Enhancing Farm Sustainability: How Can Management Strategies Reduce the Negative Impacts of Clostridium and Mycotoxins Contamination on the TMR?

Progress report for ONE24-440

Project Type: Partnership
Funds awarded in 2024: $28,069.00
Projected End Date: 10/31/2026
Grant Recipient: University of Maryland
Region: Northeast
State: Maryland
Project Leader:
Fabiana de Freitas Cardoso
University of maryland
Expand All

Project Information

Project Objectives:

This project seeks to address the problem of mycotoxins and
Clostridium contamination in TMR samples through a
comprehensive research and outreach strategy. We aim to: (1)
Assess Occurrence of Clostridium and Mycotoxins
in TMR
: We hypothesize that the source of contamination
of Clostridium and mycotoxins in TMR is due to the
conditions and management practices adopted on the farm. The
project will involve visiting 30 commercial dairy farms in
Maryland to collect TMR samples. The selection of farms will be
based on a survey identifying those experiencing challenges with
Clostridium or mycotoxin contamination. From these
farms, TMR samples will be collected and analyzed to determine
the presence and levels of Clostridium and mycotoxins,
providing crucial insights into the extent of contamination in
dairy cow diets; (2) Establish Effective Forage and TMR
Management Practices
: Based on the findings from the
analysis, the project will work towards establishing effective
forage and TMR management practices for controlling
Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination. This may
involve recommendations for proper harvesting techniques, storage
practices, and the use of mycotoxin binders to mitigate risks to
animal health and safety; (3) Understand Impact on Animal
Health, Performance and Reproduction
: By analyzing the
collected TMR samples and correlating them with health,
performance, and reproduction data gathered from the farms, the
project aims to follow the farms over the course of the project
(years 1 and 2) to be able to associate the level of
contamination with the performance and health status of animals.

Introduction:

Clostridium contamination is a reality in feeds used for animal diets and in the farm environment (March et al., 2018). The occurrence of Clostridium in dairy farms is a concern for dairy producers because their spores can contaminate the soil, animal feed, TMR, and feces (Bermúdez et al., 2016a), which could contaminate raw milk (Borreani et al., 2013). When spoiled silage is included in the TMR, it contributes mostly to the increase in spore content of TMR and consequently increases animal's exposure to Clostridium (Borreani et al., 2019). Consumption of clostridia and its products in poor quality fermented feeds have been reported to negatively impact the rumen environment and dry matter intake (Driehuis et al., 2018; Zucali et al., 2014). One of the most prevalent bacteria detected in dairy farms is C. perfringens, (March et al., 2018). Under certain conditions and predisposing host factors, certain species (spp.) can produce potent toxins and cause disease (Songer, 1996). Managing Clostridium prevalence in animal feeds is important to prevent its negative impacts on animal health, performance and reproduction.

            Similarly, forages can be contaminated with several mycotoxins in the field pre-harvest, during storage, or after ensiling during feed-out. Exposure to dietary mycotoxins adversely affects the performance and health of livestock and can compromise human health. These toxins, produced by molds such as Aspergillus and Fusarium, can cause health issues in dairy cows, including reduced feed intake, decreased milk production, and even acute illness (Ogunade et al., 2018). Addressing this problem requires implementing strategies like proper harvesting techniques, monitoring feed ingredients, and using mycotoxin binders to ensure the safety of dairy cow diets and protect both animal and human health.

