Using Drones to Manage Orchards

Final report for FNC25-1472

Project Type: Farmer/Rancher
Funds awarded in 2025: $15,000.00
Projected End Date: 10/30/2026
Grant Recipient: Sweetland Orchard
Region: North Central
State: Minnesota
Project Coordinator:
Gretchen Merryweather
Sweetland Orchard
Expand All

Project Information

Description of operation:

The farmer and primary investigator on the project is Gretchen Merryweather. Gretchen has owned Sweetland Orchard since 2010 where she grows 5000 apple, pear, and tart cherry trees on six acres. She uses integrated pest management (IPM) to manage her orchard.

Summary:

Problem and Proposed Solution

With increasingly erratic weather patterns and more periods of heavy rain, it is difficult to get into the orchard early enough in growing season for effective scab management. Scab is the primary fungal disease of apples and it requires intensive management early in the growing season: first with a tractor and flail mower to pulverize prunings and then second, to get into the orchard with a tractor and an airblast sprayer to apply copper, an organic fungicide. Using a drone to apply copper in dormant conditions eliminates the need to take a tractor through the orchard in wet, early spring conditions thereby minimizing soil compaction, erosion, and general deterioration.

The potential benefits of using a drone for orchard crop management can be taken further into the growing season as well:

  • Further reducing soil deterioration by avoiding tractor and sprayer use,

  • Reducing the use of non-renewable fuel sources

  • Reducing the volume of insecticides used on the farm

  • Decreasing the time it takes for pesticide applications

Research Approach

The project assessed spray height, spacing, and material types toward the purpose of being able to specify best practices in using a drone for orchard management. After determining the suitability of different material types, we designated which orchard-specific products are suitable in orchard production. 

To assess spray efficacy we hung spray pattern test paper at twelve points within each of two spray areas:

  • at the four corners;

  • at four points in the middle of border rows;

  • at four equidistant points in the middle of the orchard block

Each point will have three spray pattern test papers:

  • at low branches approximately three feet from the ground;

  • at middle branches approximately six feet from the ground;

  • and at upper branches approximately nine feet from the ground.

Research Conclusions

After spraying 8 gallons per acre at different spacings and heights above the trees, we found that each condition provided suitable coverage based on the spray pattern paper with the exception spray area perimeters. The issue with the perimeter had more to do with wind speed and direction than spray volume or height. 

We also determined which pesticides commonly used by apple growers were approved for aerial application and what their formulations were -- dry or liquid -- since dry pesticides tended to clog nozzles and hoses in the drone. Those pesticides and their characteristics are summarized in a table at the end of the adjoining report. 

Farmer Adoption Actions

Drone spraying appears to be a feasible option, though low spray tank volume and brief battery life present significant obstacles. Assuming that drone spraying is as effective as tractor spraying, choosing which approach depends on other factors like orchard size, row length, row orientation, elevation challenges, and wet ground. 

Project Objectives:

Objectives

Determine optimal spray heights for central leader and tall spindle orchards for management with a spray drone.

Spray heights of 12' and 16' feet merited relatively equal results. 

Determine which material types are best suited for application with spray drones.

Liquid materials are easier to use in a drone since drones do not include agitation like airblast sprayers traditionally used in orchard management. 

Help growers determine if management via drone is the right choice for their orchards.

We developed a series of questions for orchardists to address when considering using a drone in their orchards. 

Develop guidance orchardists can use for orchard management via drone.

We developed a report that summarized guidance for orchard management via drone.

Research

Materials and methods:

The project involved using a drone to spray two different orchard blocks (one tall spindle at a density of 1000 trees per acre and one central leader at 200 trees per acre) at different spray heights. I used paper to determine the density of spray patterns for each variable at twelve different points: at the four corners; at four points in the middle of border rows; at four equidistant points in the middle of the orchard block. At each of those locations, I attached paper at low branches approximately three feet from the ground; at middle branches approximately six feet from the ground; and at upper branches approximately nine feet from the ground. I used two different spray heights to determine ideal  material penetration: 12 feet and 16 feet.

Research results and discussion:

I used 8 gallons per acre and determined that in the interior of each spray block, spray coverage was adequate for all conditions. Spray area perimeters were more problematic, though not uniformly problematic. These findings indicate that growers should pay special attention to spray area borders and make accommodations through spray area modifications (based on wind speed and direction, for example), and to reduce borders by spraying larger rather than smaller areas. 

Participation summary
1 Farmers/Ranchers participating in research
1 Ag service providers participating in research

Educational & Outreach Activities

1 Consultations
1 Curricula, factsheets or educational tools

Participation summary:

2 Farmers/Ranchers
1 Agricultural service providers
Education/outreach description:

I created a report summarizing the results of my project.

After SARE publicized my project, I was contacted by two growers and one educator about it and so I sent my report to them. 

