Progress report for LNC21-445
Riparian systems are essential to maintaining key ecosystem services such as water regulation, biodiversity, wildlife habitat, and forage for grazing livestock. In some instances, removal of natural hydrological features (beaver dams) and heavy livestock utilization has caused degradation, stream bank erosion, channel incisions, and head-cutting. The result is soil erosion, poor water quality, loss of wildlife habitat, and reduced grassland economic potential. Recent research has been conducted on the use of low-cost, low-tech tools (LCLTT) that mimic beaver dams as a method for restoring riparian health. LCLTT such as beaver dam analogs (BDAs) have successfully been implemented in the Western U.S. to restore ecosystem services within degraded small and ephemeral streams and wet meadows. These earthen, natural material structures slow and disperse water, dissipate energy, and restore natural floodplains, improving soil water retention and increasing riparian vegetation. Despite benefits, LCLTT have not been adopted in North Central Region (NCR) grasslands due to lack of knowledge, producer apprehension and skepticism surrounding beavers, and a lack of trained technical experts and producer peer mentors. Thus, without research, extension, and educational programs to teach producers about the benefits of LCLTT and their role in riparian and rangeland health, riparian systems within the NCR will likely continue to see a decline in both environmental quality and profitability.
For this project our objectives are to 1) research the impact of LCLTT on soil moisture, riparian vegetation, and biomass production and 2) develop on-site demonstrations, trainings, and workshops for producers and technical experts on the implementation of LCLTT to improve hydrological function. We will specifically research the impact and efficacy of LCLTT on forage production, plant community composition, and soil moisture at a research field station and on producer ranches. We will test, demonstrate, and monitor practices in local settings with producers, allowing them to implement their grazing plans in conjunction with our work. Our inter-disciplinary team (range ecology and management and riparian health ecology) will work with producer participants to host field tours and workshops throughout the project to highlight successes and any limitations that arise. This will allow for flowing conversations to occur between producers and technical experts about potential adoption of LCLTT and will therefore create a holistic understanding of implementing LCLTT in the NCR. Overall, our long-term goal is to improve watershed health at landscape scales in grassland ecosystems and educate producers about the benefits of LCLTT.
- Research LCLTT’s impact on forage production, plant community composition, and soil moisture.
- Implement LCLTT on cooperating ranches and at a research field station.
- Teach technical experts and producers about LCLTT through trainings and workshops.
- Learn how to deploy LCLTT on public and private lands.
- Educate producers on riparian health.
- Technical experts construct LCLTT on public lands; assist producers on private lands.
- Producers more widely accept LCLTT and implement LCTT on their operations.
- Improved riparian health means less soil erosion, improved wildlife habitat and ranch profitability.
This progress report includes activities from November 1, 2021 to December 31, 2022. Below we provide an overview of activities that occurred during Year 1 of our grant. We have had great success so far, and are excited to see where this project is at the end of the grant's life.
Our hypothesis for this research is that LCLTT structures such as BDAs will increase the following: available soil moisture, forage production, and the prevalence of wetland and facultative wetland plant species such as prairie cordgrass near the stream.
This project builds upon a pilot project implemented by TNC in 2020 to restore riparian health in prairie streams in western South Dakota using LCLTT such as BDAs. The overall goals of our project are to increase awareness and adoption of riparian restoration programs by 1) providing critical research on LCLTT and impacts on forage production, plant community composition, and soil moisture and 2) conducting outreach and extension activities for producers on site selection, materials, and construction techniques for implementing LCLTT restoration techniques on their operation.
Intended Audience: The intended audience for this proposal includes technical experts (federal, state, NGO, university partners) and livestock producers within the NCR.
Site Selection: Research for this project will take place on five producer ranches as well as the SDSU Cottonwood Field Station (CFS) located near Philip, SD. The CFS is used primarily for livestock grazing and lies within a Northern Mixed Grass Prairie ecosystem. Topography of the station is gently sloping with long, rolling hills and relatively flat-topped ridges. The CFS lies within the Pierre Shale Plains major land resource area (MLRA) (MLRA 60A). Soils of the mixed-grass prairie research pastures are predominantly Kyle and Pierre clays developed from the Pierre formation (shale). Cottonwood Creek is an intermittent stream within the Bad River watershed and meanders through approximately 3 miles of the CFS boundary across 4 pastures. Long-term (>40 years) livestock grazing within pastures containing Cottonwood Creek has resulted in stream bank erosion, channel incision, and head-cutting, impairing riparian function throughout the property.