            Top of Form

To address this issue, our project aims to select farmers that are facing Clostridium and or mycotoxins challenge and provide support by offering comprehensive analysis services for detecting Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination. These services are often expensive and inaccessible to many farmers, so offering them will help farmers identify and address contamination issues on their farms. By analyzing farm records, we will gain insights into how the prevalence of Clostridium and mycotoxins may affect dairy cows’ health, performance, and reproduction, allowing us to implement management strategies to mitigate contamination effectively. By identifying potential sources of contamination and establishing effective management practices, the project will contribute to the resilience and sustainability of dairy farming in the Northeast region. Working closely with farmers, we will develop and implement best management practices to reduce Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination in animal feeds. In addition to implementing best management practices, we will disseminate educational materials to promote accessibility and equity in agricultural knowledge and resources. This outreach effort will empower farmers with the tools and information they need to address contamination challenges effectively and ensure the sustainability and economic viability of their operations. This approach will involve analyzing TMR samples (Dry Matter, Clostridium, Enterobacteria count, mold and yeast count with ID, Basic Mycotoxins (AFL/DON/T2/ZEA), Starch, in situ 7 hour Starch Digestibility , and NIR measures for the comprehensive nutrition package), collecting data records (milk yield, milk components, feeding management, stock rate, percent of herd pregnant by 150 days in milk (DIM), percent of heifers bred and percent pregnant at 15 to 17 months old, percentage of abortions in heifers and cows, and health parameters), and engaging with the farming community to raise awareness and promote sustainable agricultural practices. Ultimately, our project aims to improve the safety and quality of animal feeds, leading to enhanced livestock health and productivity while reducing the risks associated with contaminated feeds in Maryland's dairy farming industry.
            The agricultural industry needs effective solutions to address Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination in animal feeds. Farmers face significant losses due to decreased productivity, veterinary expenses, and potential market rejections of contaminated products. Potential results from our project could improve feed production practices and benefit farmers in several ways. Quantifying the economic, social, and environmental impacts of these potential results is crucial for demonstrating the significance of our research. For instance, reducing feed contamination can lead to higher livestock productivity, decreased veterinary costs, and increased market acceptance, resulting in improved farm incomes and profitability.
            Expected Impact on Sustainable Agriculture: Our proposed solution aligns with the goals of sustainable agriculture in the Northeast region by addressing two aspects of sustainability: (1) Reduction of Environmental and Health Risks: By mitigating Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination in animal feeds, our project aims to protect animal and human health and decrease feed waste. This contributes to the overall sustainability of agricultural practices by promoting safer and more environmentally friendly feed production methods; (2) Improved Productivity and Cost Reduction: By enhancing feed safety and quality, farmers can expect improvements in livestock productivity and health, leading to reduced costs associated with veterinary treatments and losses due to contaminated products. This increase in efficiency and profitability contributes to the economic viability of farming operations. By advancing current knowledge and developing effective mitigation strategies, we seek to promote sustainable agriculture in the Northeast region, aligning with the goals of Northeast SARE's outcome statement.

Cooperators

Click linked name(s) to expand/collapse or show everyone's info
  • Brian Forsythe

Research

Materials and methods:

Time Period

Activity

 

Duration

March 2024

Develop Survey: Electronic survey was created to assess dairy producers' concerns and interest in the program.

 

Completed

April 2024

Distribute Survey: Send out electronic survey to dairy producers via Maryland Extension email lists and social media channels.

 

Completed

May 2024

Survey Analysis: Analyze survey responses to identify farms experiencing challenges with Clostridium or mycotoxin contamination.

 

Completed

June 2024

Selection of Farms: Choose 30 commercial dairy farms in Maryland based on survey results to participate in the project.

 

Completed

August 2024

Meet with partner farmer and TMR Collection (First farm visit): Visit selected farms to collect TMR samples.

 

Completed

August 2024

TMR Analysis (First farm visit): Ship TMR samples to testing facility for analysis of Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination.

 

Completed

October – January 2025

Data Analysis (First farm visit): Analyze TMR analysis results and correlate with management, health, reproduction, and performance data gathered from farms.

 

Completed

February 2025

Educational Materials: Develop and distribute educational materials on Clostridium and mycotoxin management to participating farms. Abstract submission for ADSA meeting to present partial data

 

working on it

June 2025

TMR Collection (Second farm visit): Repeat TMR collection process at the same 30 farms.

 

1 week

June- April July

TMR Analysis (Second farm visit): Ship TMR samples to testing facility for analysis of Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination.

 

1 month

July - August 2025

Data Analysis (Second farm visit): Analyze TMR analysis results and correlate with management, health, reproduction, and performance data gathered from farms.

 

4 months

August 2025

Educational Outreach: Host on-farm field day events to disseminate project findings and provide training on effective management practices.

 

1 month

September - October 2025

Report Preparation: Compile final reports summarizing project findings and recommendations for participating farms.

