The Buzz on the Range: Promoting healthy soils and pollinators on Montana rangeland

Progress report for OW22-372

Project Type: Professional + Producer
Funds awarded in 2022: $55,990.00
Projected End Date: 03/31/2025
Host Institution Award ID: G242-23-W9211
Grant Recipient: Western Sustainability Exchange
Region: Western
State: Montana
Principal Investigator:
Michael DeChellis
We Are For The Land Foundation, Inc.
Co-Investigators:
Michael DeChellis
OpenTeam And We Are For the Land Board Member
Michal DeChellis
Cultivating Minds LLC and We Are For the Land Foundation
Expand All

Project Information

Summary:

There is an urgent need for resilient soil, grass, and pollinator habitat in our rangelands.  This can only be achieved through fiscally viable approaches.  This project attempts to demonstrate, with our producer partners as the focus, alternative practices to promote healthy pollinator populations and resilient soils and grass in rangeland. Currently, rangeland producers generally don’t consider that what is good for the bovine is good for the bee. We aim, with this research, education, and resulting business plan inputs, to demonstrate whether there are significant agricultural operation benefits to adjusting practices to use cows to ingest pollinator-friendly native grass seed, then pass and subsequently plant the grasses to (benefit) maximize pollinator populations.  An additional opportunity for an on-ranch enterprise could be applied to new partnerships with beekeepers or start hives of their own.

We Are For The Land Foundation proposes this project to directly support producers in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem specifically and in Southwest Montana, who are interested in deepening their understanding of soil health, water cycle, alternative approach native grass dispersal and growth, and pollinator communities. Sharing and exhibiting to producers several monitoring and testing techniques to illustrate the benefits of maximizing inputs for profitability and land health. Having a better understanding of what this looks like empowers producers to make more informative financial and land management decisions. Having more data will hopefully allow producers to increase the productivity of their grazing lands and decrease their inputs in management.

Project Objectives:

Objective 1: Increase producer  and consumer interest in the connection between soil health, pollinators, and grazing in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. 

Objective 2: Build and support a coalition of producers who are adaptive grazing, who interested in increasing their pollinator communities and who are interested in connecting with Montana apiarists. 

Objective 3: Test adaptive grazing plans with participating producers to support pollinators. 

Objective 4: Measure pollinators and soil health over 3 years in several locations. 

Objective 5: Provide community promotion of engaged producers involved in the project. 

Objective 6: Collect and share the economics of the considered practices involved in this project. 

Cooperators

Click linked name(s) to expand/collapse or show everyone's info
  • Teo Abbruzzese - Producer
  • Hannibal Anderson - Producer
  • Lily Anderson - Producer
  • Stacey Barta - Technical Advisor (Educator)
  • Alex Blake - Producer
  • Rachel Frost - Technical Advisor
  • Dr. Hayes Goosey - Technical Advisor (Researcher)
  • Meagan Lannan - Producer (Researcher)
  • Chris Mehus - Technical Advisor (Educator and Researcher)
  • Theodore Nelson - Technical Advisor

Research

Materials and methods:

Progress Reports

2023 Progress Report - an updated presentation about 2023 with visuals is presented here.

2022 Progress Report - a highlight presentation about 2022 with visuals is presented here

You may appreciate reviewing the above presentations first to get a good sense of the project before diving into the text below. Also, please note that the text below has not been changed significantly since the project start, but this year, we have REORGANIZED it under new headings to be much easier to follow - getting ready for the final report structure coming next year.

Research Summary

The bulk of the research in this project is centered around producer field measurements and management changes to achieve some ecological objectives. Producers are using approximately 1 acre paddocks marked and set up with electric fencing during active management times of the year.

Research Philosophy

We will evaluate DIRECTIONAL trends in pollinator populations, dispersed grass populations, and soil microbe health. Those will be included in the data report distributed to partners and producers. This research will inform (through our MSU partners) more rigorous controlled research if warranted.

