Evaluation of Various Legumes for use as Green Manure Cover Crops

Final report for FNC92-001

Project Type: Farmer/Rancher
Funds awarded in 1992: $2,715.00
Projected End Date: 12/31/1993
Matching Non-Federal Funds: $3,330.00
Grant Recipient: Phil and Barbara Hueneke Farm
Region: North Central
State: Iowa
Project Coordinator:
Phil and Barbara Hueneke
Phil and Barbara Hueneke Farm
Expand All

Project Information



Our family operation consists of 280 acres on which we raise corn, oats, barley, and alfalfa in a rotation. We also maintain a herd of 55 stock cows, 15 sows farrow to finish, and raise 800 fryers.

We purchased our farm in 1977 and farmed with chemicals until 1980. At this time we began a program to eliminate all chemicals and insecticides. In 1983 we used chemicals on one field and that was the last chemicals we have used on the farm. We also eliminated the use of insecticides at the same time. By using crop rotation, ecological fertilizers, and natural products we replaced the chemical insecticides.

The following people provided assistance with the grant program for 1993: William Lansing, soil consultant, provided fertilizer recommendations including calcium and trace elements. Don Irwin, district manager for Dairyland Seed provided the clover seed to use as a cover crop. At the beginning of the project I invited the following people to a meeting at our farm: Denise Chevalier, ISU Organic Project Associate, Greg Welsh, ISU Organic Ag Specialist, and Brad Parkell, New Perspective Video. At this meeting we outlined a plan of action to make the cover crop video.


1) Implementing sustainable agricultural practices

* Barriers
- Lack of on farm data and results
- Finances to purchase equipment
- Lack of time and finances to actually measure the results of the green manure cover corps

* Goal
- Use available equipment and the grant money to finance research to measure the effect of the cover crops on the soil and the corn yields.

2) Project Description
* The project began in July 1992. There were three plots. The first plot was an old stand of alfalfa which was plowed down in the spring of 1993. The second plot was of straight clover which was seeded with barley in 1992. The last plot was interseeded with clover between the rows of corn in July of 1992 during the second cultivation. I took soil samples of each plot and also tissue tested the corn plant during the growing season.
* I learned that the clover cover crop can supply much of the nitrogen needed to grow a crop of corn. The clover also causes the soil to stay mellow and to break apart easily when it is tilled. The clover also suppressed the grassy weeds in the spring before it is tilled into the soil.

3) My objective was to determine how much purchased nitrogen I could replace with home grown nitrogen by using green manure cover crops. With the experience I have gained this year I believe a farmer can grow most of the nitrogen you need to raise a crop of corn.

4) The fields were soil tested at the beginning and at the end of the growing season. Plant tissue tests where taken in July and we also yield checked the different plots. When I use the green manure crops again there are three things I would try. When interseeding I would mix in one or two additional types of seed such as rye grass, hairy vetch or nitro alfalfa. I would also no-till interseed winter rye into old stand of alfalfa or clover which would increase the amount of plow down the next year. I also need to till the clover sooner in the spring before it stands 6-8” tall.

5) Discussion: Due to my inexperience with cover crops and all the wet weather it has been hard to draw any definite conclusions from one years use. I did see enough benefits to continue to work with the cover crops. By making the changes listed I believe there are a lot of economic and biological benefits of cover crops. I would recommend other farmers to start to work with cover crops to gain actual experience.


Throughout the growing season we video taped each step we took to include green manure cover crops into the raising of a crop of corn. All the video taping was edited in 15-20 minutes. The finished video will be made available to interested people through direct mailing and advertising in the New Farm Magazine. A farm tour was held on September 16, 1993. About 50 people attended the farm tour. Written results and overhead transparencies are made and will also be used at meetings to share the results with other people.


Materials and methods:
  • Phil and Barbara Hueneke will provide 4 parcels of land, 2.5 acres each, to compare the different green cover crops that could replace purchased nitrogen.
  • Steve Schroeder, FFA instructor, will oversee the nitrogen tissue testing to see which green cover crops will provide the best source of nitrogen.
  • Keith Cuvelier, soil consultant, will provide fertilizer recommendations from soil tests.

1992: Establish red clover, alfalfa and interseed red clover in growing corn in 1992 in 3 separate parcels (already accomplished).

1993: No-till rye into alfalfa.

  1. Soil test
  2. Chisel plow under green manure crops
  3. Plant corn
  4. Tissue test during growing season. Throughout the 1993 growing season, we will be tissue testing to determine any nitrogen/nutrient deficiencies. 
  5. Yield check each parcel at harvest


Research results and discussion:



Green manure comparison data

Green Manure Comparison - handout for farm tour on September 16, 1993

Green manure comparison, Nitrogen fertilizer purchase and yield


Green manure comparison-tissue test for Nitrogen in corn


Participation Summary
2 Farmers participating in research

Educational & Outreach Activities

1 Tours

Participation Summary:

Education/outreach description:


Newspaper article


Press release for field day 9-16-1993

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the view of the U.S. Department of Agriculture or SARE.