YFS Sowing Opportunities for Youth Leadership (SOYL)

Final report for YENC23-199

Project Type: Youth Educator
Funds awarded in 2023: $6,000.00
Projected End Date: 01/31/2025
Grant Recipient: Youth & Family Services, Inc.
Region: North Central
State: South Dakota
Project Manager:
Sharon Oney
Youth & Family Services, Inc.
Expand All

Project Information

Summary:

The Youth Educator will implement Sowing Opportunities for Youth Leadership (SOYL) with at least 15 youth, ages 12-18. Participants will learn about sustainable agriculture through hands-on activities, visits with area producers who implement sustainable practices, and by developing their own projects. This approach will help them comprehend and recognize ecologically sound, economically viable, socially responsible agriculture. They will also explore the links between food justice, localized food systems, and sustainability. Our goal is to empower these youth to be change makers in the community and to consider careers in sustainable agriculture to help address critically important environmental and social issues.

Project Objectives:
  1. At least 15 middle and high school youth will participate in ten 1-hour lessons/activities about soil health, organic gardening practices, the food system, food justice, composting/vermicomposting, pollinators, soil-less alternatives, and permaculture.
  2. The youth will explore sustainable agriculture career options through field trips to 3-4 local farms/ranching operations and one visit to the Black Hills Farmers’ Market.
  3. The youth will showcase their learning through facilitating a garden class with a group of younger kids to teach a sustainable agriculture practice or creating and presenting a group project on a sustainable agriculture practice to the larger group of participants.

Educational & Outreach Activities

10 Consultations
5 On-farm demonstrations
2 Tours
1 Webinars / talks / presentations
10 Other educational activities: Greenhouse classroom activities to learn about and discuss soil health, sustainable agriculture, food systems, and food justice.

Participation Summary:

11 Farmers/ranchers
24 Youth
1 Parents
1 Educators
1 Other adults
Education/outreach description:

The SOYL project targets middle school students enrolled in Youth and Family Services’ after-school and summer program. Activities during the summer (2023) involved field trips to four area farms/ranches, including YFS’ Fullerton Farm in Box Elder, and a field trip to the Black Hills Farmers Market. In 2024, activities included field trips to The Cheyenne River Buffalo Ranch and the Rapid City Landfill. The project also welcomed presenters from Trash Lilly Farms to talk with youth about composting. The students also tended on-site raised bed gardens at YFS’ Adams Street facility and at General Beadle Elementary School, both in North Rapid City. During the school year, students participated in learning activities in the Greenhouse Classroom twice each month to discuss and learn more about sustainable agriculture, soil health, food systems, food justice, pollinators, composting, and hydroponics. The Youth Educator used curriculum resources from Cornell Cooperative Extension’s Garden-Based Learning, Project S.O.W. (Seeds of Wonder): Gardening with Food Justice in Mind, Cornell’s Gardening in Our Warming World: Youth Grow! Curriculum, and Fork Farms 6-8 Hydroponic Curriculum.

Destiny Durham, the Youth Educator, prepares program updates for the monthly Board of Directors meeting and reports that the Middle School Program teacher has become quite interested in the project. "She has been very supportive of this project and has an interest in the area [of sustainable agriculture] herself." 

Board members and other YFS staff have also been supportive of the project. The Chief Program Officer, Out-of-School-Time Programs Director, Chief Grants Officer, several YFS teachers, and the Communications Coordinator showed their support by attending the middle school youth’s final project presentation in August 2024. A final report of the project was shared on YFS’ social media platforms, our monthly Program Updates for the YFS Board of Directors, USDA’s The Dirt newsletter, SDSU Extension’s Farm to School Network newsletter, and on a SARE presentation panel at the 2024 South Dakota Local Foods Conference held in Rapid City, SD on November 8-9.  