Research Objectives

Pollinator Promotion Objectives:

Determine - Can ruminants spread, stomp, and water native pollinator-promoting grasses to improve pollinator populations in the test area? Is that approach economically efficient for producers? There are several studies that demonstrate that endozoochory (dispersion of seed through ruminant dung) is a viable way to distribute grass seed. Our research objective is to see if using livestock to spread grass seed that promotes pollinator health results in better pollinator populations. From that, we’ll document what costs are involved and deliver a report on viability as a management choice. We believe this has a better chance of success because:

  • Although digestive tracts can significantly reduce seed viability, it’s a low effort dispersal technique for land managers
  • Constant seeding of native mixed cover promotes soil biomass which in turn promotes germination success (positive feedback loop)
  • Hoof action can promote seed-dung-soil mixing, especially for high wind dry rangeland environments
  • Germination rates have been quite poor in other pollinator promotion projects funded by Western SARE, spread directly:

Soil Microbe Health Objectives:

Determine - Do multi seeding grasses through endozoochory coupled with winter bale grazing result in more robust soil microbe health?
There is much evidence for ground cover and root penetration improving soil microbe health in literature and practice.
We are interested in promoting that to specifically improve the pollinator results and reduce grazing costs for producers. We believe they inform each other.

Rangeland Management Tools Objective:

Determine if pollinator health indicators can be included in ecological outcomes tracking in worldwide tools as part of the OpenTEAM collaborative? OpenTEAM is using satellite data correlated with field data to build Machine Learning models that are able to predict outcomes based on different management techniques. Due to the potential financial benefit to producers selling ecological outcome credits, this research data will help codify measurement techniques necessary and provide seed data to evaluate if more research is warranted.

Business Plan Impact Objectives:

If any significant benefit is realized from research activities, the impact to business plans will be gathered and presented.

Research Protocols

Pollinator Promotion Plan:

Producer partners will mix native pollinator promotion seed with loose feed for livestock. The details of the 2022 seed mix are in this single sheet here. In 2023, we added 3 more species to the seed mix. Details about that mix are in this sheet here. Producer partners will create an approximate 1-acre paddock and allow livestock to graze paddock from 1-3 days after feed to provide feed spread, stomp, and watering action through dung and urine. The details are in the single sheet for producers here. This activity happened during September 2022 and June 2023 to maximize likelihood of germination and growth. Timing decision informed by Western SARE FW20-358 Improving Irrigated Pasture Productivity and Soil Biodiversity in Oregon's High Desert.

Soil Microbe Health Promotion Plan:

Producer partners will bale graze in early 2023 and 2024 in order to increase biomass cover and moisture retention. Producers will bury underwear as part of a “soil your undies” microbe evaluation each year to measure qualitative improvements.

Rangeland Management Tools Promotion Plan:

After collection, MJD will gather data and present to OpenTEAM Artificial Intelligence and Ecological Markets partners to evaluate viability. MJD will provide direct tool use feedback to OpenTEAM tools developers (FarmOS / SurveyStack / LandPKS), through our partnership with them, and share data with the OpenTEAM research group to evaluate ecological market viability.

Business Plan Impact Promotion Plan:

MJD, Rachel Frost, Hayes Goosey, and producer partners will provide input to a pollinator business plan that will include the following:

  • Inputs (materials and time) and estimates of benefit (grazing cost reduction, soil health outcomes)
  • Value propositions to beekeeper partnerships and profit co-benefits.

This business plan will be co-authored and presented to partners and producers and published on the website.

Research Methods (including updates!)

Rangeland Monitoring

In 2022, the PIs and Producers performed comprehensive assessments of the following for 3 of the 5 participating producers (Barney Creek Livestock, Anderson Ranch, and Keeywadin Ranch):

  • Ecological and Soil health indicators using the Savory Short Term Ecological Outcome Verification methodology.
  • Plant surveys on Transects relying on methodology from Savory Long Term Ecological Outcome Verification methodology.

These results are included in the following locations: Anderson Ranch, Kee Wayden Ranch, Barney Creek Ranch

In a setback in 2022, the other 2 of the 5 producers (Milk Maid Meats, West Creek Ranch) had major impacts to their grazing plans due to flooding (they are located in the Yellowstone River valley in Paradise Valley), and weren’t able to participate as planned, but will be doing the protocols and comprehensive baselines in 2023 with follow-ups.