Learning Outcomes

Lessons Learned:

Considerations for Spraying Tree Fruit with a Drone

This report is intended to address growers’ questions about the experience of using a drone to manage an orchard’s spray program. The report addresses “boots on the ground” experience with a drone but does not cover other key questions related to using a drone in an orchard such as drone selection, nozzle calibration, and best practices.

This guide reflects my experience with one particular drone, a DJI Agras T30, at one particular orchard. The T30 has an eight-gallon tank. I have three batteries and an indoor charger. Battery life is about ten minutes, which is a brief enough period of time to be fairly inconvenient. DJI does make a generator-powered charger that charges the batteries quickly. Indoor charges takes about 40 minutes per battery.

There are a number of characteristics of my situation that made drone spraying appear to be an attractive option for me:

  • My acreage is relatively small – only about six acres

  • My orchard has short rows set up in different orientations – some rows are east-west, some are north-south, some are northeast-southwest.

  • I am okay not driving a tractor

  • I have an affinity for digital technology versus engines and hydraulics

  • In the spring, my orchard tends to be wet

  • My orchard has some elevations that are challenging for traversing with a tractor

Bottom line: if you spray with a tractor and are happy with that approach, keep taking that approach. There is no research yet to suggest that orchard spraying with a drone is superior to orchard spraying with a tractor and an airblast sprayer. At the same time, there is no research to suggest drone spraying is inferior to tractor/airblast spraying. In my particular case, tractor spraying took an inordinate amount of time due to short rows with different orientations and so I was interested in exploring the feasibility of using a drone to spray.

Starting Your Spray Day

I discovered that my “home base” wasn’t conducive to efficient drone spraying since it used valuable battery life just to get from my charging station to the start of the spray area, so I generally left the drone out in the orchard and transported the following out to the drone on a utility vehicle:

  • Spray materials

  • Measurement devices (scale/volumetric measuring container)

  • Water jugs

  • Mixing container (a five-gallon container with a screw-top opening)

  • Drone batteries, fully charged

  • Remote, fully charged

  • PPE

Mixing

When you are spraying at a small scale, your mixing technology needn’t be expensive or fancy. I have a designated mixing container that I use to combine materials. I add water first and then add the spray materials in the designated order, mixing between each addition. Agitation is provided by manually shaking/inverting the mixing container. I then add the contents of my mixing container to the drone’s tank, alternating with water.

Applying

Researchers at Penn State and Michigan State are engaged in establishing best practices for drone spraying fruit trees; those best practices are beyond the scope of this guide. It is important to be aware of this research because it will ultimately provide useful information about spray nozzle types, spray volumes, and spray patterns. I found that the minimum gallons per acre specified by product labels sprayed at 18’ feet from the ground in roughly alternate rows parallel to the tree rows provided adequate coverage on spray paper placed at three different heights in the canopy. My drone’s speed was set according to the gallons per acre I wanted to spray, so I did not treat speed as a variable.

The advice coming out of those two research programs is to spray 15-25 gallons per acre and to treat the label guidance for gpa as minimal. Given short battery life and a small tank, it will be tempting to use those minimums. I haven’t found those minimums to be problematic. What I have found to be more problematic are materials and spray area perimeters.

Because the drone does not have built-in agitation, dry spray materials – especially powders – are prone to settling and clogging; therefore I suggest modifying your drone-based spray program to use liquids to the extent possible. If liquids are not possible, use a water-dispersable granule rather than a wettable powder. See the attached spreadsheet for aerial-application-approved pesticides and growth regulators and their characteristics of dry versus liquid.

I’ve also found issues with spray area perimeters, namely that coverage on perimeters has been less than optimal. There are a couple of ways to address perimeter challenges:

  • Use larger spray areas to reduce spray area borders. I have used large areas and small areas. In large areas, the challenge is battery life; however, I will trade challenges associated with interrupted sprays due to battery life for insufficient pesticide coverage.

  • Pay careful attention to wind direction and speed and modify your spray area to accommodate those differences from one spray day to the next.

Clean-Up

After spraying, I rinse the tank and spray lines out, much as you would for your airblast sprayer.

Conclusions

In conclusion, for orchardists trying to decide if drone-based spraying is right for them: there is no single correct answer. Consider the factors I listed above (access in wet conditions, spray time on a tractor, material selection, comfort with tractors versus digital technology, equipment investment) to determine if drone spraying is an option for you. If you are unsure about the results associated with using a drone to spray, stay tuned for research coming out of Penn State and Michigan State within the next year.

2 Farmers/Ranchers gained knowledge, skills and/or awareness
1 Agricultural service providers gained knowledge, skills and/or awareness

Project Outcomes

1 Farmers/Ranchers changed or adopted a practice
2 New working collaborations
Recommendations:

SARE has already funded a project out of Penn State that will provide a valuable research-based approach for drone spraying in terms of drone efficacy versus tractor efficacy. 

Information Products

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.