In 2019, TNC developed a web-based tool (missouriheadwaterstool.org) to foster collaboration at a watershed scale to enhance riparian health efforts among partners in Western South Dakota, North Dakota, Montana, and Wyoming. The tool aggregates spatial datasets such as ecological sites, rangeland potential, hydrologic data, elevation, slope, and satellite imagery to help identify intactness, erosion potential, drought vulnerability, and resilience of riparian areas. This tool will be used to identify riparian areas on cooperator ranches with the highest potential for enhancement using LCLTT. Cooperator ranches will be located within MLRA 60A to minimize differences in soil type and land potential allowing for comparison of results between sites. Data collection is the same for Research and Demonstration aspects of this project, and for simplicity, is described only once.
Hypothesis: LCLTT will increase riparian vegetation, biomass production, and soil moisture content compared to untreated stream reaches.
Restoration Treatments: Six stream reaches suitable for riparian restoration will be identified at each site (CFS and the 5 producer ranches). Stream reaches will be randomly allocated into a control (no restoration) and a LCLTT. This will be a complete randomized block design with producer ranches as blocks and reaches as the experimental unit.
Vegetation Data Collection: Along each of the 6 stream reaches per site, three vegetation transects will be established and measured prior to the LCLTT implementation to collect baseline vegetation data. Vegetation transects (50 m) will be established perpendicular to the stream channel and span the valley bottom width. Along each transect, a pin flag will be dropped every 50cm and all plant species that contact the pin flag will be recorded. Vegetation transects will be measured in the summer of Years 1, 2, and 3. Data from the plant transects will be used to analyze species composition within riparian areas to compute similarity indexes between current vegetation composition and historical states as defined by ecological site descriptions. Data will be statistically analyzed for treatment effects within and between years.
Vegetation biomass will be evaluated using 0.25 m2 permanent plots; 3 plots will be randomly located in each stream reach segment within the floodplain area. Livestock exclusion cages will be used to protect plot vegetation from grazing. Plots will be evaluated once each growing season in Years 1, 2, and 3 during peak biomass production (July-August). Data collected in each plot will include: 1) a complete species list, 2) percent cover for each species, 3) height of each species, and 4) non-destructive biomass estimates of each species using a double sampling technique. Biomass composition (based on biomass and cover), species richness, and a Shannon-Weiner diversity index will be derived from the plot data. Response variables will be statistically analyzed for treatment effects within and between years.
Within each stream reach, two photo monitoring points will be established at opposite ends of the reach. Digital photographs will be taken at each photo point during biomass sampling. Photo monitoring is a valuable qualitative tool for documenting current conditions of a site as well as tracking changes due to treatment or management differences. Photo point data will be used for demonstration and extension materials.
Soil Moisture Data Collection: State-of-the-art sensors for soil water content, soil temperature, and soil electrical conductivity will be used to determine seepage of soil moisture at 0, 6, 12, and 18-inch depths at two locations (1 LCLIT and 1 Control) at each site. Soil moisture will be collected using probes for measuring soil volumetric water content (e.g. HOBOnet Multi-Depth Soil Moisture Sensor, Bourne, MA). Soil probes will be installed 10 m from the edge of the stream channel within the flood plain. Once installed, the sensors will record measurements at 15-minute time intervals for the entire study period. Sensors will be connected to a wireless network to allow data to be received and downloaded from a central location. Differences in soil moisture will be statistically analyzed for treatment effects within and between years.
Methodology for the Outreach and Extension activities are described below in the appropriate section.
Research objective: Research LCLTT’s impact on forage production, plant community composition, and soil moisture.