In 2023, the PIs and Producers performed comprehensive assessments at all 5 participating producers (Barney Creek Livestock, Anderson Ranch, Keeywadin Ranch, Milk Maid Meats, and West Creek Ranch). The comprehensive reports will be included in our final reports after the 2024 seasons.
The Principle Investigators, Producers, and any participating MSU students and interns will measure and document with photos the previously listed indicators in 2024.

Pollinator Monitoring

In a change/improvement from our original grant proposal, we have enlisted the expert help of Sarah Red-Laird of the Bee Girl Organization (a 501c3 non-profit focused on pollinator research) to provide much better pollinator data than originally envisioned with this project.
She did pollinator assessments at 2 of our 5 producer partners’ ranches in 2022 and continued those assessments in 2023. We shifted budget in the project to allow for this expert partnership and continue to raise additional funds to do detailed bee species identification to improve the output of the project.

Data Tracking Tools

Successful Use of FarmOS to House Project Data We are using OpenTEAM open source data tools to document and share the measurement data in a consistent manner including:

  • FarmOS to document management actions and field measurements
  • SurveyStack and LandPKS to build smartphone-friendly pollinator surveys and complete consistent soil health and plant surveys

The data has been housed at https://buzzontherange.farmos.net. This is an instance of FarmOS, the key OpenTEAM platform, made for the Buzz On The Range project. This data is NOT shared or accessible outside of the project team. After the project is over, if there is something meaningful to share with the FarmOS / OpenTEAM community on how the tool was used for this project, then a presentation will be made at that time (assuming the producer partners are comfortable with that).

Use of iNaturalist as a Flowering Plant Species Inventory Repository In addition to FarmOS, our bee expert, Sarah Red-Laird, has created a project page on iNaturalist where she has created a very compelling inventory of species found that are pollinator supporting. That can be found here.

Decision to not use SurveyStack with the project SurveyStack was not used because it wasn't offline friendly enough in 2022. By 2023, the FarmOS instance that we have used for this project has been adequate for DIRECTLY inputting the data from our collection. We had intended to establish a baseline process for field measurement in 2022 and encapsulate it in a SurveyStack process for 2023 and beyond. This was a complication that provided no value to our objectives. The offline non-readiness of FarmOS had been a central discussion point in developer meetings that our project has helped to motivate. We continue to follow the development of a module in FarmOS called Field Kit. This will be huge for offline efforts. I’ve been joining developer calls also encouraging better documentation (some of that here) - this kicked off early in the project and has progressed nicely - the use of these tools in this project has already made the open-source platform better, I think. Serious credit to the developer team because they’re so responsive to feedback! This was the point of using these tools to make them better for farmers/ranchers that are trying to break out of proprietary and expensive tools.

LandPKS LandPKS had been intended for soil health evaluation, but the Savory methodology proved to be a MUCH better fit for this project because of its ecological outcomes focus.

Research results and discussion:

Year 1 Report (2022)

Pollinator Promoting Seed Mix

In research and consultation with partners Ted Nelson, Stacy Barta, and our producer partners, we determined the best seed mix for this project was the following (weight ratio in brackets):

  • Bluebunch Wheatgrass (Pseudoroegneria spicata) [50%], a cool-season native perennial bunchgrass
  • Purple Prairie Clover (Dalea purpurea) [20%], perennial legume wildflower
  • Joseph’s Idaho Fescue (Festuca idahoensis 'Joseph') [20%], a cool-season native perennial bunchgrass
  • Stillwater Prairie Coneflower (Ratibida columnifera) [10%], a late-season native perennial forb

Please see the attached Pollinator Promoting Seed Info Sheet for photos and a summary.

Feeding, Grazing, and Paddock Protocol

We also researched, determined, and documented the feeding/paddock protocol for the project and distributed to the producers for ease of implementation and reporting. See the attached Overview and Grazing Plan for Producer Partners.  Additionally, here are the completed forms by Anderson, Barney Creek, and Kee Wayden.

Additional Outcomes

Some additional outcomes from the research this year:

  • We had no reports from producers of any ill effects of the seed mix in the animals.
  • We directly observed the seeds coming out in the dung of the animals in the test paddock of at least one producer.
  • The preliminary results from the pollinator assessments (including 24 hour blue vane traps and bee species identification) show bee populations that are varied, with Anderson Ranch having significant pollinator activity. The full (comprehensive) report will be available at project end.

