Demonstrating the Feasibility of Producing Culturally Preferred Vegetable Crops in Underrepresented Urban Areas

Final report for FNC23-1373

Project Type: Farmer/Rancher
Funds awarded in 2023: $14,690.00
Projected End Date: 01/31/2025
Grant Recipient: City Sprouts
Region: North Central
State: Nebraska
Project Coordinator:
Aaron French
City Sprouts
Expand All

Project Information

Description of operation:

City Sprouts was founded in 1995 and incorporated the first community garden in Omaha. The organization has grown significantly in the past 30 years and now employs eight full-time staff dedicated to using urban agriculture as a platform to develop equitable food systems, provide educational experiences, and build community. In addition to its community garden and robust educational programs, City Sprouts operates a seven-acre urban vegetable farm in Northeast Omaha. The farm hosts 25 Urban Farming Interns annually and produces tens of thousands of pounds of produce for distribution to partner food banks and pantries. The farm was purchased in 2022 and City Sprouts staff has been increasing production, as well as implementing conservation practices since then.

Aaron French: Mr. French brings 13 years of professional vegetable production experience to City Sprouts having worked on commercial vegetable farms, in the non-profit agricultural sector and having managed a seven-acre farm business incubator program. Mr. French will oversee the operations of this program and help facilitate all aspects of the grant. The demonstration aspect of the grant will take place on the seven-acre City Sprouts Community Urban Farm, located north of downtown Omaha in the historically underserved Sherman neighborhood. City Sprouts utilizes a variety of sustainable production methods including reduced tillage, cover cropping, integrated pest and weed management programs and the use of conventional and walk-behind tractors with implements meant to reduce tillage impacts on soil health. The farm produces diverse vegetables, herbs and flowers.

Edgar Romero Gonzalez: Edgar joined City Sprouts in 2021 as the City Sprouts South Manager + Education Assistant. Edgar’s education background is in Horticulture, Land Systems, and Management. A graduate of the 2019 Growing Growers apprenticeship program at Stoney Crest Organic Urban Farm in Kansas City. Edgar will be assisting with the planning, production, and distribution aspects of the grant.

Laura Simpson: Laura joined the City Sprouts team in 2020 as the Programs + Distribution Coordinator. Their role is to develop and maintain partnerships with community organizations to distribute culturally preferred produce. Prior to City Sprouts, Simpson completed the Aspiring Farmer Residency Program in Omaha growing seasonal produce on 5 urban farm plots, CSA program, and market vending. Laura also completed the New Roots Internship with The Big Garden.

Mia Webb: Ms. Webb participated in the City Sprouts Urban Farming Internship in 2019 and returned in 2020 as an intern team leader, managing interns on City Sprouts’ urban farm. Ms. Webb was hired on as a permanent staff in 2022, facilitating educational experiences for and managing interns.

Urban Farming Interns: A crucial part of both the production and planning aspects of this grant program, the City Sprouts Urban Farming Interns are a diverse group of young people, primarily from Southeast Asia, Central America and Central / East Africa. Interns assist with the selection of culturally important crops for production as well as the planting, harvesting, and distribution of those crops.

Summary:

Omaha, like many similar sized cities, continues to face rising levels of food insecurity and an increasing population of immigrant and refugee families. These two issues often intersect, leaving vulnerable populations in need of governmental and nonprofit assistance for basic needs like housing, employment and most acutely, food. From 2010-2019 Nebraska resettled approximately 10,000 refugees, with over half settling in the greater Omaha area. By many estimates, this rate of resettlement has and will continue to increase following escalated conflicts around the world. Food banks are providing these communities with food services that help address base levels of food insecurity but often lack in fresh vegetables and specifically culturally preferred vegetables and herbs. According to a 2020 report from a state agency, over ⅔ of refugees in Nebraska report eating a vegetable less than once per day. Many of these preferred produce items are not available in traditional or culturally specific groceries or farmers markets, leaving new Americans with little to no access to important cultural and culinary resources. Another limiting factor in the availability of produce is the lack of knowledge amongst most urban and peri-urban farmers in the production practices of culturally preferred produce and herbs.

