numerous hives will result in improved bee spotting among the apple trees. 

 

We will continue to try to capture varietal honey from forest crops.  In 2016 we hope to capture honey from the tulip poplar and perhaps the linden tree.

 

We will continue to improve our skills in pollen identification.  In 2016 we hope to expand our skills to include isolating pollen samples in honey.

 

We plan to continue to build our reference library of pollen grains from common farm plants.  We plan to continue to use the camera that we acquired through the SARE grant to photograph the pollen grains.  We are discussing the possibility of creating an online database of pollen samples with the help of Dr. Delaney at the University of Delaware.

 

We will continue to participate in the Sentinel Honey Bee Project by sending monthly bee samples to the University of Maryland for health analysis.  We expect the excellent foraging available to our bees, either on a small, diverse family farm or in a wild Appalachian forest to continue to maintain a high level of honey bee health.

 

The capstone of our project will be the production of a booklet outlining techniques to guide other beekeepers in the exploration of pollen and honey through a microscope.  The booklet will include samples of pollen grains.

 

OUTREACH

We shared our project information through Facebook, television, radio, and tours.  Chasing the Honey is the title of our Facebook page that specifically highlighted our grant project research.  We have referenced Chasing the Honey to our business Facebook pages as well, Curtis Orchard and Pumpkin Patch and Second Nature Honey.

 

We sent out a press release of our SARE activities to local media.  Television crews were eager to learn more about our project and beekeeping.  We even had the opportunity on two occasions to suit up Fox News anchor, Janese Harris and her camera person to film the honeybees in action.  This was broadcasted across central Illinois during two separate news segments.

 

Phillip Kisubika, Radio personality for WDWS NewsTalk 1400, braved his fears of being stung to join us on a bee sampling day.  He was eager to see us in action and to capture the sound of a bee hive.  Here is a link to the audio file Bee research at Curtis Orchard which is shared through our local newspaper’s website.

 

Lastly, we mentioned our grant to the many guests that attend our tours at Curtis Orchard.  We have about 4,000 guests of all ages join our tours and our tour guides mentioned our grant during the honeybee portion of our tour.  One tour of note was the SARE tour with about 35 SARE employees and University of Illinois staff in attendance.  We were excited to share the progress of our research with those closest to the grant funding.

 

This year our plans involve inviting interested persons to Curtis Orchard for a presentation about our findings.  We will also send more press releases out in the hopes of generating additional news coverage.  We also plan to approach local educational venues about presentations, including Parkland College, Urbana Parks and Recreation and the University of  Illinois Extension.

Annex A

Table of flowers with bloom periods, 2015

 

 

Name of crop

Quantity

Place

Date 1st bloom

Date end bloom

Comments

Dandelions

10 acres

Curtis

April 15

 

observed bees on plants

Apples

5,000 trees, 25 acres

Curtis

April 20

May 3

cool and cloudy at bloom beginning

Black locust trees

200 trees on 1 acre

Mahomet

May 9

May 24

White and red honeysuckle nearby

Buckwheat

6×6 foot patch

Urbana

May 25

Start to go to seed in early July

Did not observe honey bees on crop.

Sourwood trees

forest w/ at least 300 sourwoods

North Georgia

June 30 2015

 

Bees very excited, working hard on July 3

Strawberries

5 rows, 15 ft long

Curtis

April 29

 

observed bees on crop

White & red clover

10 acres

Curtis

April-May 25

 

observed bees on crop

Black Raspberries

40 ft row

Curtis

May 17

 

observed bees on crop

Blueberries highbush

16 plants

Curtis

April 23

May 13

observed bees on crop

Cucurbits

20 acres

Curtis

July 14

 

observed bees on crop

Red raspberries

3 rows, 50, 28, 15 ft.

Curtis

July 26

August 6

observed bees on crop

 

 

 

REFERENCES

Diet-dependent gene expression in honey bees: honey vs. sucrose or high fructose corn syrup.  Marsha M. Wheeler & Gene E. Robinson. Scientific Reports 4, Article number: 5726 (2014)

doi:10.1038/srep05726

 

Collaborators:

Rachel Coventry

rachel@curtisorchard.com
Beekeeper
Curtis Orchard & Pumpkin Patch
3902 S Duncan Rd.
Champaign, IL 61822
Office Phone: 2178526048