We are in year one of our research project. We anticipate seeing outcomes from our seeding efforts starting this spring (whether we have germination or not).

Year 2 Report (2023)

Expanded Pollinator Promoting Seed Mix

In addition to the seeding mix from Year 1, we added three MORE species to our mix this year, for a total of 7:

  • Cicer Milkvetch(Astragalus cicer) - perennial legume wildflower
  • Birdsfoot Trefoil(Lotus corniculatus) - perennial legume wildflower
  • Rocky Mountain Beeplant(Cleome serulata) - flowering forb

See the attached front-and-back sheet with the updated species list, including weight percentages.

Continued Trend of No Unhealthy Outcomes for the Cows

With the now expanded seed being fed to the cows, we again had no noticed or reported ill effects.

Field Observations Key Insights

  • As of yet, we have seen NO emergence of the grass species from last year in our test paddocks emerge. In particular, this year was a dynamite time for germination, so we’re considering that this may mean the endozoochory technique we’re using still hasn’t seen proper conditions, or that the seed simply isn’t making it through the animal gut as a viable plant.
  • Once again, we did see evidence in the fresh manure of seed coming through the gut.

Pollinator Inventory Key Insights

Presentation on Pollinator Observations from Year 2 can be found here:

  • Pollinator populations are steady or slightly up.
  • Still having rare species finds
  • Upsetting queen bee death incident observed from neighbor spraying at time of observations.
Participation Summary
5 Producers participating in research

Research Outcomes

Recommendations for sustainable agricultural production and future research:

Year 1 Report (2022)

Pollinator Promoting Seed Mix

In research and consultation with partners Ted Nelson, Stacy Barta, and our producer partners, we determined the best seed mix for this project was the following (weight ratio in brackets):

  • Bluebunch Wheatgrass (Pseudoroegneria spicata) [50%], a cool-season native perennial bunchgrass
  • Purple Prairie Clover (Dalea purpurea) [20%], perennial legume wildflower
  • Joseph’s Idaho Fescue (Festuca idahoensis 'Joseph') [20%], a cool-season native perennial bunchgrass
  • Stillwater Prairie Coneflower (Ratibida columnifera) [10%], a late-season native perennial forb

Please see the attached Pollinator Promoting Seed Info Sheet for photos and a summary.

Feeding, Grazing, and Paddock Protocol

We also researched, determined, and documented the feeding/paddock protocol for the project and distributed to the producers for ease of implementation and reporting. See the attached Overview and Grazing Plan for Producer Partners.  Additionally, here are the completed forms by Anderson, Barney Creek, and Kee Wayden.

Additional Outcomes

Some additional outcomes from the research this year:

  • We had no reports from producers of any ill effects of the seed mix in the animals.
  • We directly observed the seeds coming out in the dung of the animals in the test paddock of at least one producer.
  • The preliminary results from the pollinator assessments (including 24 hour blue vane traps and bee species identification) show bee populations that are varied, with Anderson Ranch having significant pollinator activity. The full (comprehensive) report will be available at project end.

We are in year one of our research project. We anticipate seeing outcomes from our seeding efforts starting this spring (whether we have germination or not).

Year 2 Report (2023)

Expanded Pollinator Promoting Seed Mix

In addition to the seeding mix from Year 1, we added three MORE species to our mix this year, for a total of 7:

  • Cicer Milkvetch(Astragalus cicer) - perennial legume wildflower
  • Birdsfoot Trefoil(Lotus corniculatus) - perennial legume wildflower
  • Rocky Mountain Beeplant(Cleome serulata) - flowering forb

See the attached front-and-back sheet with the updated species list, including weight percentages.

Continued Trend of No Unhealthy Outcomes for the Cows

With the now expanded seed being fed to the cows, we again had no noticed or reported ill effects.