City Sprouts addressed the lack of knowledge regarding production practices of culturally preferred produce through the creation of a series of crop production guides. A survey and follow-up interviews conducted with participants in City Sprouts' Urban Farming Internship (most of whom are from the four geographic areas identified as priority) led to the selection of eight crops from four geographic regions. These crops were identified as both dietary and cultural staples by interviewees and survey participants and after initial research regarding City Sprouts' ability to produce these crops, the following vegetables, from the noted geographic areas, were selected for trialing. 


-Burma: Roselle + Thai Eggplant

-Burundi: Burundian Eggplant + Pumpkin Leaves

-Sudan / South Sudan: Molokhia + Black Eyed Pea Leaves

-Afghanistan: Tinda Gourd + Persian Cucumber

Throughout two growing seasons City Sprouts staff trialed these eight crops, recording all relevant details and identifying best practices for the production of these crops in Nebraska. Of particular importance was understanding the timing of these crops(with relation to planting and harvest), identifying potential pest/disease issues, and dialing in proper harvest procedures and post-harvest care. In addition to the eight production guides produced as part of this project, City Sprouts staff promoted the production of these culturally preferred crops at conferences, field days, and farm tours, including for NC-SARE administrative council and state coordinators. Growers from Omaha and other surrounding areas were able to view the production of these culturally preferred crops up close and in-person. Nearly 100 growers were able to discuss the specific production methods (and challenges) with City Sprouts staff as well as the culinary and cultural value with City Sprouts urban farming interns. The production guides are being distributed at urban agriculture networking and learning events throughout Omaha in the winter of 2025 and will continue to be shared widely. As demand grows, City Sprouts will continue to host specific producer workshops / skill-shares to focus on the production practices of these crops and will expand production of these, and other, crops to meet increasing needs among Omaha's growing refugee and immigrant populations experiencing food insecurity. As City Sprouts continues to expand its work supporting other local growers (primarily by offering greenhouse space and space in the shared-use wash/pack HarvestHub facility), more growers in urban and peri-urban areas around Omaha will hopefully adopt the production of these crops and be aided by the production guides created with this generous Farmer Rancher Grant funding from SARE.

Project Objectives:

In this demonstration and education project, City Sprouts will lean heavily on its large network of volunteers, staff, interns, community partners and associated urban farmers to identify and select three preferred crops from each selected culture (Burmese, Afghan, Iraqi, Somali, Sudanese / South Sudanese and Ukrainian) to grow on its seven acre farm. Crops will be identified through in depth interviews with current and former interns who represent these cultures as well as surveys distributed to community partners actively engaged with refugee populations. Once selected, a one-sheet production guide for each crop will be created by City Sprouts for distribution to other urban and peri-urban farmers in its extensive network as an educational resource.

City Sprouts has designed and delivered a survey to former interns, staff and community partners to gauge which culturally preferred crops would be most beneficial to study and create a growing guide for. Additionally, City Sprouts staff have conducted in-person interviews with growers and members of the identified communities to assess where market shortfalls exist in terms of produce availability. After assessing capacity and based on initial survey results, City Sprouts staff have decided to reduce both the number of crops and cultures to focus on, in order to provide higher quality growing guides. City Sprouts will engage with members of the Burmese, Burundian, Sudanese/South Sudanese and Afghan communities and have identified two crops per culture. The crops are as follows:

  • Burmese (Karen, Karenni, Chin): 
    • Sour Leaf / Sorrel: A type of hibiscus cultivated in Burma, Thailand and other parts of Southeast Asia, primarily for it's young, tender and bitter leaves. Used heavily to make stews and soups. 
    • Thai Eggplant: Called Thai eggplant but popular through parts of Burma, Thailand, Laos and Cambodia these small, spherical green eggplant vary wildly from Italian and French eggplants most commonly cultivated in the United States. 
  • Burundian:
    • Burundian Eggplant: A small white eggplant that ripens to a deep orange grown by Burundian refugees in Omaha. Seed gifted to City Sprouts by a grower in our network and sold at the Maranatha Market, a Burundian owned and operated grocer in Omaha. 
    • Pumpkin Leaves: Harvested when young and tender, the leaves are stewed and served as a relish (of sorts) with many dishes, known as muboora. Also commonly cultivated by Burmese growers in Omaha. 
  • Sudanese / South Sudanese:
    • Molokhia: Referred to here using the name of a dish commonly made with this plant in the mallow family. Also referred to as jute, the tender leaves are harvested and stewed with seasonings to create a mucilaginous stew common in both Sudan and South Sudan. 
    • Black Eyed Pea Leaves: While black eyed peas are commonly cultivated, particularly in the American south, growerS in Nebraska rarely harvest the leaves from these leguminous crops. Stewed in a similar way to molokhia, these are known in South Sudan as nyete. 
  •  Afghani:
    • Persian Cucumber: Small, smooth and seedless cucumbers are common in Afghan cuisine and valued as a snack or to prepare doogh, a yogurt and cucumber drink. 
    • Tinda / Apple Gourd: A small, round curcubit. This green gourd is harvested at a slightly immature stage and generally stuffed and steamed. 