We worked with Bear Butte Gardens, Cycle Farm, and Dry Creek Farm & Ranch to host field trips at their local farms and ranches. We are currently working with Michelle Grosek, co-owner of Bear Butte Gardens and a member of YFS' Garden Advisory Group. We have collaborated with Michelle in the past and are fortunate to continue to work with her. She is an expert in organic gardening practices in Western South Dakota. Bear Butte Gardens is a USDA certified organic farm that features a farm stand and a commercial kitchen. They host events, education classes, and more. We will continue to collaborate with Bear Butte Gardens in the future.

Learning Outcomes

12 Youth reporting change in knowledge, attitudes, skills and/or awareness
Key changes:
  • Our food system

  • Food processing

  • Farmer's markets

  • Pollinator habitats

Results and discussion:

Youth Educator Destiny Durham: The SOYL project was a success. This project has given students enriching experiences that have built their foundation of knowledge on organic gardening practices, sustainable agriculture, our food system, and food justice. The project period began in March 2023 and concluded in August 2024 with the students’ presentation of their sustainable practice and a youth-led hands-on activity with their younger peers. A final survey was conducted and 70% of respondents reported positive changes in their knowledge, attitude, skills, or awareness of agricultural practices since participating in the SOYL Project; 25% reported they would consider a career in agriculture. Just this week, we received hydroponic STEM kits from NY SunWorks to supplement the hydroponic lessons the youth have had to date. Participants will have additional education sessions about hydroponic gardening and will be able to take the kits home.

Some challenges we’ve overcome throughout the project include staff changes, frequency of participants in classes, and time period spent on project. Though there have been hurdles, the successes of this project greatly outweigh the challenges.

From March to May 2023, the group had four lessons focused on organic gardening practices, pollinators, and soil health. Students began their summer group sessions with an introductory Group Bingo. The exercise was to match a statement on their bingo card such as “composts at home” or “has given a speech before” to a student in the group. This created a sense of community and connection from the start of our summer classes and field trips together. We then worked to plan and plant the raised bed gardens at General Beadle Elementary school near the YFS Adams St. facility in Rapid City. It was exciting to see the youth taking ownership of the space and working as a team. They were eager to transplant the plants that were started in the classroom in March. In the summer of 2023, the youth took field trips to local farms and ranches including YFS’ Fullerton Farm where they had the opportunity to suit up and see our beehives up close while learning about pollinators. While visiting Dry Creek Farm and Ranch in June, the students were introduced to regenerative agriculture. Owners Kristy and Shawn Freeland took us on a tractor ride (with their friendliest goat) around their property. Their previous crop management system had used traditional agriculture methods, but in recent years they transitioned to regenerative agriculture methods. They noted how the health of their grass and alfalfa fields has improved after not spraying for weeds, not allowing their cattle to eat the grass down to the soil and not working their fields. Now they use an intensive grazing management system, moving an electric fence several times daily. The students were in love with all the animals (pigs, goats, chickens, cows, a guard dog, a ranch dog, and a couple of horses). I believe it changed some of their perspectives about farming and ranching. Some of the students had never even been in grass taller than their ankles. This grass was above our waist at times when we got off the tractor and walked about the field.

In July we took field trips to Spearfish and Sturgis to visit two local farms. At Cycle Farm, the students learned about pollinators, pollinator habitats, permaculture, and regenerative agriculture. Cycle Farm grows vegetables to sell at a small farm stand on the property and several places in the Spearfish community. Owner Jeremy Smith spoke about the importance of a healthy farm ecosystem and explained how each bug, plant, and animal has a specific role in balancing the ecosystem. He let each of us hold a baby chick. The students’ faces lit up while holding them. Jeremy highlighted how they rarely weed. Looking down the rows, it was a bit harder to see the vegetables, but everything was vibrant and green. We learned that plants communicate through their roots, and by not disturbing the roots with tilling and by allowing nature to flourish in the space, over time it made their gardens healthier and more resistant to pests and diseases. They also use cover cropping to preserve the soil when vegetables are not growing.