Field Observations Key Insights

  • As of yet, we have seen NO emergence of the grass species from last year in our test paddocks emerge. In particular, this year was a dynamite time for germination, so we’re considering that this may mean the endozoochory technique we’re using still hasn’t seen proper conditions, or that the seed simply isn’t making it through the animal gut as a viable plant.
  • Once again, we did see evidence in the fresh manure of seed coming through the gut.

Pollinator Inventory Key Insights

Presentation on Pollinator Observations from Year 2 can be found here:

  • Pollinator populations are steady or slightly up.
  • Still having rare species finds
  • Upsetting queen bee death incident observed from neighbor spraying at time of observations.

Education and Outreach

9 Consultations
3 Curricula, factsheets or educational tools
1 On-farm demonstrations
1 Published press articles, newsletters
2 Webinars / talks / presentations
3 Workshop field days

Participation Summary:

53 Farmers participated
33 Ag professionals participated
Education and outreach methods and analyses:

The following details our education and outreach throughout the project. We have updated it by year while retaining intention details from the grant application.

Progress Reports

2023 Progress Report - an updated presentation about 2023 with visuals is presented here.

2022 Progress Report - a highlight presentation about 2022 with visuals is presented here

You may appreciate reviewing the above presentations first to get a good sense of the project before diving into the text below. Also, please note that the text below has not been changed significantly since the project start, but this year, we have REORGANIZED it under new headings to be much easier to follow - getting ready for the final report structure coming next year.

Overall Objectives

Participating producers will learn how the soil health and pollinator activity of their ranges vary within their own ranches and how they compare to other ranges in their ecosystem and region. They will see how the management of rangeland can influence soil health and how improved soil health might impact the ecosystem and pollinator habitats. Participating partners and community members will learn many of the same things as they participate in various aspects of the work.

Methods

Our grant proposal includes education and outreach in 3 clear ways:

  • Workshops each year touching on various aspects of the project and impacts
  • Public/Rancher awareness campaigns such as “Soil Your Undies”
  • Opportunity for producers and students to learn at research in action field days
  • Documenting and sharing the outputs of the project widely

2022 Education and Outreach

Workshop 1 Details - April 29, 2022 - Soil Health and “Soil your Undies” Workshop - West Creek Ranch

Outreach

We invited producers and ranchers from across Southwest Montana to join our workshop. Partner workshop development and support: Stacey Barta (The Montana DNRC), Western Sustainability Exchange. Target audience:

  • Project producers,
  • producers in our region,
  • partner organizations/programs, the
  • Yellowstone Valley Ecosystem communities

We used our Project partner organizations email lists and event sites (it was held at West Creek Ranch), and word of mouth from participating producers. There are fantastic marketing tools from Oregon's NRCS that we used to start our "Soil your undies" marketing in our area. The flyer for the event is here.

Event
  • See slides 9-10 of the update presentation for visuals of the day.
  • We had 8 producer attendees, a DNRC representative, an NRCS soil health specialist, the Executive Director from Western Sustainability Exchange and the Conservation Director from AMB West in attendance.
  • Participants learned or reviewed the five principles of soil health, ways to measure soil health, and how to improve the quality of their soil with tools they may already own. The workshop also covered microbiological activity, health, and seeds in mineral--planting seeds for bees/bovine.
  • Marni Thompson, the NRCS Soil health Specialist in Montana did a wonderful lesson and demonstration on: Visual Soil Assessment and Discussion of Soil Health
  • Chris Mehus from Western Sustainability Exchange and We Are For the Land representatives did a demonstration on how to bury undies on rangeland. This kicked off our “Soil Your Undies” campaign for 2022.

2022 Soil Your Undies Campaign

We invited our producers in our region as well as interested community members to "Soil Their Undies." Here is the flyer we created. We also created a landing page on our website here for them to report their progress. This is a campaign started from the Oregon NRCS. This challenge encourages participants to "plant" cotton underwear and then dig them back up 60/90 days later to check on the microbial activity in the soil. While this is just an experiment just for fun, it gets people thinking about what their microbes are up to and how their management style influences how quickly they can eat their undies? We started a social media campaign on Instagram and Facebook encouraging others and workshop attendees to show us their "Soil your Undies" project. We checked back in 90 days on people who have joined the campaign and showed them the results of the buried underwear from the workshop site and encouraged them to share their photos.