2023 Update:

Not all the above listed crops were able to be grown during the 2023 season, so additional trials and production data will be gathered during the 2024 growing season. Crops that were grown during the 2023 season italicized above. 

The production guides will include information on seed sourcing (from organic / sustainable and BIPOC-owned sources, where possible), propagation and transplant management using minimal plastic, minimal and/or no-till field preparation, transplant / direct seeding guidance, irrigation requirements (with a focus on water conservation), integrated weed management, the use of both organic (leaf litter, straw, etc) and biodegradable, MATER-BI based mulch. Proper harvest and post-harvest handling instructions will also be included, as well as any understood pest issues.

In addition to the production guides, which will be available online on City Sprouts' website and social media and at public outreach events, City Sprouts promoted the production guides and our SARE-funded work at multiple field days, farm tours, and educational events. A specific field day had been planned with two partner organizations, but in the intervening years, both organizations went through periods of transition and were no longer able to participate. However, over 175 individuals participated in tours and field days and learned about our production trials. Of those 175, nearly 100 were active producers / growers and may adopt the production of these important, cultural crops. 

Through publicly demonstrating the sustainable production of these culturally preferred crops, creating and distributing production guides and hosting a field day with refugee-led community partners, City Sprouts will provide an example to other growers in the area that the production of culturally preferred crops is not just possible, but also potentially economically beneficial to their farm operation. Through its partnership with the Food Bank for the Heartland, City Sprouts is actively creating marketing opportunities for small-scale farmers to be compensated for growing and distributing culturally preferred produce through the Food Bank’s network of partner pantries. The demonstration and education portions of this program will lead directly to an increase in both the availability and accessibility of that produce while also increasing the economic viability of producing it for local growers.

OBJECTIVES (2024 updates in bold):