 

2 months

November 2025

Report Distribution: Provide final reports to participating farms and other stakeholders.

 

2 weeks

December 2025 - February 2026

Abstract submission for ADSA meeting

 

3 months

May 2026

Field Day Event: Host a final field day event to showcase project results and provide additional outreach to the broader farming community.

 

1 week

June 2026

National Conference: Travel to attend national conference and present project results.

 

1 week

July 2026

Project Wrap-Up: Finalize project documentation, submit any required reports, and evaluate project outcomes.

 

1 month

Research results and discussion:

Findings and Observations from the Project

Data Collected and Analysis

  1. Farm Management Practices:

    • Survey Data:
      Through a comprehensive survey, we collected detailed data on farm management practices, focusing on aspects like feeding routines, forage and feed storage methods, and management practices for total mixed ration (TMR). Specific attention was given to potential contamination points, such as silo maintenance and feed handling.
  2. Sample Collection and Analysis:

    • TMR and Corn Silage Samples:
      • TMR samples were analyzed for chemical composition, Clostridium, and mycotoxins.
      • Corn silage samples were assessed for chemical composition.
    • Laboratory Analysis:
      All samples were sent to a commercial laboratory for precise and standardized testing. This provided quantitative data on nutrient content, contamination levels, and risks associated with Clostridium and mycotoxins.

Preliminary Observations and Outcomes

  1. Farm Visits and Engagement:

    • The farm visits were well-received, with farmers showing significant interest and willingness to share data and samples. Their cooperative attitude highlighted their interest in improving feed management and addressing contamination issues.
    • Many farmers expressed satisfaction with the collaborative approach and appreciated receiving detailed feedback about their specific operations.
  2. Data Insights:

    • Farmers will be provided (in a week from today) with an overview of statewide trends in feed quality and contamination risks, along with individualized reports showing their farm's performance in comparison.
    • This benchmarking will provide farmers actionable insights into how their practices measure up to others in the state and potential areas for improvement.

Adjustments to Methods

  1. Enhanced Communication:

    • During the visits, it became apparent that farmers were more responsive when presented with real-time explanations and preliminary insights. This led to the incorporation of more interactive discussions during sample collection.
    • Reports will be made more user-friendly and included visual aids such as charts and comparative analyses to ensure clarity.
  2. Expanded Educational Materials:

    • While the initial plan focused on individual farm reports, the need for broader educational resources became evident. As a result, we began developing comprehensive educational materials summarizing key findings, best practices, and mitigation strategies to share with all participating and non-participating producers.
  1.  

Projected Farm-Level Changes

  1. Improved Feed Management:

    • Farmers are expected to make changes based on the individualized reports and guidance provided. These may include adopting preventive measures to reduce Clostridium and mycotoxin risks, such as better feeding management.
  2. Economic Benefits:

    • Improved feed quality and reduced contamination are likely to result in better animal health and performance, reducing veterinary costs and potentially increasing milk production.
  3. Time and Cost Efficiency:

    • Adoption of improved management strategies could lead to long-term savings in feed inputs and storage costs by minimizing spoilage and contamination.

The project has been successful in engaging Maryland dairy farmers and collecting valuable data to understand feed quality and contamination issues. The individualized reports and educational resources are expected to drive significant improvements in feed management practices. While further analysis is ongoing, initial outcomes suggest a positive trajectory for enhancing dairy farm sustainability and profitability.

 
 
 
 
Research conclusions:

The primary goal of this project was to assess the occurrence of Clostridium and mycotoxins in total mixed rations (TMR) on dairy farms in Maryland, understand farm management practices contributing to contamination, and provide actionable recommendations to improve feed management and animal health. This objective was successfully pursued through a combination of surveys, sample analysis, and direct farmer engagement.

What We Sought to Do:
We aimed to characterize the prevalence of Clostridium and mycotoxins in TMR and corn silage, identify risk factors associated with feed contamination, and support dairy producers in implementing best management practices. The ultimate goal was to enhance feed quality, improve animal performance, and promote sustainable dairy farming practices in Maryland.