2022 SUCCESS STORY: Even more Soil Your Undies - A BONUS WORKSHOP and serious awareness at the Livingston Farmers Market.

We were so inspired by the Soil Your Undies potential that, with fantastic in-kind support from Western Sustainability Exchange and Marni Thompson at NRCS, we did a soil health demonstration day at Miles Park in Livingston Montana that was well attended. We even put out a press release about it. We buried undies in Miles Park and dug them up on the soil health day on July 20th, 2022. See slides 12-13 on the project update presentation to get a sense of how well regarded, attended, and successful the day was.

2023 Education and Outreach

Expansion into 2 workshops

We had two main educational activities for our producers this year. Our original project proposal included only 1 workshop in 2023, but we had the distinct luck to have a fantastic partner in BGO as pollinator experts. We decided to include an ADDITIONAL workshop for our producers detailing just the pollinator aspect of their ranches. More details about that below.

Curriculum Shuffle

In addition to ADDING significant curriculum around pollinators from our expert partner. We also felt that a workshop centered around native grasses/plant surveys/water infiltration/bale grazing would be low-value-add for our producer partners since they also had been actively doing those activities with us in the field. Therefore, we had an opportunity to provide a different, more engaging workshop based on a sister event that we’ll share details about below.

Workshop: Montana Rangeland Tour - July 6th, 2023

The DNRC Montana Range Land tour took the place of our initially planned summer 2023 workshop which was intended for our producers with a wide invitation for other producers in the area to attend. However, with DNRC hosting a workshop already at one of our producer’s (Barney Creek Livestock) locations we decided that we would be able to reach more producers by presenting as part of their workshop.

Initial grant application workshop objectives (for reference, changed per “Curriculum Shuffle” above)

Content/Objectives:

  • We'll share project updates and any progress notes on the project with all attendees.
  • The workshop will focus on native grasses that are good for grazing livestock and for pollinators, how to conduct plant surveys and examples of common plants that are found in Montana rangeland.
  • The workshop will also cover how to impact Water Infiltration and the what the benefits of Bale Grazing are and how to use this technique effectively.

Target audience:

  • Project producers,
  • Producers in our region,
  • MSU students from partner organizations/programs,
  • the Yellowstone Valley Ecosystem communities

Partner workshop development and support: Ted Nelson (NRCS), Rachel Frost (MSU DSRP), Chris Mehus (WSE), Stacey Barta (DNRC)

Curriculum for Montana Rangeland Tour

The attached schedule for the Montana Rangeland Tour includes the details of the day. Note inclusion of Buzz on the Range. Major touchpoints:

  • Soil health demonstration from world-renowned Nicole Masters, including a trench and microbiome discussion
  • Pasture tours of Pete and Meagan (Barney Creek Livestock) locales including in-depths on electric fence and water management to support daily moves
Buzz on the Range Section of the Montana Range Tour Days
  • Stacey Barta, our DNRC grant partner, enthusiastically included almost an hour for us to share the details of this project and objectives.
  • Barney Creek Livestock producer, Meagan Lannan led the conversation about Buzz on the Range. Meagan shared overall about the project, the grazing protocol producers were using as well as the native seed mix involved.
  • Lara Birkes, also shared about how the protocol has impacted her land which was previously heavily sprayed, un-grazed for a time, and lacked pollinator promoting plants.
  • Buzz on the Range’s Fiscal Sponsor, Western Sustainability Exchange’s (WSE) then Program Director now Executive Director, Chris Mehus supported Meagan in talking about the project and connected how this work has inspired educational efforts in WSE’s programming. More on that in the impacts/outcome section.
  • Michael DeChellis shared about how this work was supported by a Western SARE grant and encouraged attendees to come up with innovative producer partnerships for consideration by Western SARE for their grant goals.
Attendees

The workshop was WIDELY attended by all of those on the Rangeland Tour (estimated 40+ attendees!) Project producers Milk Maid Meats, Blake Ranch, and Malou Anderson were able to attend the workshop. Barney Creek Livestock has an additional project site and the landowner, Lara Birkes was in attendance to share her experience being part of the research protocol. Our 5th producer, West Creek Ranch, did not attend.