  • Demonstrate the use of five sustainable production techniques in growing culturally preferred vegetables (Ex: integrative pest and weed management, cover cropping, compost applications and sustainable tillage implements (Spring-Fall 2023)
    • City Sprouts demonstrated these techniques for culturally preferred vegetable crops in 2023 and will continue to demonstrate, record, and promote these techniques in 2024, particularly within the growing guides. 
    • City Sprouts demonstrated and recorded sustainable production techniques and practices for each of the 8 crops selected as part of this project. These production techniques included:
      • Use of soil-blocks for seed starting, eliminating conventional polystyrene greenhouse materials.
      • Use of 15 mil drip irrigation for water conservation and disease/fungus management. Drip irrigation was collected at the end of the season and saved for reuse the following year. 
      • Use of Bio360 Mater-Bi mulch for weed suppression and soil temperature regulation on early planted crops. Mulch was collected at the end of the season and commercially composted. 
      • Crops were planted in 36" beds with 33" walkways which were seeded with annual cover crops for weed control in walkways / harvest paths and to encourage beneficial, predatory and pollinator insect populations. Buckwheat was seeded at the time of bed forming (mid-May) and terminated with a flail mower in late June. At that point, oats were seeded and winterkilled after the crops had been removed. Both cover crops were seeded with an Earthway seeder with Beans / Small Pea plate at 3.6" spacing. Five rows were seeded of both species. 
      • While not noted in the production guides due to its cost and particular niche, a reticulating spader was used for bed prep in all production beds, limiting soil compaction and providing a hospitable seed bed for both direct seeded and transplanted crops. 
  • Produce 5,000 - 7,000 pounds, annually, of selected culturally preferred vegetables at the City Sprouts Urban Farm for distribution to local food pantries (Fall, 2023)
    • In 2023, City Sprouts produced over 15,000 lbs of produce for distribution to the Bountiful Harvest Food Pantry through its partnership with the Food Bank for the Heartland. Of those 15,000 lbs, 7,307 were categorized as culturally preferred. 
    • In 2024, City Sprouts produced nearly 16,000 lbs of produce for distribution to our community partners, including the Bountiful Harvest Food Pantry in partnership with the Food Bank for the Heartland. Of those 16,000 lbs, 8,404 were categorized as culturally preferred. 
  • Complete 10 interviews and receive 20 survey responses to identify culturally preferred produce from select populations (Spring, 2023)
    • City Sprouts received 8 survey responses regarding culturally preferred produce from select populations in 2023, a lower number than expected. However, City Sprouts staff engaged with 14 community members and growers to gather information regarding culturally preferred produce items. Survey responses will continue to be collected as City Sprouts still seeks to continue to learn and educate growers on the production of culturally preferred crops beyond the grant period. 
  • Create and distribute ten culturally preferred vegetable production guides to the large network of growers in the Omaha area (Spring, 2024)
    • City Sprouts has collected data, photos and practices and will continue to identify best practices to include in the production guides. The guides will most likely be ready for production and distribution by Fall, 2024.
    • City Sprouts, due to the limited capacity of staff and space on the farm, chose to only grow eight culturally preferred vegetable crops and thus produced eight production guides. These guides are uploaded on the City Sprouts website and will continue to be distributed to the urban and small-scale agriculture community. City Sprouts annually interacts with ~150 producers through its outreach events, farm tours, field days and community / grower workshops.
  • Engage 15 Omaha area farmers through a hands-on, production-focused field day (Fall, 2023)
    • City Sprouts hosted two large tours and field days in 2023. The first of which was in conjunction with the Nebraska Sustainable Agriculture Society and brought 27 farmers and food system professionals to the farm to learn about City Sprouts and the farms production methods, particularly as they relate to specialty, culturally preferred crops. City Sprouts also hosted 45 growers and food systems professionals at our first annual Soil Health Field Day. While the focus was not explicitly on this project, all attendees were extremely interested in our production methods and crops, and the field day spent ~1.5 hours discussing and touring the related fields. It was also an extreme pleasure to host members of the NCR-SARE Administrative Council and staff to our farm to learn about our work. 
    • City Sprouts continued to host field days in 2024, although none of them were specifically focused on the production of specialty crops. City Sprouts hosted 65 growers and food systems professionals attending the National Farm to School grant awardee conference in Omaha in September. Additionally, City Sprouts hosted staff from the USDA's Office of Urban Agriculture and Innovative Production in May. Staff, including the director of the office Brian Guse, were extremely intrigued and impressed with the production of culturally preferred crops. The farm was lucky enough to host the director of the NRCS, Terry Crosby, on the farm in October. While many of the crops involved in this project were out of production we were able to share small tastes of roselle and molokhia (unfortunately not very good raw). Lastly, City Sprouts hosted its second annual Soil Health Field Day, which brought 40 producers to the farm. In addition to excellent soil health information, they were able to explore and learn about the production methods for these specialty crops, with a particular focus on the conservation practices employed. 

Research

Materials and methods:

City Sprouts conducted interviews and distributed a survey to community partners, former and current interns, and other members of our community to gather information around which culturally preferred vegetable crops members of Omaha's Burmese, Sudanese, Afghan, and Burundian communities desired greater affordable access to. Several crops were identified and grown by City Sprouts in 2023. Information regarding the successful propagation, maintenance and cultivation of these crops were collected and recorded by City Sprouts and will be, along with information from the 2024 growing season, condensed into one-page growing guides for 8 culturally preferred vegetable crops that all grow well in our region.   

The 2023 season, like many growing seasons, didn't go exactly as we planned and so we were not able to produce all 8 varieties selected, nor were we able to host a specific SARE project-related field day. However, we purposefully built an additional season into our project and so will be trialing all 8 varieties in the spring and summer of 2024 to further fill out the growing guides we will produce and distribute in the fall of 2024. 

The 2024 growing season was productive and all 8 selected crops were trialed, documented, and analyzed for production challenges and opportunities. Relevant information was recorded and incorporated into the production guides. No additional surveys or interviews were conducted in 2024. 

 

Research results and discussion:

The results from the survey and interviews conducted with City Sprouts Urban Farming Interns and, informally, other urban and small-scale producers were mostly qualitative and based on individuals' personal experiences with the production of culturally preferred crops. 