What We Did:

  • A survey was mailed with a return envelope and postage to every Maryland dairy farm on record (n=293). A reminder note was sent a month later to encourage participation. Responses were received from 56 farms, and all answers were manually entered into a Qualtrics online survey. This data provided an updated understanding of the Maryland dairy industry, the issues farmers faced, and the management strategies they employed. The data was utilized to enhance the sustainability and profitability of dairy operations through extension education and outreach initiatives. 30 farmers were then selected for farm visits and TMR and Corn silage sampling.
     
  • Collected TMR and corn silage samples for laboratory analysis of chemical composition, Clostridium presence, and mycotoxins.
  • Analyzed the data to identify statewide trends and provided each farm with individualized reports comparing their results with statewide averages.
  • Presented preliminary findings at the Cornerstone event at the University of Maryland and are preparing another abstract for submission to the ADSA meeting.
  • Began developing educational materials to share insights and recommendations with both participating and non-participating producers.

Results and Outcomes:

  • Farm-Level Insights: Individualized reports will provide farmers with valuable benchmarks to evaluate their management practices. 
  • Statewide Trends: Preliminary analysis indicates a wide range of feed quality and contamination levels across Maryland dairy farms, highlighting areas for improvement.
  • Farmer Engagement: Farmers were highly cooperative and supportive, valuing the opportunity to learn about feed contamination and management strategies.

Meeting Objectives:
We are confident that the project is meeting its objectives, as evidenced by the successful completion of planned activities and the positive reception from dairy producers. The data collected has not only answered questions regarding Clostridium and mycotoxin prevalence but has also provided actionable insights to drive improvements.

This project is on track to achieve its objectives, and the preliminary results are promising. With further analysis, presentations, and educational outreach, we expect to support Maryland dairy farms in achieving measurable and sustainable improvements in feed quality and farm productivity.

Participation Summary
30 Farmers participating in research

Education & Outreach Activities and Participation Summary

Participation Summary:

Education/outreach description:

The outreach plan for our project on mycotoxins and Clostridium contamination in TMR samples is designed to effectively disseminate the project results and engage dairy farmers in Maryland. Our team plans to achieve this through: (1) Electronic Survey Distribution: We are currently distributing an electronic survey to dairy producers via Maryland Extension email lists and social media platforms. This survey will assess farmers' concerns regarding forage and TMR quality, as well as their interest in participating in a program focused on mitigating the negative effects of Clostridium and mycotoxins on their farms. By reaching out to farmers directly, we aim to gather valuable insights into their specific needs and challenges; (2) Results Dissemination: Once the survey results are collected and analyzed, we will disseminate the findings to the farming community through various channels. This may include presentations at agricultural conferences, webinars, newsletters, and publications in relevant journals. By sharing the results widely, we aim to raise awareness about the prevalence of Clostridium and mycotoxins in TMR samples and their potential impact on animal health, performance and reproduction; (3) Educational Materials: We will develop educational materials, such as fact sheets, guides, and videos, to provide farmers with practical information on managing Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination on their farms. These materials will be distributed electronically and made available on our project website for easy access; (4) On-Farm Field Days: To provide hands-on learning opportunities, we will host two on-farm field days at select dairy farms in Maryland. These events will allow farmers to see firsthand how effective management practices can mitigate Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination. We anticipate approximately 50 participants for each on-farm field day, providing a valuable opportunity for networking and knowledge exchange among farmers; (5) Collaboration with Extension Agents: We will collaborate closely with Extension agents from the University of Maryland Extension to ensure a comprehensive approach to addressing the challenges related to Clostridium and mycotoxins on dairy farms. Extension agents will help disseminate project information to their networks and provide additional support to participating farmers; (6) Compensation for Participants: Farmers participating in our program will be compensated through the provision of free analysis for Clostridium and mycotoxins, as well as gaining valuable knowledge and insights into managing these challenges on their farms. This incentivizes participation and ensures that farmers receive tangible benefits from their involvement in the project.

By implementing these outreach strategies, we aim to empower dairy farmers in Maryland to effectively manage Clostridium and mycotoxin contamination in their TMR samples, ultimately improving animal health, productivity, and food safety on their farms.

Information Products

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.