Workshop: Buzz on the Range Pollinator Surveys, Findings, and Pollinator Insights by Bee Girl Organization’s Sarah Red-Laird - December 11th, 2023

The second educational effort came from Sarah Red-Laird, Executive Director of the Bee Girl Organization. Last summer and this summer, she acted as our main pollinator research partner. She held a session with our producers to share with them all that she learned when surveying their fields. All 4 participating producers this year were able to attend this session. Sarah shared why there was a lack of complete bee data, shared preliminary findings, and demonstrated use of iNaturalist pages, where she was hosting her research. She also discussed methods for analyzing vegetation and bee populations. She also shared a powerful story about a bee death during her measurements on a producer’s land that really put the cost of spraying into focus from a pollinator perspective. Details of her presentation are in the update document here.

BONUS Education Activity: Soil Your Undies for ANOTHER YEAR!

We really wanted to highlight a successful continuation that came from our initial grant-funded Soil Your Undies campaign last year. At that time, we partnered with WSE to host a Soil Your Undies Campaign, which was met with great interest and success. While we weren’t able to continue this activity under this grant for this particular activity, WSE in 2023 did a social media campaign to encourage folks around Montana to Soil their Undies. They created some MT specific materials that they shared with their networks. In an email about this impact, Chris Mehus (project partner and ED of Western Sustainability Exchange) said: “Looks like our Western SARE Soil Your Undies activity continues to thrive and expand beyond our expectations! Last year, several groups, most notably Yellowstone County Extension and 4H used the concept for a large educational push that had tremendous reach through their youth program. From the forwarded email here, the MT Soil Health Week collaborative is using it this year as a major part of their outreach and programming!”

2024 Education and Outreach (Planned - from original grant plan)

Workshop 3: Profit for Ranchers & The Final Buzz on the Range

Content/Objectives:

  • Project results thus far, what the input costs have been, what ecosystem impacts are we seeing
  • We will also have a session on Budget management related to soil health and pollinators

Partners: Chris Mehus, Stacy Barta, Rachel Frost, Hayes Goosey, Ted Nelson, Plank Stewardship-Tris Menisci

On-Ranch Research in Action Field Days

MSU students, interns, project producers, project organizational partners will be invited to participate in the data collection at participating producer sites in order to give participants a real world application and a hands-on, experiential learning environment. Objective: Workshop participants will have the opportunity for hands-on learning related to research items at the time which could include:

  • Setting up paddocks for research,
  • feeding methods,
  • plant community tracking,
  • taking pollinator measurements
  • and looking at soil health testing and indicators.

This objective is directly tied to our Research Objectives. All participants on these days will learn more about the research methods and get to try their own data recording. There will be discussions about how these activities impact the health of that producer's ecosystem, the health of their soil, and the robustness of their pollinator populations. Producers and researchers will be available to answer questions and have conversations about their decision-making process for their operations. Research will occur throughout the year (Spring, summer, fall) over 2023-2024 so we hope there are ample opportunities for the target audience to join for these research in action days. Target audience:  MSU students, interns, project producers, project organizational partners, producers who attended the workshop, and other interested community members.

Project Findings Communications

These activities will take place once we have completed our research in the fall of 2024.

Buzz on the Range Lessons

We will create two separate lessons one aimed at adult producers and one for k-12 youth that can be used by agencies, educators, other producers based on our project and outlining our current work and suggesting future research areas related to grazing and pollinators. This will be shared with all participating producers and agencies as well as widely shared through farm to school networks, 4H, and FFA.Lessons will include opening focus question, learning objectives, lesson description, action steps, and a closing. Lesson Objectives:

  1. Increased understanding about the relationship of soil health, pollinator habitats, and grazing animals.
  2. Increased understanding about types of land management options available to support healthy ecosystems.
  3. Improved knowledge of ranching careers and the scope of work and their decision- making process.
  4. Improved awareness of current issues and challenges in agriculture.

We'll post these on our website We Are For the Land and share widely within our networks.