Our next stop that day was at Bear Butte Gardens. Owners Michelle and Rick Grosek met us at their farm store and then gave us a tour of their farm. We learned about composting, farm animals, guard dogs, organic gardening, pollinators, and working as a farmer and business owner. Michelle steered the conversations to careers. She asked the students how many thought they would like to do something in agriculture. Some students raised their hands. Then she enlightened us on how she started working in this field, growing her own vegetables and selling at farmers markets locally until eventually they built their own farm store and got certified to be organic producers.

Our last summer field trip in 2023 was to the Black Hills Farmers Market (BHFM) on Wednesday, August 9. BHFM hosted a group of 24 youth. Youth brought money to shop at the market and were given questionnaires. The task was to visit five vendors and ask them questions such as, “How did you start selling your own product?” and “Why do you think it’s important to shop locally?” It was a small market that day, so students were able to visit all the booths. When the youth returned, some had whole cucumbers and tomatoes and were taking bites just as they were. Others bought jerky and baked goods and were sharing with the whole group, and some bought produce to take home to their family. This field trip was unique because the youth themselves were participating in our local food system and were free to engage with the vendors on their own.

From September 2023 to May 2024, the students participated in lessons on soil, our food system, food justice, hydroponics, climate change, systems thinking, composting, and vermicomposting. One lesson in the Cornell S.O.W. curriculum was to come up with a list of community agreements that would serve as the rules for themselves and all of the younger classes. Students demonstrated communication, social skills, and teamwork to create these rules. Now they are displayed in the Greenhouse Classroom for every class to reference. An activity in Cornell’s Gardening in Our Warming World: Youth Grow! focused on systems thinking. The activity was to start with a ball of yarn. One student would start by thinking of a problem related to climate change, then they would wrap the yarn around their finger and pass it to the next person who would piggyback on that idea. By then end of the activity, we had a big web of yarn. It helped students to visualize how issues are related when talking about climate change. 

In summer 2024, the students visited the Rapid City Landfill where they learned about waste and composting. Our final field trip was to the Cheyenne River Buffalo Ranch. When we arrived, hosts Jillian and Colton took us on a trailer ride to see their processing facility and the buffalo herd. We stopped at a small trailer where workers were preparing the buffalo for packaging. Colton explained that the buffalo on their ranch never see the inside of a trailer like the majority of today’s livestock does. The animals are harvested in the fields by a sharpshooter and brought back to the temperature-controlled trailer for processing. Some students checked out the inside of the processing facility. Next, we rode off into the pasture to see the buffalo herd. The hosts talked about the grassland ecosystem. They explained that buffalo birds, prairie dogs, black footed ferrets, buffalo, and the native grassland all work together to balance the prairie land habitat. Youth were engaged and asked questions such as, “What do they eat during the winter?” and “Why are the babies lighter?” Jillian and Colton also let the kids scavenge for buffalo bones to take home if they wanted. Almost everyone came back with a buffalo bone, mostly skulls. In our next class together, I asked the students to write one thing that they took away from our trip to the buffalo ranch. One response is notable: “The Great Plains prairie grass is better at pulling CO2 out of the atmosphere than the Amazon rainforest.” (Please see the photo with the students’ responses at the end of this report.)

Most of the farms and ranches we visited focused on soil health, so the youth chose to develop a presentation and implement a youth-led activity about composting as a sustainable agriculture practice. On August 12, the students presented their project to 20 2nd and 3rd grade students from YFS Girls Inc. YFS Directors were invited to attend. Pairs of students presented the PowerPoint slides they had created about composting. After the presentation, the students directed the young girls to make “compost” in a bag. They had bowls of various food items at each table. Frosted Flakes represented leaves, cranberries represented food waste, crumbled Oreos resembled dirt, gummy worms stood in for live worms, and pretzels looked like sticks or yard waste. With the guidance of the older students, the Girls Inc. members then layered their bag with the ingredients needed to make compost. The last thing they did was shake the bag to add air. Afterward, the girls ate their “compost.” When asked what ingredients are needed to make compost, the girls were able to recite them correctly.