Participation Summary
5 Farmers participating in research

Educational & Outreach Activities

54 Consultations
8 Curricula, factsheets or educational tools
7 On-farm demonstrations
15 Tours
4 Workshop field days

Participation Summary:

105 Farmers participated
55 Ag professionals participated
Education/outreach description:

As previously mentioned, City Sprouts hosts numerous educational events, field days, tours and workshops on our farm every year. With all of those events, we take special care to mention each project currently happening on our farm which includes this SARE Farmer-Rancher grant program. Since we were in year one of this project, we mostly informed visitors to our farm of what we had accomplished so far and what we were hoping to continue to accomplish with the rest of the grant period. All tours, workshops, field days and educational events were conducted by City Sprouts staff and most included some hands-on activities in the field. We have found the mix of tours plus hands-on activities to be most effective in learning both production practices and about specific cultural varieties. 

City Sprouts, as mentioned previously, hosted two large field days that spent significant time highlighting the production methods of specialty crops. The first field day was held in conjunction with the National Farm to School Network and brought 65 producers and food system professionals to the City Sprouts farm to discuss our production methods and innovative distribution channels City Sprouts employs to get culturally preferred produce to communities throughout Omaha. The second large event hosted was the annual Soil Health Field Day, which highlighted (among other things) the use of conservation tillage, irrigation, weed and pest management in the production of the eight selected crops. 

Learning Outcomes

45 Farmers reported changes in knowledge, attitudes, skills and/or awareness as a result of their participation
Lessons Learned:

Roughly halfway through this project, the City Sprouts team has learned much about the successful, and sometimes unsuccessful, production of culturally preferred vegetable varieties for distribution to area markets (in our case a food pantry associated with the Food Bank for the Heartland in Omaha, Nebraska). In year one we successfully identified several cultural crops that grow extremely well, even under less-than-ideal conditions. We learned a significant amount regarding the in-field management of those crops and perhaps our biggest takeaway so far is the harvest and post-harvest handling of these crops. Many are incredibly time-consuming to harvest in significant quantities by hand and our team will be experimenting with new and innovative ways to bulk harvest during the 2024 growing season. 

In 2024, City Sprouts honed in on the production methods for these eight crops and employed new strategies for harvesting several crops. In particular, molokhia leaves were previously harvested one by one when roughly 3" long. However, several staff and volunteers would harvest from a 100' bed for an hour and only have ~5 lbs. This harvesting method proved inefficient and, at the behest of urban farming interns, City Sprouts transitioned to harvesting sections of branches and distributing those together which significantly reduced harvest time. 

Project Outcomes

6 Farmers changed or adopted a practice
3 New working collaborations
Success stories:

City Sprouts, as part of this project, was able to expand on its produce distribution efforts this year. Previously all culturally preferred produce had been directed through a partnership with the Food Bank for the Heartland to a pantry serving the referenced populations. This year, however, City Sprouts made a connection with the All People's Pantry (APP), a project of the Hanscom Park United Methodist Church. APP is a quarterly food pantry distribution that focuses solely on providing culturally preferred foods to Omaha's refugee and immigrant communities. At their most recent quarterly distribution (December, 2024) APP distributed food to 238 households with individuals from 38 different countries. The pantry, prior to this past year had distributed virtually no fresh produce but City Sprouts provided over 500 lbs of fresh, culturally preferred produce to APP for their fall and winter pantry distribution. Fresh produce is one of the most consistently lacking items for food-insecure refugee populations in Omaha, according to the volunteer leadership of APP, and City Sprouts is excited to grow its involvement in this burgeoning new venture providing much-needed support in Omaha. 

Recommendations:

This project should serve as just the beginning of vegetable producers' exploration of the production of culturally preferred crops in eastern Nebraska and beyond. Beyond providing culturally important produce to populations who lack reliable access to it, it represents an enormous potential market, especially for urban and small-scale producers. Further study should be done to hone in on varieties, production methods, and in particular, marketing opportunities for these producers. Anectodally, growers outside of particular communities have had difficulty selling products to specialty food stores or international markets. Many of these markets exist, in particular, for the geographic regions this project focuses on, in Omaha and fresh, culturally specific produce is often hard to come by from regional and national suppliers. Growing the direct-to-market infrastructure for these crops (which often have relatively short shelf lives) could benefit growers greatly and should be looked into. 

Information Products

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.