Buzz on the Range Video series

Objective: A visual story and example of what doing this research actually looks like in the hopes that they this worked could be replicated by someone on their own. We'll be recording all our initial workshops as well as how we are gathering data at each producer site. We'll show how we are taking measurements and taking note of what we are noticing in our sites over time. This will be shared with our project producers and partners who will be encouraged to share this as well. We'll post on our We Are For the Land Website and ask other organizations like NCAT, AERO to also share these videos to their networks.

Project Report

Objective: Clear documentation of our project, process, and results throughout the project presented in a way that is digestible to interested parties. This will look like a a written document or a powerpoint presentation that will provide: Project summary, research introduction and goal, research methodology. research results, research discussion, conclusion. This document will also have links to the curriculum, video series, and recorded workshops for people who would like to delve more deeply into the project. We'll share this report with all participating agency partners to include in their resource libraries as well.

Education and outreach results:

2022

The 2022 season was full of learning and excitement for the project team and producers. Some key aspects of our successes:

  • We tried to truly respect our producer partners’ time and they knew that, so they showed up for us when they were needed.
  • We made very clear single pagers for most things and kept communication as short and sweet as possible. See all of the attached work.
  • We elevated the producers to their peers and to the public by showcasing them in our work.
  • 1+1 = 3 - partnerships really make a difference. We couldn’t be more grateful for the engagement and interest in our partners. In fact, they were also inspired to showcase this work in other ways - inviting the Soil Your Undies display to go on tour at the WSE markets conference and at Regenerate in Denver in 2022.

2023

  • Reviewing the 2022 successes, those all applied again this year.
  • Unfortunately, we were not able to give the WSARE survey at the DNRC, so we are not certain of the learning outcomes from the Montana Range Tour event specifically related to our session. However, the Montana Range Tour is a well attended and regarded event so this felt like a fantastic opportunity for this project to be shared and have a producer’s attention - bundling education with an already existing program seems like an efficient way to share about this work. During the session, people were interested, asked questions, responded, and got into the nitty gritty of our implementation of this work.
  • We also did not survey producers for the before and after for the Bee Girl Presentation. However, producers were incredibly engaged during the session, asked many questions, and seemed to gain more overall knowledge about pollinators and how their activities can affect pollinators.
  • As mentioned before, the Soil Your Undies campaign has gotten real legs and continues to have an impact beyond this project, which is clear from Chris’ note.
3 Farmers intend/plan to change their practice(s)

Education and Outreach Outcomes

Recommendations for education and outreach:

Respect Partners’ Time

We have strode to make engagements efficient and useful, wasting no one’s precious time. That has made engagement strong and trustworthy.

Utilize Existing Platforms

Continue leveraging existing events and workshops, such as the DNRC Montana Range Tour, to share project updates and findings. Bundling educational sessions with well-attended programs maximizes exposure and engagement among producers.

Feedback Mechanisms

While surveys were not conducted at the DNRC Montana Range Tour or the Bee Girl Organization session, consider implementing pre- and post-session surveys in future educational events. This will help gather quantitative data on participants' knowledge gain and perception changes regarding agricultural sustainability practices.

Engage Stakeholders

Continue fostering engagement with stakeholders by encouraging active participation during educational sessions. Utilize interactive elements such as Q&A sessions, discussions, and demonstrations to enhance understanding and address any queries or concerns.

Partnership Collaboration

Strengthen partnerships with organizations like the Bee Girl Organization and Western Sustainability Exchange (WSE) to enhance the project's outreach capabilities. Collaborate on joint initiatives, such as the Soil Your Undies Campaign, to amplify messaging and foster community engagement in sustainable agriculture initiatives.

Evaluate Impact

Implement mechanisms for ongoing evaluation and monitoring of the project's impact on stakeholders' understanding of agricultural sustainability. This may include conducting follow-up surveys, interviews, or focus group discussions to assess long-term behavioral changes and adoption of sustainable practices among producers.

5 Producers reported gaining knowledge, attitude, skills and/or awareness as a result of the project
Non-producer stakeholders reported changes in knowledge, attitudes, skills and/or awareness as a result of project outreach
35 General public
Key changes:
  • Seed spreading methods

  • Soil health awareness techniques

  • Fundamentals of soil health

  • Soil health impacts to rangeland

Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the view of the U.S. Department of Agriculture or SARE.