 

Key strengths and weaknesses of this curricula or lesson plans:

Project S.O.W: Food Gardening with Justice in Mind

     Strengths: Cultivates connection between group members; introductory engagement activities; life skills; appropriate for Middle School and up

     Weaknesses: None

Gardening in Our Warming World: Youth Grow!

     Strengths: Varying levels of skill levels for student activities; tips on how to talk about climate change with youth; many links to other resources

     Weaknesses: Some lessons are too complex for an out of school program, seems more appropriate for high school students during the school day; significant amount of time in preparation for lessons if you are unexperienced in facilitating education about climate change

Flex Farm 6-8 Curriculum 

     Strengths: STEM education for all grade levels relating to hydroponic growing; Power Points included for each lesson; easy to follow for instructors

     Weaknesses: Needs more introductory engagement activities; hard to use with large groups of students

Project Outcomes

7 Number of youth considering a career in sustainable agriculture
3 Grants received that built upon this project
4 New working collaborations
Increased organizational support to explore and teach sustainable ag:
Yes
Explanation for change in organizational support to explore and teach sustainable ag:

YFS has been very supportive of garden education and sustainable agriculture for more than a decade. The CEO serves on our Garden Advisory Group, and a Board member and his family have established an endowed fund for YFS Fullerton Farm. (The land for the farm was donated by the Board member's parents in 2014.) This project has elicited increasing interest among staff members and more.

Sustainable Agriculture practices parents adopted:
Success stories:

Youth Educator Destiny Durham: I am incredibly proud of this group! I know that sustainable agriculture is likely not at the top of the list of things a middle school student cares about, so it was incredible to watch how willing and professional they were when presenting and facilitating the hands-on project with their younger peers. The experiences gained by youth in the SOYL project will certainly be remembered as they are growing up. It was a first for many to experience a farm or ranch, a first for many to learn about the food system, and a first for many to form their own opinions on the world we live in as it relates to the well-being of all living things and our food. I do not think it will be the last time they revisit this topic. I hope this experience has given them some of the tools they need to become informed adults in the future. One student, Kena, wrote, “It would be awesome to grow your own fruit and vegetables.”

There have been many successes throughout this project. At least 24 students were able to experience field trips to local farms and were engaged even if they didn’t want to work in a related field or weren’t interested in the topic. One of the biggest successes of the project is simply increasing awareness. Most young people spend most of their time on computers, their phones, and in man-made environments. This project gave them the opportunity to step out of their comfort zones and familiar ways of thinking. An example of this is when we were at Dry Creek Farm & Ranch this summer, students were asking questions like, “What happens if the cow touches the fence?”, “What would happen if I touched the fence?”, “What do the pigs eat?”, “Aw, why can’t the dog come with?” and “Oh, no! You people eat these cows!” I overheard a student say to other members of the group that she “would love to live here and get to come outside in the morning to do this for work.” It was refreshing to witness the students’ reactions to this environment versus learning about it in the classroom. On the bus ride back after the second field trip, the students were asked which place they had visited that day was their favorite and why. About half wrote “Barbacoa’s”, a local restaurant where we went for lunch earlier, but most of the others wrote Bear Butte Gardens. When studying food justice and our food system, we watched The 7Gen Food System Vision video. This video highlights the food system the Lakota people had before the settlers arrived and how they are working to transform it today. When asked how this topic made them feel, one student responded with, “I feel shocked.”  I hope these awarenesses will hold value in their futures. 

Recommendations:

Youth Educator Destiny Durham: I love that SARE is giving youth the opportunity to learn about sustainable agriculture. It will likely be a part of their livelihoods and future. Opening the door to learn about sustainable agriculture at this age will influence the students’ futures. If they know the dangers of industrial agriculture and our current system, they can work with us to change it. We need a system that is not harmful to society and our environment. This project has helped the middle school students come to an awareness and understanding that would not have been possible in the classroom alone.

Managing our SARE grant was made simpler by the available resources, like the webinar for managing a youth educator grant and by working with Liz Brownlee. The SARE grant was very thorough, and we are grateful to have been able to do this project.

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and should not be construed to represent any official USDA or U.S. Government determination or policy.