Research progress as of 12/31/2022:
- We hired a Graduate Research Assistant, James Bolyard. James started January 2022. James was born and raised in southwestern Michigan. After spending several years pursuing medical studies, he graduated from Northern Michigan University in 2015 with a B.A. in Environmental Science, whereupon he spent much of the next six years working with AmeriCorps, NGOs, and various Federal agencies as a seasonal employee in several capacities. James comes to this project with extensive working knowledge of LCLTT for riparian restoration and has been a great addition to the project's team.
- We established 4 sites in 2022; the watershed size above sites varies from 12 km2 to 460 km2. The associated Major Land Resource Area (MLRA) is noted.
- Upper Battle Creek - MLRA 60A.
- Lower Battle Creek - MLRA 60A.
- Newell (SD) Producer - MLRA 60A.
- South Dakota State University (SDSU) Cottonwood Field Station - MLRA 63 A.
- Several additional producer sites were identified in 2022, but due to limited access (i.e., producer operations are located on "gumbo" - sticky, high clay soils that make it difficult to access the site unless it is dry) we were unable to complete any LCLTT installation. These sites are now priority for the 2023 field season.
- At each site, the stream width was measured at 20 random points. A stream reach was defined as the stream length equal to 20 average stream widths. Three (3) control reaches were located upstream, and 3 treatment reaches were located downstream. This experimental design was to avoid confounding the effects of the treatment reaches and also included a minimum of 2 reaches as a buffer between the end of the control reaches and the start of the treatment reaches (Figure 1).
- 1.08 miles of stream - this includes the stream reach equivalent above each treatment reach that should see at least some improvement from implementation of the structures.
- 28 structures were built across all sites (Figure 2).
- Structures were installed by AmeriCorps crews in June and July 2022. A mixture of beaver dam analogs (BDAs) and post-assisted log structures (PALs) were used, depending on available materials and site conditions.
- Structures range from <0.3 m to ~ 1.3 m tall and <1 m to >4 m wide.
- Soil moisture probes were installed.
- We are using 45 cm long Hobo Multi-depth soil probes that do soil moisture readings at 0-15 cm, 15-30 cm, and 30-45 cm depths.
- Two probes at each site - 1 probe in a treatment reach and 1 probe in a control reach.
- Readings every 15 min, with broadcast to the cloud every 1 hr.
- Plant community data was collected.
- 50 m transects, 4 transects per reach using the line-point intercept technique
- Non-destructive biomass estimates were collected from 0.5 m2 plots; 3 plots per reach
- We have had notable early success at the SDSU Cottonwood Field Station!!
- We installed structures at Cottonwood in July 2022. Figure 3 shows a yellow line, which is where one of our structures was located. We received several inches of rain, causing a few structures - including the one denoted by the yellow line - to blow out. At the same time, we noticed signs of beaver activity on the stream! The beavers reestablished themselves at Cottonwood and built several beaver dams themselves, one of which is noted by the red line in Figure 3 and a close up is provided in Figure 4. Figure 3 clearly demonstrates the benefit of LCLTT such as BDAs in slowing and holding water on the landscape, which is further benefitted by beaver recolonizing the area.
- Of note is that LCLTT structures are not meant to be permanent - instead, they are designed to do exactly what occurred at Cottonwood. The slowing and holding of water on the landscape resulted in water being backed up on Cottonwood Creek further than it has ever been documented before - well into September.
Anticipated research activities in 2023:
- Finish site selection
- Install structures on new sites
- Conduct plant community assessments, including biomass
- Check on soil probe functionality and re-establish connection, if needed
- Structure maintenance on existing sites
2. Outreach and Extension Activities
New and unfamiliar practices are difficult to export without allowing ranchers and partners to see the benefits. The 5 producers involved in this project will serve as producer peer mentors (2 of which we have already identified, please see Commitment Letters). Producers will be compensated monetarily for their time and effort, with two payment schedules - one payment at the start of the project and one payment at the completion of the project. Working with producers will benefit the project in several ways. First, these producers own and operate on private and public lands, creating avenues for collaboration among multiple agencies (e.g., BLM and NRCS) and groups (NGOs like TNC, as well as SDSU). Second, new practices are sometimes perceived as high risk and if presented by NGOs, are perceived as threatening. Working with producers who have strong partnerships with TNC and SDSU will remove a layer of skepticism.
