A Comparison of Weed Control Strategies in Christmas Tree Plantations Using Mechanical and Chemical Methods or Shropshire Sheep

Project Overview

FNC24-1423
Project Type: Farmer/Rancher
Funds awarded in 2024: $15,000.00
Projected End Date: 02/15/2026
Grant Recipient: Sylvanmore
Region: North Central
State: Indiana
Project Coordinator:
Elise Koning
Sylvanmore

Commodities

  • Agronomic: clovers, grass (misc. perennial)
  • Additional Plants: trees
  • Animals: sheep

Practices

  • Animal Production: grazing - rotational, stocking rate
  • Crop Production: silvopasture
  • Pest Management: Weed Management
  • Production Systems: integrated crop and livestock systems

    Proposal summary:

    We focus on the production of sheep and Christmas trees. We can
    produce quality products, but our resources also can be limited
    in achieving these goals. One restraint is labor. Both Elise and
    Jeff are employed off-farm, which can sometimes conflict with
    farm needs. We are located in a rural area with a limited labor
    pool, and we are not yet profitable enough to pay staff anyway.
    Land also is limited. Our 12 acres are landlocked. While we may
    obtain space to expand in the future, we currently must use all
    resources in the most efficient way possible. Because of these
    restraints of time, labor, and space, we are looking to combine
    the processes of raising sheep and trees as much as possible to
    the benefit of both commodities.

    Project objectives from proposal:

    Solution: 

    As a solution to our limited time, labor, and land, we will
    combine elements of our sheep and Christmas tree operations and
    examine how they can each benefit the other. We propose
    introducing sheep into the Christmas tree stand to eat weeds.

    Within Christmas tree plantations, weed control is an ongoing
    challenge throughout the growing season. Dense, tall vegetation
    can stunt, if not kill, the trees by robbing nutrients and
    moisture that the trees need. However, this vegetation is an
    unused resource that could be used to feed our sheep. Grazing the
    sheep within the trees will potentially reduce the time, labor,
    and land we need to control the weeds and feed our animals. Our
    research trial will examine the labor and material costs of sheep
    grazing versus the labor and material costs of mechanical and
    chemical weed control in a Christmas tree plantation.

    Sheep can provide fertilizer, as well, and potentially reduce the
    labor and costs of mechanically and chemically controlling weeds.
    The symbiotic relationship saves on sourcing other forage and
    minimizes, if not eliminates, chemical and mechanical weed
    removal.

    For our trial, we will designate two areas in our acre of 800
    second-year trees. In our control area, we will manage weeds
    conventionally by mechanically mowing, spraying herbicide, and
    spreading mulch or compost around the base of the trees. In our
    experimental area, Shropshire sheep will graze amongst the trees
    in a rotational grazing system.

    Our methods will measure the amount of time that we spend with
    each weed control method. For conventional weed control, we will
    measure the amount of time used to mow, apply chemicals, and
    mulch the trees. We will also analyze the cost of materials for
    mechanical and chemical methods.

    For sheep grazing, we will analyze the cost of materials and
    measure how much time is used to set up the sheep paddocks using
    solar-powered temporary netting, move the sheep, and provide
    daily care and feeding. While we are using Shropshire sheep,
    which have a good reputation for working among tree plantations,
    the sheep will need to be moved as soon as they have exhausted
    their forage to eliminate the possibility of damage to the trees.
    To do this, we will need to monitor the sheep through webcams.

    The following materials are needed:

    For the sheep grazing area:

    1. Shropshire sheep
    2. Netting
    3. Solar charger
    4. Trail cam
    5. Water wagon and tanks
    6. Supplemental feed
    7. Feed/mineral feeders
    8. Shade
    9. Fly control

    For the chemical and mechanical control:

    1. Herbicide
    2. Chemical sprayer
    3. Mulch or compost
    4. Mower

    The sustainable agriculture practices we will be using include
    rotational grazing and intercropping.

     

    Objectives: 

    Our objectives center on discovering what symbiotic relationship
    can exist between sheep and Christmas trees and sharing the
    results of our research trials with other Christmas tree growers
    who will benefit.

    • Determine how many days sheep can graze within a Christmas
      tree plantation without disturbing the trees
    • Evaluate two systems of weed control in Christmas trees
    • Share findings through conference presentations
    Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.