Workshops and Trainings: Workshops and trainings will be held at each producer’s ranch. The cooperating producer ranches will serve as an important bridge between the research aspect of the project and adoption of LCLTT to help restore riparian function. The focus of these workshops will be on riparian health education and implementation of LCLTT, and will utilize a new tool developed in cooperation with SDSU Extension, NRCS, and TNC - the Guide to Classification and Management of Western South Dakota Prairie Streams (“Stream Guide”). The Stream Guide provides valuable information to producers and technical staff on stream health metrics, and will serve as a basis for field demonstration days.
Workshops will discuss with livestock producers the importance of riparian health to livestock production, grazing management considerations for riparian areas, and the potential benefits and consequences associated with healthy and unhealthy riparian systems. We will use and point participants to sections of the Stream Guide that walk through how to conduct a stream health assessment. Additional tutorials will demonstrate to attendees how to assess current riparian condition and methods for measuring and monitoring riparian plant communities. During the workshops, we will introduce the concepts behind LCLTT restoration techniques to help dissipate energy from stream runoff and reconnect stream channels to floodplains. A focus of the program will be to highlight which stream reaches are appropriate for LCLTT restoration techniques to maximize success. We will then describe the materials and construction methods for installing BDA type structures within stream beds, as well as provide information for sourcing materials locally. Workshops will conclude by constructing a BDA on site.
Field Days: Field tours will be conducted at the CFS to highlight LCLTT methods for restoring riparian function. A benefit to hosting field days at the SDSU CFS is to demonstrate to producers that the organizations involved on this project (SDSU, TNC) are invested partners in restoring riparian function. A focus of the field days will be to discuss research results from the overall project including differences observed between treatment groups in biomass production, plant community composition, and soil moisture retention. In addition, overall landscape level benefits to implementing these strategies will be discussed.
Publications and Videos: We will use several avenues to disseminate information about this project. Extension publications will be used to communicate project status and findings to general audiences such as the public and producers. Once all data is collected, we will transform it into key takeways that will be shared in an Extension Fact Sheet. We will capture video using GoPros at specific parts of the project, namely during the site selection, material selection, and BDA construction phases. These videos will translate 1,000s of words into an easily digestible format that can be paused and rewatched countless times. Producer peer mentors will be involved in these videos, if they wish, so that their viewpoint can be recognized and shared with their peers. Peer-reviewed journal articles will share information with a wider scientific audience, and expand on the knowledge base of how LCLTT function outside of montane ecoregions.
Educational & Outreach Activities
- Bolyard J. Meeting with Newell Producer. 2022 May. Belle Fourche, SD.
- Bolyard J. Meeting with Philip Producer. 2022 May. Philip, SD.
-Webinars, talks, and presentations:
- Bolyard J, K Ehlert, and J Brennan. 2022 September 19. Low-cost, low-tech tools for riparian restoration. South Dakota Conservation District Annual Meeting. Chamberlain, SD.
- Direct contacts: 50 adults.
- Bolyard J, K Ehlert, and J Brennan. 2022 November 18. Low-cost, low-tech tools for riparian restoration. South Dakota State University, Natural Resource Management Department seminar. Brookings, SD.
- Direct contacts: 40 adults.
-Workshops and field days:
- Bolyard J, K Ehlert, and J Brennan. 2022 October 12. Beavers and low-cost, low-tech tools for riparian restoration. South Dakota Section - Society for Range Management Annual Meeting. Wall, SD.
- Direct contacts: 35 adults.
- 2023 January. Start an article series (4 or 5 articles total) highlighting the importance of riparian restoration. Have 1 article released approximately every other month.
- 2023 February. Present research at the Society for Range Management (SRM) 2023 annual meeting in Boise, ID.
- 2023 March. Present research at the Black Hills Ecology and Botany Workshop annual meeting in Rapid City, SD.
- 2023 March-June. Producer meetings for potential sites.
- 2023 October. Present research at the South Dakota Student Water Conference in Brookings, SD.